BEHIND CLOSED DOORS What is Domestic Violence? - PowerPoint Presentation

Slide1

BEHIND CLOSED DOORS

Slide2

What is Domestic Violence?

NYS Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence defines DV as:

A

pattern

of coercive tactics

, which can include

physical, psychological, sexual, economic and emotional abuse

perpetrated by one person against an adult intimate partner with the goal of establishing and maintaining

power and control

over the victim.

Slide3

What does that really mean?

Focus is on “

pattern of coercive tactics

” and “

power and control.

”

Differs

from

high conflict

relationships

Note the different types of IPV—it’s

not just physical!

In other words, abuse is any behavior that seeks to deprive the victim of independence and respect that the abuser demands for himself in the relationship.

Slide4

Types of Abuse

We often think of physical abuse when thinking of DV.

Other types of abuse include:

Sexual

Non-physical

Financial

Emotional

Psychological

Victims have told us that these other forms of abuse can be much more damaging than physical violence.

Slide5

Physical Abuse

Strangling

, punching, kicking, biting, shaking, hitting, whipping, shoving;

Pushing, hair pulling, arm twisting, scratching

Hitting head against wall, burning.

Attacking with a weapon, or other item, such as a chair, table, cord, lamp, etc.

Forcing alcohol or other drug use.

Slide6

Harm without violence

Physical

harm

can be caused without physical

violence

. . .

Refusing to practice safe sex; knowingly transmitting STDs, HIV or other diseases;

Forcing unsafe living conditions;

Dangerous driving;

Denying food, sleep, medication, health care, mobility aids;

Revealing information to others.

Slide7

Sexual Abuse

Forcing unwanted or unprotected sex

Objectification

Not taking

‘

no

’

for an answer

Criticizing performance or desirability

Jealousy, obsessiveness, accusations of infidelity

Forcing sex with others

Unwanted or unknown filming of a sexual act

Revenge porn

Sextortion

Slide8

Internet Crime

Online predators are increasing drastically with expansion of social networking sites and availability and access to technology.

Children are particularly vulnerable to sexual predators, sexual offenses, and cyberbullying.

Predators use social networking sites to gain insights into victim’s habits and likes.

Explicit sexual graphics, pornography and violence is easily accessible (YouTube, online gaming).

Slide9

Financial Abuse

Fostering financial dependency

Controlling money & financial info

Withholding money

Hindering partner

’

s work or school

Making partner hand over paychecks

Financial exploitation

Making partner commit welfare fraud or other unlawful acts

Getting into debt in partner

’

s name

Theft

Slide10

Emotional/Verbal Abuse

Emotional abuse is

speech and/or behavior

that’s derogating, controlling, punishing, or manipulative.

Erodes a person’s self-esteem, self-worth, independence and makes them feel they are nothing without the abuser.

Includes verbal abuse tactics: Opposing, Blocking, Discounting/Belittling; Undermining/Interrupting; Denying/Gaslighting

Slide11

Examples of Emotional Abuse

Opposing:

The abuser will argue against anything you say, challenging your perceptions, opinions, and thoughts.

Blocking:

This is another tactic used to abort conversation. The abuser may switch topics, accuse you, or use words that in effect say, “Shut Up.”

Discounting & Belittling:

This is verbal abuse that minimizes or trivializes your feelings, thoughts, or experiences. It’s a way of saying that your feelings don’t matter or are wrong.

Undermining & Interrupting:

These words are meant to undermine your self-esteem and confidence, such as, “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”

Slide12

Examples of Emotional Abuse (cont’d)

Denying:

An abuser may deny that agreements or promises were made or that a conversation or other events took place, including prior abuse. The abuser instead may express affection or make declarations of love and caring. This manipulative behavior leads the victim to gradually doubt her/his own memory, perceptions, and experience.

You may have heard the term “gaslighting” to describe this type of extreme, persistent behavior. The term was derived from the Ingrid Bergman movie,

Gaslight

. In that movie, a husband used denial in a plot to make his wife believe she was losing her grip on reality.

Slide13

Psychological Abuse

Intimidation/infliction of mental anguish; scary behavior intended to frighten victim.

Involves using tactics to make the victim appear –or even feel—unstable:

Threatening to kill victim, children, and/or self

Hurting animals or threatening to do so

Threats, blackmail

Stalking

(can include seemingly innocuous gestures like sending notes and flowers), menacing, harassing

Throwing things; destroying things partner values

*Victims say that psychological and emotional abuse can be far more damaging than the physical assault

.

Slide14

Psychological Abuse (cont’d)

Manipulation

Lying, making & breaking promises

Isolation from family & friends

Restrictions

Controlling partner

’

s every move

Exploiting vulnerabilities

Homophobic control

Control through disability

Slide15

Tactics Used to Gain Power and Control

Abuse is a choice. It’s not about

losing

control --it’s about doing whatever it takes to

gain

and

maintain

power and control.

Some tactics include:

Isolation

Intimidation

Minimizing/denying/blaming

Using children or pets

Coercion and threats

Slide16

Duluth Power and Control Wheel

Slide17

Dynamics of DV

Domestic violence is a complex dynamic that occurs on a continuum.

The

Cycle of Violence Theory

was developed in 1979 by Dr. Lenore Walker and describes the phases an abusive relationship moves through in the lead up to a violent event and its follow-up.

The cycle of violence looks at the

repetitive nature

of perpetrator’s actions that

hinder a victim’s ability to leave

an abusive relationship.

The

cycle of violence theory

 provides an insight into this by illustrating how

the behavior of a perpetrator can change very dramatically, making it difficult for the woman to leave.

Women who have experienced violence may recognize this cycle.

Slide18

Slide19

Why Do Victims Stay or

Go Back to

Abusive Partners?

Slide20

Why Do Victims Stay or Go Back to Abusive Partners?

Children

Fear

Culture/family influence/Religious beliefs

Isolation

Safety

Self-blame, embarrassment, guilt

Belief that abuser will change

Economic dependency

Unsure of where to go for help

Love

Slide21

Who is affected by DV

?

Statistics vary, but National Coalition Against Domestic Violence reports show

1 in 4 women and 1 in 9 men

have experienced severe intimate partner physical violence, intimate partner contact sexual violence, and/or intimate partner stalking with impacts such as injury, fearfulness, post-traumatic stress disorder, and contraction of sexually transmitted diseases.

1 in 3 women and 1 in 4 men have experience “some form” of IPV.

44% of Lesbians and 61% of bisexual women have experienced rape, physical violence or stalking by an intimate partner.

26% of gay men and 37% of bisexual men have experienced rape, physical violence or stalking by an intimate partner.

The 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey found 47% of transgender people are sexually assaulted at some time during their lifetime.

Slide22

What does a DV victim look like?

Slide23

What does a DV victim look like?

DV knows no boundaries. It does not discriminate!

The majority of DV victims are women; however...

DV affects every race and ethnicity, educational background, religious background, gender, sexual orientation, socio-economic level…and occurs in every city, state and country around the world

.

Slide24

You never know what goes on behind closed doors…

Slide25

DV Fatalities in Westchester County

In 2018, Richard

DeLucia

, 71, shot and killed his wife,

Ann

DeLucia

, 70, with a licensed .38 caliber handgun before turning the gun on himself. Police later found a note in which the husband stated he was distraught over his wife’s medical issues and wanted to end her suffering.

Also in 2018, Cynthia Arce, 29, killed her two year old daughter

Gabriella Boyd

and then attempted to kill herself. Arce and Gabriella’s father were in the middle of a custody dispute when Arce murdered their daughter. Arce also attacked and slashed two police officers who responded to a 911 call at the house. She pled guilty to 2

nd

degree Murder and Attempted Aggravated Assault and is scheduled to be sentenced on October 31, 2019 to 25 years to life.

In 2017, Steven

Dym

, 56, shot and killed his wife

Loretta

Dym

,

50, and their daughter

Caroline

with a shotgun before turning the gun on himself. Loretta

Dym

had returned from California the night before, after dropping their son off at college. Their house had recently been sold and indications of financial problems/fraud involving Steven

Dym

were uncovered after the murders.

Slide26

DV Fatalities in Westchester (cont’d)

In 2017, 7 year old

Gabrielle White

was suffocated to death by her father a day after he and Gabrielle’s mother signed papers to finalize their divorce. Neil White, 47, was found with slash marks on his arms when police arrived at the scene. Neil White stated that he did not want his daughter to grow up with divorced parents.

In 2016,

Dr. Robin Goldman,

58,

was stabbed by her husband, 61 year old Julius Reich, 21 times while showering; the couple was in the midst of a divorce at the time.

In 2015, retired White Plains police officer Glen

Hochman

, 52, killed two of his daughters and his dogs before killing himself. His wife, who was out of town with their third daughter when the murders took place, reportedly had recently told the perpetrator that she wanted to end the marriage.

In 2011,

Amy Friedlander

was bludgeoned to death by her husband. He then shot and killed both of their children with a 12-gauge shotgun before turning the gun on himself. They, too, were in the middle of a bitter divorce when the perpetrator killed the entire family.

Slide27

What are we doing here in WC to address risk of lethality?

In 2017, the Office for Women, along with 5 PDs in Northern Westchester, Hope’s Door, PWJC, Probation and the DA’s Office, was awarded a 2 year NYS grant to implement a pilot program to provide enhanced responses in domestic violence cases exhibiting high risk for lethality.

Slide28

What are we doing here in WC to address risk of lethality?

A victim’s safety should not depend on where they live.

We are rolling out a countywide Lethality Assessment program to provide enhanced responses to all high risk DV cases.

Team consists of law enforcement, DA’s Office, County agencies (Probation, OFW, DCMH, DSS), local NFPs, Westchester Medical Center.

Slide29

Danger Assessment Tool

The

Danger Assessment Tool (DA)

is an evidence-based model developed in 1985 by

Dr. Jacquelyn Campbell

, Associate Dean at Johns Hopkins University, to help victims and advocates better understand the threats to victims’ safety.

It is a questionnaire designed to assess a woman's risk of being killed by an abusive partner. It is also designed to give women more of a role in planning their own safety, and to give them more personalized help.

Many advocates are trained and certified in using this instrument and incorporate it as part of their safety planning.

Police officers/first responders also trained in using DA tool as part of Lethality Assessment Program.

Slide30

Danger/Lethality Assessment—“the 5 S’s”

Separation-

ALWAYS the most dangerous time

Strangulation

Stalking

Suicide-

includes threats and/or attempts to kill himself, you and/or children.

***********************

SES

: change in socio-economic status

Slide31

Warning Signs of Abuse

Does your intimate partner…

Isolate you from family and friends?

Put you down?

Try to control what you do/say/wear?

Deny you access to money or financial assets?

Blame YOU for everything that’s wrong in the relationship?

Accuse you over and over of being unfaithful?

Force you into having sex when or in ways you don’t want?

Threaten to harm you, the children, your family, your pets…or himself?

Shove, hit, kick, bite, slap, punch, pull your hair?

Slide32

What does DV look like to an Outsider?

Signs/behaviors that MAY indicate that someone you know is experiencing DV, include:

Visible physical injuries;

Stress-related illnesses;

Marital/family problems;

Alcohol or other addictions;

Depression, anxiety, suicidal thoughts or attempts;

Leaving work early/arriving early; absenteeism/lateness;

Strict adherence to start and end times for work or social events;

Inability to go out with friends;

Frequently cancelling plans;

Constant “checking in” with partner;

Having to get approval on every purchase;

Abrupt changes in personality;

Fatigue, sullenness.

Slide33

Ways to Support Victims

Ask: “How can I help you?”

Support their right to make their own decisions. Understand that risks are attached to every decision they make!

They know their abuser best

.

Reassure them that it’s not their fault, that they are not alone, and that no one deserves to be treated this way.

Express concern for their safety and that of their children.

Connect them to local resources (counseling, legal, housing, immigration,

safety planning

).

Slide34

What to Do and Not to Do

DO

offer support and concern.

DO

validate their experience; assure them they are not to blame and are not alone.

DO

refer them to a DV service provider for safety planning and other services.

DON’T

suggest that they leave their partner!

DON’T

suggest they immediately retain a lawyer.

DON’T

give advice.

Slide35

Key Take Aways

ANYONE can be a victim of DV. Anyone can be an abuser.

DV is not just physical; psychological/emotional abuse may be worse.

Express concern for victim’s safety and that of their children, and connect them to local resources –

do not give advice

!

Slide36

Resources

Westchester County Office for Women

: 995-5972

Refer to our website for a complete list of resources:

women.westchestergov.com

Westchester County Family Justice Center:

995-1880

Hope’s Door

: 747-0828

My Sister’s Place

: 683-1333

Pace Women’s Justice Center

: 287-0739

Legal Services of the Hudson Valley

: 949-1305

Slide37

Questions? Comments?

Darlene Reda

Office for Women

(914) 995-3100