GOODYEAR Lady Justice Hallett - PowerPoint Presentation

Slide1

GOODYEAR

Lady Justice Hallett DBE and Dame Linda Dobbs DBE

SENTENCE INDICATIONS

GOODYEAR

Goodyear [2005] 2 Cr App R 20, (para 53) establishes:

that a judge,

if asked

, is entitled to give an indication as to the likely sentence. This is ordinarily confined to indicating the maximum sentence s/he would pass if the defendant were to plead guilty at the time the indication is sought.

The

Basic

Principle

is

to safeguard against creation or

appearance

of judicial pressure on

D.

See

: St Lucia CPR Part 11.4

.

AUTHORITY

DPP v Elvis Richardson ECSC Crim. – Claim. No. SKBHCR 2013/0030: Setting out the general approach to Sentence Indications in R v Goodyear:

“Defendant may seek an indication from the court what is the maximum sentence to be imposed if he were to plead guilty. Such an indication must be given in open court and in the presence of the defendant.”

GENERAL RULES

The process is started by the defence advocate/defendant.In an appropriate case the judge may remind defence counsel of the right to seek an advance indication.

The advocate should have written instructions from the defendant.

It should be done at the earliest opportunity.

WARNINGS

An indication should not be sought while there is any uncertainty

about acceptable plea or factual basis of sentencing.

Judge must have access to all evidence relied on by P including D’s antecedents and victim impact statements

.

The judge may ask for more information/reserve position e.g. where reports are expected

.

Where appropriate must be written agreed basis of plea; if not, judge should refuse to give indication

.

WARNINGS (Contd.)

Where appropriate must be written agreed basis of plea; if not, judge should refuse to give indication.The judge may give an indication of the maximum sentence he would impose in the event of a plea of guilty at that stage.

Indications should not be given on alternate bases e.g. on conviction rather than plea.

An indication once given, is binding on the judge and any other judge who takes over the case (save exceptionally)

WARNINGS (Contd.)

Judge should ensure D understands only plead if guilty and consequence of indication

If D does not plead guilty within reasonable time after indication given, it ceases to have effect: ( R v. Patel [2009] 2 Cr App R 20).

Until D pleads guilty no reference to indication should be made by press.

An unrepresented D may seek indication. Judges/prosecutors should be wary of informing unrepresented D for fear of putting under undue pressure.

WARNINGS (Contd.)

Hearings should normally be in open court; there must be proper record of proceedings with D present, preferably both sides with legal representation.Judges should not enter into negotiations or become involved in discussions which link the acceptable plea to likely sentence to be imposed.

Deviation from ground rules can cause problems: R v

Omole

2011 EWCA

Crim

1428.

REASONS TO REFUSE

Judge has discretion whether to give an indication and whether

to give

reasons. The

judge may

refuse

to give an

advance

indication, e.g

.:

where not in proper position to assess true culpability of D or differing levels of responsibility between

co-Ds;

where D is already under pressure/ particularly

vulnerable;

where D may not understand that he should not plead guilty unless he is

guilty;

or in a multi handed case, an indication to one D may put undue pressure on others.