The discipline that studies philosophical questions Perhaps a more helpful answer than it seems Because curiously you very likely already know how to spot such questions Lets try this as an exercise ID: 1037196
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "What is philosophy? Not-very-helpful ans..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
1. What is philosophy?Not-very-helpful answer: “The discipline that studies philosophical questions.”Perhaps a more helpful answer than it seems! Because – curiously – you very likely already know how to spot such questions. (Let’s try this as an exercise.)Philosophical questions tend to divide into • questions about reality and what it contains (Does God exist?); • questions about knowledge, opinion, and inquiry (How do we know we’re not in the Matrix?); • questions about values, norms, and conduct (What is the best way to live?). Answers to philosophical questions lie just under the surface of almost every aspect of life – but very often, those answers go unnoticed and unexamined.
2. Okay, so how do we study these questions?In a variety of ways, but at their heart is the use of argument.An argument, for us in the Philosophy department, is not a fight.Instead, it’s an attempt to lay out a viewpoint on some philosophical question by constructing a careful, logically coherent chain of reasoning in support of some answer to that question. It is not necessarily even an attempt to persuade.Your argument succeeds when it • renders your viewpoint intelligible, interesting, and plausible; • puts your audience in a position to critique that viewpoint, with an eye toward making it more sophisticated and even more interesting and plausible.
3. What’s it like being a student in a philosophy class?Right from the start, you’ll confront the challenge of answering philosophical questions for yourself. In philosophy, there’s no gap between studying and doing!To help you, we do our best to teach you • a certain way of writing; • a certain way of reading; • a certain way of discussing.(And yes, we teach you a lot of content as well. But skills are front and center.)The aim is to put you in a better and better position to spot and work out answers to philosophical questions, and to help others do so as well.By the way, those skills won’t just help you do philosophy! They are highly transferable.
4. What kind of culture do we try to create in our classes, and in our department?An atmosphere that is simultaneously highly welcoming and highly challenging.Welcoming, because philosophy belongs to all people in equal measure: • you all have the ability to do it;Challenging, because you will regularly confront good reasons to doubt things you believe. To help maintain this culture, we emphasize two “freedoms of speech”: • you all have the ability to get better at it; • you can all find it immensely rewarding to do so. • freedom from fear of reprisal for what you say; • freedom to speak and be heard.We also emphasize the importance of using these freedoms responsibly!
5. How welcoming is academic philosophy, in general?From this source: https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/11/diversity-in-philosophy-departments-introduction/“In its 2018 membership data, the American Philosophical Association reports 26% women among members responding to a demographic survey, 74% men, and 0.2% ‘something else’.”“In its membership data from 2018, the APA finds 80% of respondents identifying as White/Caucasian, compared to 60% in the general U.S. population.”This is a scandal. (With, in part, ugly historical origins.) In our department, one of our hopes is that we can make Harvard a place that undoes this scandal!