how to monitor a complex problem Gero Carletto Development Research Group The World Bank What we can all agree on Multidimensional concept Need suite of indicators Proliferation of indicators ID: 1048297
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Comments on … Food Insecurity:" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
1. Comments on …Food Insecurity: how to monitor a complex problemGero CarlettoDevelopment Research GroupThe World Bank
2. What we can all agree on …Multi-dimensional conceptNeed suite of indicatorsProliferation of indicatorsWhite noiseToo few indicators at right periodicity and for enough countries
3. What we still need to agree on …Which concept/dimensions?Which indicators?Aggregation into composite indexPreference elicitationWhat can we learn from the welfare debate?The FI “dashboard”By age group
4. What is neededStrong mandate and well-defined institutional frameworkConsultative process, with clear responsibility structureLearn from previous effortsBuild on existing strategic frameworksData platformGlobal vs. country-levelMonitoring vs. policy/evaluationHousehold surveys vs. resident-based vs. satellite-basedQuantitative vs. qualitativeStand-alone vs. piggybackingReal-time vs. AnytimeStatic vs. dynamicEffective dissemination strategyFAO platform?
5. Institutional frameworkThe players: the more, the merrier?International organizationsIn-country The forumThe championThe mandateThe incentive mechanismsThe enforcement rules
6. Data Platform: Household Surveys Food expFood consumptionFood FrequencyDietary DiversityAnthroQualitativeHBS/IESLSMS/IHSDHSMICSCFSVA…
7. In conclusion …Need to agree on core indicators, jointlyNon-core, up to countries/institutionsCFS, NAS, …Need to streamline collection of core indicators in existing household survey systemsNeed global mandate, need country buy-inLarge countriesIntegrate into existing frameworksNSDS, Global Strategy, UNSC, ....Harmonization is possible Short-term vs. medium-term goalsEnabling institutions for more coherent FS dataEstablish Household Survey Group (UNSC?)MethodologyData collection