Professor Christopher Ullman Christian Life College 2 Everyone has a concept of what is truefalse Each person decides how important truth is to him Each of you know of ways to test a statement to see if it is true ID: 345248
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Epistemology" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Epistemology
Professor Christopher Ullman Christian Life CollegeSlide2
2
Everyone has a concept of what is true/false.
Each person decides how important truth is to him.
Each of you know of ways to test a statement to see if it is true.
These underlying presuppositions govern our thoughts, words, choices, and actions.Slide3
3
Consider these questions asked by thinking people
What is truth?
Can we even define truth?
Can we know truth?
Can we know truth with certainty?
Is truth merely opinion controlled by the dominant forces of our society?
How is it that so many people have so many different views of truth?
Is truth relative?
How can we say something is false if we have no way of determining what is true?Slide4
4
Some truth tests
Pragmatism
: truth is that which works. If something works, then it must be true.
Coherence
: there is an essential internal harmony of ideas. If something does not harmonize with the ideas that already cohere, it may not be true.
Correspondence
: truth corresponds to reality, identifies things as they actually are.
Slide5
5
Poststructuralism
is an intellectual movement that
completely rejects “binary oppositions” such as
true/false
right/wrong
good/evil, and
formulates views consistent with that rejection.
These dualistic concepts are believed to be rooted not in reality, but in modernistic philosophy that has “scripted” Western thought and culture. Slide6
6
Postmodernism
rejects the belief in universal absolute truth that transcends culture, time, and space by
redefining
it to say that truth is that which is
Created
Defined
Articulated by local (sub) communities.
Young people today are choosing a postmodern worldview over and against all other worldviews. Slide7
7
5 Ways to Know Something
Empirical: through sensed perceptions
Rational: through reason apart from the senses
Mystical: immediately, apart from the senses and reason
Pragmatical: by finding out what works
Authority: through a trusted source Slide8
8
Consider these questions asked by thinking people
Can we trust our senses?
What are the proper roles of reason and sense experience in knowledge?
Are our intuitions more dependable than our perceptions?
What is the relationship between faith and reason?
Is knowledge about God possible? If so, how?
Should we appeal to “mystical downloads” for spiritual knowledge?Slide9
9
Sources of Knowledge
1. Reason alone (excluding faith)
2. Faith alone (excluding reason)
Faith + Reason (God created people to think rationally)
Intuition
Sensed perceptions
AuthoritySlide10
10
A Tale of Two Systems
Continental philosophers taught that human knowledge comes not originally or even primarily from sense experience, but from reason. This is
rationalism
.
Rene Descartes: I think, therefore I am
Baruch Spinoza: the essence of each and every thing is a way that God causes himself to exist
Gottfried Leibniz: we have innate ideas, but all ideas that come from the senses are confused Slide11
11
A Tale of Two Systems
Some problems arose for the rationalists
The Theory of Ideas
“What you
know
when you perceive a brown table is the idea of a brown table.”
The key word here is
know.
The Problem of the External World
How do we know there’s a world
out there
?
The Problem of Other Minds
How do I know that
you
have a mind?Slide12
12
A Tale of Two Systems
The Rise and Fall of
Empiricism
Rejecting rationalism and innate ideas, three British philosophers come rushing into the room:
John Locke
: “The mind is a blank slate”
Sensed experience begins to fill it
Reflection arranges it
George Berkeley
: “The objects of human knowledge are ideas, not things”
You cannot know the carrot, but you can know the idea “carrot”Slide13
13
A Tale of Two Systems
David Hume
: all that is real consists of sensations, and these are unconnected to one another
What about things we do not personally experience? We cannot prove they are causally connected to anything else
So we accept out of custom or habit that one idea is caused by another
Knowledge boils down to non-rational operations of the soul
“We can stop our philosophical researches”Slide14
14
Ontological
The study of the nature of existence, or what it means “to be”:
Is basic reality found in matter or physical energy (the world we can sense), or spirit/spiritual energy?
Is reality lawful and orderly or chaotic?
Is reality fixed and stable or ever-changeable?
Is reality friendly, unfriendly, or neutral in regard to humanity?Slide15
15
Basic Question In Epistemology…
Is there truth independent of human experience?
A Priori knowledge
A Posteriori knowledgeSlide16
16
A Priori Knowledge:
Is independent of human awareness
Is true whether humans know/accept it or not
Exists prior to human experience
Traditional science has upheld the superiority of
a priori
knowledge as it represents the fixed and permanent world that is ‘uncontaminated’ by human knowers Slide17
17
A Posteriori Knowledge:
Requires human experience for verification of truth/knowledge
Modern philosophers claim
a posteriori
knowledge is superior, and that
a priori
knowledge does not even exist!Slide18
18
3 Basic Positions on the Objectivity of Knowledge:
Humans are
recipients
in the knowledge process.
Humans are
participants
in the knowledge process.
Humans exist as ‘pure objects’ who become
manufacturers of truth
rather than recipients or participantsSlide19
19
Sources of Knowledge:
Empirical Knowledge
:
composed of ideas formed from observable data
Sensory Knowledge
:
knowledge obtained through the Senses
Revelatory Knowledge
:
knowledge that is revealed through a transcendent or supernatural reality that breaks into the natural order/realitySlide20
20
Sources of Knowledge:
Authoritative Knowledge
:
accepted as truth because it comes from experts or is sanctioned over time by tradition
Rationalism/Reason:
emphasizes the power of thought & what the mind contributes to knowledge, the senses are not enough
Intuition:
knowledge that is not the result of conscious reasoning Slide21
21
Validity of Knowledge
Corresponding Theory
Coherence Theory
Pragmatic TheorySlide22
22
Validity of Knowledge - Tests of Truths
Correspondence Theory:
theory fits the data collected & analyzed through research
if the judgement corresponds with the facts it is true
method most often used by those working in the sciencesSlide23
23
Validity of Knowledge - Tests of Truths
Coherence Theory:
places its trust in the consistency of harmony of all ones’ judgments
a judgment is true if it is consistent with other judgments that have previously been accepted as true
there is an agreement on the boundaries, logic & phenomenon of the theory Slide24
24
Validity of Knowledge - Tests of Truths
Pragmatic Theory:
there is NO such thing as static or absolute truth
people know only their own experiences
the test of truth is in its utility, workability, or satisfactory consequencesSlide25
25
Epistemology
What is Epistemology?
“The theory or science of the method or grounds of knowledge.”
—Webster’s Dictionary
“The branch of philosophy that is concerned with the theory of knowledge. It is an inquiry into the nature and source of knowledge, the bounds of knowledge, and the justification of claims to knowledge.”
—FeinbergSlide26
26
“Today evangelical Christians stand at a greater distance from those with whom we communicate than we did just 20 years ago. At that time, even those who rejected Christianity were prepared to discuss whether the evidence for Christianity’s truth was adequate. Today, this is much less frequently the case. Before we can broach the question of whether the Christian gospel is true, we have to establish that such a thing as truth exists.” Slide27
27
A Conversation Between Protagoras and Socrates (4
th
Century B.C.)
Protagoras:
Truth is relative. It is only a matter of opinion.
Socrates:
You mean that truth is mere subjective opinion?
Protagoras:
Exactly. What is true for you is true for you, and what is true for me is true for me. Truth is subjective.
Socrates:
Do you really mean that? That my opinion is true by virtue of its being my opinion? Slide28
28
A Conversation Between Protagoras and Socrates (4
th
Century B.C.)
Protagoras:
Indeed I do.
Socrates:
My opinion is: Truth is absolute, not opinion, and that you, Mr. Protagoras, are absolutely in error. Since this is my opinion, then you must grant that it is true according to your philosophy.
Protagoras:
You are quite correct, Socrates. Slide29
29
Epistemology
Self-defeating statements:
“I cannot speak a word in English.”
“My wife has never been married.”
“We cannot know anything about God.”
“There is no such thing as truth.”
“Truth cannot be known.”Slide30
30
Epistemology
A short history of western civilization:
Three periods:
Premodern (400-1600 A.D.)
Modern (1600-1900 A.D.)
Postmodern (1960-present)Slide31
31
Epistemology
Premodern
Modern
Postmodern
400
1600
1960Slide32
PRE-MODERNISM: THE TIME AND WORLDVIEW WHEN
TRUTH INCLUDES
HEAVEN
GOD
EARTH
NATURE
OTHERS
SELF
THE TRUTH IS
UP THERE
AND
OUT THERE
32Slide33
33
PRE-MODERN WORLD
Embraced the objectivity of truth
The preference was for a
Platonist, or
neo-Platonist
notion
of reality
There is an
objective, or external realm
that is transcendent
“
Reality existed independently
of any individual apprehension of it”
For the Christian pre-moderns, this independently existing realm of transcendence was
the mind of God
. Erickson,
Evangelical Interpretation
, 100.
There was a belief in the referential understanding of language; that is, “language referred to something beyond itself,” Erickson,
EI
, 100. Slide34
34
PRE-MODERN WORLD
There was belief in the
“Correspondence Theory of Truth”
which asserted that “true ideas are those that accurately correspond to the state of affairs as it is
.”
In terms of hermeneutics, the pre-modern period accepted that “the
meaning of a text was . . . within that text
in a rather literal or straightforward fashion. . . . Hermeneutics was in this approach virtually equivalent to exegesis.”
The premodern understanding of
reality was teleological
. There was believed to be a purpose or purposes in the universe.”Slide35
MODERNISM: THE TIME AND WORLDVIEW WHEN
TRUTH INCLUDES
EARTH
INDIVIDUAL EXPERIENCE
REASON ONLY
THE TRUTH IS
OUT THERE
35Slide36
36
Transition
1900-1960
Epistemology
Modern
PostmodernSlide37
POST-MODERNISM: THE TIME AND WORLDVIEW WHEN
TRUTH INCLUDES
INDIVIDUALS GROUPED IN COMMUNITIES
THE TRUTH IS
ONLY IN HERE
37Slide38
38
POST-MODERNISM: Impact
Ideas have legs! It is impossible to understand postmodernism without noting its impact on our culture
What begins in the ethereal realm of the academy eventually will show up in popular culture
The Arts
Architecture
LiteratureSlide39
39
Truth and Tolerance
“In Postmodernism, there is no objective, universal truth; there is only the perspective of the group. . . . In postmodernism, all viewpoints, all lifestyles, all beliefs and behaviors are regarded as equally valid. . . . Tolerance has become so important that no exception is tolerated.”
–
Charles Colson, Slide40
40
Modernist Objections to Christianity
What about all the contradictions?
God is just a crutch. Religion was invented by man.
Jesus was just a man.
The Bible we have today is not the same as when it was written two thousand years ago.
I don’t believe in what I can’t see.
Evolution has proven Christianity to be wrong.Slide41
41
Modernist Objections to Christianity
The Bible is a myth full of fairy tales.
How did Noah get all of the animals on the Ark?
There are no such thing as miracles.
Do you really believe in the story of Adam and Eve?
Slide42
42
Postmodernist Objections
to Christianity
If God exists why is there evil?
The inquisition and the Crusades show that Christianity is oppressive.
Christianity is
a
way to God but not the
only
way.
Christianity is arrogant and exclusive.
How do you know that your Bible is better than other religious writings?
Why does God allow bad things to happen to good people? Slide43
43
Postmodernist Objections to Christianity
What about those who have never heard?
The church is full of hypocrites.
Why would God send anyone to Hell?
The God of the OT is cruel, partial, and unjust. Slide44
44
Modernism vs. Postmodernism:
Objections to Christianity
Modernist
Postmodernist
Facts
Rationality
Evidence
Fairness
Relationships
Emotion`Slide45
45
Modern View of Truth
Correspondence view of truth:
(1) Truth is an objective reality that exists whether someone believes it or not, (2) and (to the modernist) that objective reality has no definite basis.Slide46
46
Modern View of Truth
True statements are that which correspond to that objective reality.
False statements are those that do not correspond to that objective reality.Slide47
47
Modern View of Truth
Law of non-contradiction does apply
A
≠
-A at the same time and in the same relationship. Slide48
48
Modern View of Truth
What is an example?
Key Motto:
Man can and will know all truth.
Slide49
49
Postmodern View of Truth
Relativism:
what is right/wrong, true/false is determined by some group.
Subjectivism:
what is right/wrong, true/false is determined by each individual.
Pragmatism:
what is right/wrong, true/false is determined by what works.Slide50
50
Postmodern View of Truth
What is an example?
Law of non-contradiction does not apply
A = -A at the same time and in the same relationship.
No objective truth
Key Motto: The truth cannot be known.Slide51
51
Postmodern View of Truth
Religious Spin on Postmodern Epistemology
Universalism: All will make it to Heaven.
Pluralism: Many ways to God that are equally valid.
Syncretism: Assimilation of differing beliefs and practices.
Inclusivism: Salvation is only through Christ, but Christ may be revealed in other religions.Slide52
ENGAGING THOSE WITH POSTMODERN WORLDVIEWS
Acknowledge your culture-encoded version of Christianity
Affirm truth, love and compassion
Magnify the importance of faith perspectives
Show respect
Learn to listen to and tell postmodern stories
52Slide53
53
The Second Vatican Council: Roman
Catholicism slides into universalism
1962-1965
“But the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the creator. In the first place among these there are the Moslems, whom professing to hold the faith of Abraham, along with us adore the one and merciful god, who on the last day will judge mankind. Those also can attain salvation who through no fault of their own do not know the gospel of Christ or his church, yet sincerely seek god and, moved by grace, strive by their deeds to do his will as it is known to them through the dictates of conscience.”
Q. Why support mission evangelism any longer? Slide54
54
Christian View of Truth
What is the Christian view of truth?
Correspondence view of truth:
(1) Truth is an objective reality that exists whether someone believes it or not, (2) and that objective reality has God alone as its objective basis.Slide55
55
Christian View of Truth
The law of non-contradiction is a foundational necessity to all truth.
God cannot even violate this principle since it is a logical impossibility.