Recent Research on Cold War Studies - PowerPoint Presentation

Slide1

Recent Research on Cold War Studies

Dr

Eirini Karamouzi

Teaching History at post-16 and beyond Conference

Tuesday, 16 June 2015

Slide2

Cold War Studies

1) Why Study the Cold War?

2) Old and New Historiography

3) Five paradigms: Ideology; Politics and Economics; Technology and Arms Race; Culture and Propaganda; Human Rights;

4) Primary Sources

5) Questions

Slide3

Why Study the Cold War?

25 years after the end of the Cold war, we stand a precise moment when scholarship and sources are coming together

What

impact did the Cold War have? Did the Cold War define the post war period?

What was the Cold War? Is there a definitive history of the Cold War

?

Historisation

of the Cold War

25

th

anniversary and talk about a new Cold War

(Edward

Lucas) has

galvanized

the literature: more emphasis on the World that the Cold War

made

GOAL is to offer out students factual grounding and conceptual apparatus necessary to understand the contemporary world

Slide4

The Old Historiography

Orthodox

: Those who blamed Soviet aggression

(Arthur Schlesinger)

Revisionist

: Those who blamed US expansionism

(William

Appleman

Williams)

Post-Revisionist

(or Realist): Those who focus on concepts of national interest

; no assignment of blame

(John Lewis Gaddis I)

Neo-Orthodox

: Those who return to Stalin’s culpability

(Gaddis II, of

We Now Know

)

Slide5

The New Historiography: Multi-archival, multipolar (analytical frameworks), multilevel (crossroads of national, transnational and global perspectives)

Material factors

vs.

ideal concepts

‘Young’ Gaddis vs. Westad

Authoritarian

rule vs.

US global power

‘Late’ Gaddis vs. Anders

Stephanson

Europe

vs. the

Third World

Federico Romero vs. Michael Latham

Slide6

Major Publications

Cambridge History of the Cold War :3 volumes

The Routledge History of the Cold War

Two journals dedicated on the Cold War:

Cold War History, LSE:

http://www.tandfonline.com/toc/fcwh20/

current

 

Journal

of Cold War Studies, Harvard:

http://www.mitpressjournals.org/loi/jcws

Slide7

What is new about Cold War history in the last decade?

the

pervasiveness of the Cold War has often been used as an argument for studying it on its own terms; the bipolar system and its dynamics dominated all the nooks and crannies of the societies involves. But its very pervasiveness means that it was also permeable and subject to a myriad of influences and transformative trends

.

Slide8

The only dangerous form of observation is the idea that the part being observed is the only constituent part of the whole

Odd Arne Westad (LSE): proponent of intellectual and methodological pluralism

Slide9

New Cold War History

BUT with such a pluralistic approach: how do we untangle the Cold from all the other strands of 20

th

century history; what was distinctive about this period? Otherwise we

may dilute

its importance and

obscure

the centrality of many other factors both in the domestic and international realms

;decentring the field from diplomatic and military realm Cold War risks of losing its War character

One or many Cold War Histories?

Cold War affected different groups in a multiplicity of ways, based on location and temporality;

Slide10

New Cold War History

Also do we need to ‘take off the Cold War lenses” especially in the case of the Third World or even postwar

Europe

?

Major theme the importance of a

Global Cold War:

major advanced on Latin America studies, Africa, Southeast Asia

A focus on Europe: Walter

LaFeber

observed in his classic America, Russia and the Cold War ‘He controls all of Europe is well on his way towards controlling the whole world’. HOWEVER instead of an object of superpower politics, more importance attached to European actors in transforming the international arena

Slide11

Federico Romero

Cold

War Historiography at the Crossroads, Cold War History, 14:4 (2014), 685-702

How is the Cold War understood in an expanding and

diversifying historiographical

field? Conceptual precision and specificity seem to be

giving way

to a looser understanding of the Cold War as an era that

encompassed different

although interconnected conflicts and transformations. Some

scholars ask for specificity and consistency while current centrifugal trends point to multiple approaches and centres

of interest. Diversity is galvanising the field, but historians need to (re)define their object of inquiry and strive for at least a minimum of conceptual clarity. In particular, we should aim at a broad cultural understanding of the Cold War, contextualise it in larger processes of historical change

without confusing the two dimensions, and reassess relations between Europe and other Cold War contexts.

Slide12

A. Ideology as a Modernization Project

Engerman: Russia’s 1917 October revolutions triggered confrontation between USA and SU: Became global in the 40s

A battle of ideas: American liberalism

vs

Soviet Communism

Both ideologies progressive, universalistic and deterministic/

messianistic

; both presented as projects on modernity seeking to supplant moribund European traditions

Slide13

B. Politics

and Economics

ECSC, 1950

Treaty of Rome (EEC), 1957

NATO, 1949

Slide14

Politics and Economics

Cold War and European Integration:

interaction

evolution

of the Cold War and the gradual development of

today’s European

Union (EU) was so intimate as to make it vital for historians

to break

down the barriers between the two fields

.

Early EEC; Maastricht/German Unification; enlargementsFor example, geopolitical Cold War reasons explain Greek entry to the EEC:

Slide15

C

. Technology

and Arms Race

Slide16

Technology and Arms Race

Nuclear weapons essential about the cold war, distinguishes it fundamentally from other conflicts. A Cold War without nuclear weapons seems unthinkable

BUT Fear of nuclear annihilation made the Cold War ‘over the long pull’: defeat capitalism

or

communism by means of peaceful competition: culture- technological innovation, consumer satisfaction

Slide17

Technology

and Arms Race

Westad: Technology was the epitome of the two modernist USA and Soviet ideologies and the systems they represented:

attempts at simplifying and conquering a complex world

How did technology contribute to the many weapons with which the Cold War was fought

?

Crucial areas of technology that were opened up though defence related funding include navigation systems, space exploration, and even genetics

MOST IMPORTANT: Funding in electronics and communications- the most important areas of technology that contributed to global changes and the way the conflict

ended

Reynolds: the technologies that have shaped the late 20

th

c, though derived from CW science, are emphatically the products of capitalism , not communism ( computer, transistors)

Slide18

C. Cultural and Propaganda

Slide19

C. Cultural and Propaganda

Despite two superpower domination: the implementation of cultural policies neither monolithic nor uniformly successful. local factor important; a process of cultural adaptation and rejection on both sides of the Iron Curtain

Cold War privileged Cultural relations in an unprecedented degree:

The repressive side of cold war culture, although significant, should not obscure how the Cold War also helped secure progressive and inclusive reforms.

Importance of popular culture; but bear in mind the cultural version of Cold War triumphalism in

historiography: Americanization:

Mainly used for the period after 1945-USA by virtue of technological-military-industrial prowess and Cold War dynamics abandon isolationism, engage in western Europe reconstruction

Slide20

D. Human Rights

Akira

Iriye

: The Human Rights Revolution (Oxford, 2012)

Since 1945, the human rights have been defined and redefined according to political needs, moral imperatives, and local contexts’.

Role of Human Rights in ending the Cold war: Snyder and Thomas show how the ‘Helsinki process’ facilitated the rise of organized dissent in Eastern Europe and pressures for human rights reforms in the Soviet Union; NOT containment won the Cold War BUT efforts of activists, lawyers, minority-right advocates across the borders that set the stage for the political earthquakes that followed.

Slide21

Primary Resources

Hanhimanki

/Westad: The

Cold War: A History in Documents and Eyewitness

Accounts ( Oxford University Press, 2013)

Judge, Edward & Langdon, John (eds.)

,

The Cold War: A Global History with Documents

, Pearson,

2010

Jane Degras, Soviet Documents on Foreign Policy, Oxford University press, Royal Institute of International Affairs, 1953

Slide22

Primary Sources

a) The National Archives: Cabinet Papers, 1915-1986

http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/cabinetpapers/

b

) Foreign Relations of the United

States ( NOW all digitalised)

The

Foreign Relations of the United States

(FRUS) series presents the official documentary historical record of major U.S. foreign policy decisions and significant diplomatic

activity

https://history.state.gov/

historicaldocumentsc) The US Presidential Libraries hold a wealth of documents  

Slide23

Primary Sources

d) Wilson Center, Digital Archive

The Digital Archive contains once-secret documents from governments ( and especially the Soviet Union) all across the globe, uncovering new sources and providing fresh insights into the history of international relations and diplomacy. It collects the research of two Wilson Center projects which focus on the interrelated histories of the

Cold War

, and

Nuclear Proliferation

. The third link points to publications based on these declassified documents

http://digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/theme/cold-war-history

http://digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/theme/nuclear-history

http://www.wilsoncenter.org/program-publications/Cold%20War%20International%20History%20Project

Slide24

Primary S

ources

CVCE

: The research infrastructure on European

Integration

http

://www.cvce.eu/en/hom

Kings College London: Oral History Witness Seminars:

http://www.kcl.ac.uk/sspp/departments/icbh/witness/OnlineArchive.aspx

 

British Cartoon Archives holds collections by over three hundred cartoonistshttp://www.cartoons.ac.uk/collections-bca

Slide25

Reviews

If you are interested in reviews of major works on Cold War or roundtables, the h-diplo is the best sources which is part of the h- net:

H-Net Reviews in the Humanities and Social

Sciences

an online scholarly review resource

.

https://networks.h-net.org/h-

diplo

Slide26

Questions?

Thank you