Peterson, A. (2010). Elizabeth Birr Moje on “Disciplinary Literacy

Download presentation
1 - 20

finestlaxr's Recent Documents

Felicitas Nowak-Lehmann D. / Inmaculada Mart
Felicitas Nowak-Lehmann D. / Inmaculada Mart

The MERCOSUR countries have a dominant net export position as far as agricultural trade is concerned. They dominate temperate export products (Vald

published 0K
Global Outlook on Forest Education (GOFE)
Global Outlook on Forest Education (GOFE)

WP Coordination Mika Rekola, University of Helsinki, mika.rekola@helsinki.fi , skype: mika_rekola ABSTRACT Forestry and forests are changing under several drivers such as globalization, climate change

published 0K
\r	\n	\r\n\r	\r\n		\n\n\n
\r \n \r\n\r \r\n  \n\n\n

 \n \r \n  \r  \n     \n \n \r$\r %&& ' (%& )&      ) * +,\n\n\n \n   -). -).  /\n\r  0

published 0K
THE UNIVERSITY OF IOWAStudent Organization Business Office 1 IMU | 319
THE UNIVERSITY OF IOWAStudent Organization Business Office 1 IMU | 319

Office Use Only Pickup Date:CardNumber: CREDIT CARD REQUEST FORM ** The Credit Card may not be used to pay for copies or printing ** PURCHASER INFORMATION Organization Organization Contact Contact E

published 0K
USDA Forest Service RMRS-P-53CD.  2008.
USDA Forest Service RMRS-P-53CD. 2008.

2OEHUGLQJ6XVDQ'DQG0RRUH0DUJDUHW0WHFKFRRUGV

published 0K
CANADIAN SOLAR INC.
CANADIAN SOLAR INC.

CS3W-425|430|435|440P MORE POWER 425 W ~ 440 W is committed to providing high quality solar products, solar system solutions and services to cus - tomers around the world. No. 1 module supplier for q

published 1K
BIME LIVE culminates its lineup with Foals and
BIME LIVE culminates its lineup with Foals and

Floating Points, the Goxo stage, and a camping option making it this autumn’s ultimate festival event • The festival adds 4 new acts — Foals, Floating Points, First Girl on the Moon, and R

published 0K
Download Section

Download - The PPT/PDF document "" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.






Document on Subject : "Peterson, A. (2010). Elizabeth Birr Moje on “Disciplinary Literacy"— Transcript:

1 Peterson, A. (2010). Elizabeth Birr Moj
Peterson, A. (2010). Elizabeth Birr Moje on “Disciplinary Literacy” and Reading Across the Content Areas. Accessed online at the National Writing Project on August 23, 2012. From: http://www.nwp.org/cs/public/print/resource/3041 Elizabeth Birr Moje on “Disciplinary Literacy” and Reading Across the Content Areas By: Art Peterson Date: January 13, 2010 Summary : Elizabeth Birr Moje makes the case for a disciplinary literacy that, rather than hewing to generic literacy “strategies,” focuses on the literacy skills required of practitioners in a content field. Moje will be the keynote speaker at the 2010 National Reading Initiativ e Conference. Elizabeth Birr Moje Podcast with Moje expounding on building disciplinary literacy instructional programs. What does it mean to be "smart" in a discipline? Does it mean knowing many facts? Does it mean understanding the discipline's important theoretical ideas? Does it mean being able to understand what questions the discipline is meant to address? Perhaps it means to be able to create knowledge that address es those very questions? And related to all of these possibilities, one might also ask what it means to read or write successfully within that discipline. For many educators these multiple and seemingly conflicting demands frame the essential questions a bout teaching and learning in their discipline. That's why the ideas of Elizabeth Birr Moje , who will deliver the keynote address at the NWP National Reading Initiative Conference, What's Next: Possibilities for Literacy and Content Area Learning , to be held on March 5 - 6 in New Orleans, deserve their attention. Moje, a professor of Literacy, Language and Culture in the Educational St udies Department at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, is urging educators to give attention to a focus she calls disciplinary literacy . The idea of disciplinary literacy is not new in itself. It has a rich tradition in the field of rhetoric among tho se interested in writing in the disciplines, and it seems to have grown fresh legs lately among those interested in adolescent literacy. Moje has been a leader among those arguing that thinking about disciplinary literacy will help us understand how to thi nk

2 more productively about the thinking a
more productively about the thinking and learning demands students face as they move through different content area classes that make up a typical high school day. It's Moje's belief that each discipline has its own literacy and that by stripping away the one - size - fits - all literacy "strategies" and engaging students in the way historians and scientists actually read and write, literacy learning will be central, no longer a side dish. Theory that Starts in the Classroom Moje's thinking about disciplinar y literacy has evolved out of years of experience as a high school teacher of history, biology, and drama, as well as out of her university work with school - based colleagues. Literacy learning will be central, no longer a side dish. "Many years of experi ence have shaped my thinking about disciplinary/adolescent literacy," she says. "During my years as a regular classroom teacher, I routinely found myself frustrated with my inability to get kids to engage in reading and writing disciplinary texts. At the s ame time, I witnessed them reading and writing all sorts of texts on their own time, or for dramatic productions that I directed, so I knew that they would or could read or write when they had a purpose or an interest." Moje's work as scholar and ethnogra pher supports these earlier understandings. She has spent more than eight years following children in the low - income, predominantly Latino southwest side of Detroit. Working with these young people, she found that they would devour books like the Harry Pot ter series, S.E. Hinton's The Outsiders , and Louis Sachar's Holes . However, confronted with most textbooks, their enthusiasm for reading shriveled. Alternatives to Textbooks Moje's solution: Put the textbook on the back burner. Textbooks, she believes, ar e a primary culprit in what Theodore Sizer has described as the "pedagogy of telling," providing content area teachers with a vehicle for covering vast amounts of information in short periods of time at the expense of the understanding that makes for true engagement. Moje would replace dependence on a single text with the tools that workers in a scholarly field actually use. Students of history, for instance, would have at their disposal a variety of source

3 documents that would help them construct
documents that would help them construct their ow n narrative and understandings. "Literacy thus becomes an essential aspect of disciplinary practice, rather than a set of strategies or tools brought into the disciplines to improve reading and writing of subject - matter texts," she wrote in Foregrounding the Disciplines in Secondary Literacy Teaching and Learning: A Call for Change , which appeared in the October 2008 issue of the Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy . (For more, listen to the accompanying podcast .) Related Articles on NWP.org  Multiple Texts: Multiple Opportunities for Teaching and Learning  Redefining Content - Area Literacy Teacher Education: Finding My Voic e through Collaboration Moje is realistic about the difficulties of such an approach. She tells the story from her own classroom experience. As a history teacher she had assigned her students to read one of The Federalist Papers . "The next day I asked, 'So what was Madison trying to say?' I was met by blank stares. The work was not accessible to my students." She knows that it will be the educator's job to find user - friendly materials and provide the scaffolding that will generate understanding. This task is somewhat easier now than it was when Moje was a classroom teacher. Now multiple text types and new media are at the fingertips of teachers and students. "Teachers can employ many different forms of representation to construct knowledge of one concept — d ifferent genres (e.g. narrative, expository, poetics, music), different symbol systems (e.g. print, graphs, tables), and different semiotic tools (image, sound, and performance)," she writes in Foregrounding the Disciplines in Secondary Teaching and Learni ng . "Each of these forms — now readily available through digital venues — can support the construction of knowledge necessary to access the abstract print text of the disciplines." Linking Learning and Life For any of this to work, however, Moje insists on ano ther principle that has been at the forefront of her work for many years. Learning must be linked to everyday life. She provides an example in which she and her colleagues asked middle school students to analyze data from a hypothetical experiment designed to te

4 st a mother's advice that two young wome
st a mother's advice that two young women wash their hands for at least 15 seconds to reduce bacteria growth. "In their conclusions we asked students to both write a scientific claim based on the data and write what they would tell their mothers abo ut the experiment. As a literacy activity, students had to read data from charts and then make their claims. One student drew this (uncorrected) conclusion: 'They should tell there mom that she was right and they were wrong and they should of believed her in the first place 'cause mama knows best.'" These students were acting as scientists, but in the context of a familiar experience. Moje understands that the road to disciplinary literacy is fraught with roadblocks and uncertainties. For example, "What op portunities do teacher education and inservice professional development provide teachers to learn about the discursive basis of their subject matter? How many disciplinary teachers have a deep understanding of the knowledge - producing practices of their dis cipline?" To bring about these changes will require "the involvement of teacher educators, school administrators, teachers, researchers, national policymakers, and the young people themselves." So what can the classroom teachers do now to nudge along the changes Moje is advocating? "One simple step is to use text — as opposed to textbooks — more and to engage students in text - based discussion, regardless of the discipline. Teachers can model how to look back to texts and draw from ideas in the text to make ar guments and require students to use writing to augment those text - based discussions. These discussions can be bolstered if kids are encouraged to write their opinions and the author's views or perspective before discussing." A lot of what Moje is attempti ng to accomplish involves changing the face of teacher education. "We are trying to innovate teacher education so that preservice teachers can both learn about the nature of language and literacy in their disciplines and how to challenge notions of the dis cipline as something that exists apart from human invention. We want to really shake up the usual practice of field - based learning." About the Author Art Peterson is a senior editor with the National Writing Projec