Dr Takatsugu HYODO ISOTC 126WG 22 Expert JISC 612020WebISOTC12686 v2 Contents ISOTC 126 TOBACCO AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS Proposal from ISOTC 126 to IECTC 61 Liaison mode between ISO and IEC ID: 932498
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Liaison between IEC/TC 61 and ISO/TC 126" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Liaison between IEC/TC 61 and ISO/TC 126
Dr. Takatsugu HYODOISO/TC 126/WG 22 Expert (JISC)
61(2020Web/ISOTC126)86 v2
Slide2Contents
ISO/TC 126 “TOBACCO AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS”
Proposal from ISO/TC 126 to IEC/TC 61
Liaison mode between ISO and IEC
Basic concept on liaison between ISO and IEC
Overview of international standards development in ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61
Why is mode 4 suitable?
Slide3ISO/TC 126 “TOBACCO AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS”
Scope
Standardization of terminology and test methods for unmanufactured tobacco, all types of tobacco products, materials used for manufacturing tobacco products and tobacco smoke including environmental tobacco smoke aspects; specifications and questions of handling, storage, packaging and transport are included as appropriate.
Tobacco product means any product made or derived from tobacco that is intended for human use and products that are used in a manner similar to smoking or smokeless products.
Slide4ISO/TC 126 “TOBACCO AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS”
Slide5Gentle proposal from ISO/TC 126 to IEC/TC 61
As we got the information that the next plenary session of IEC/TC 61 is foreseen for September 2020/October 2020
we would highly appreciate if you could put the topic on the agenda to discuss as possible liaison with ISO/TC 126.
We personally see that at least
mode 4
for cooperation between ISO and IEC is necessary.
(email from chairman of ISO/TC 126 to chairman of IEO/TC 61 on July 17
th
, 2020)
Slide6Overview of liaison mode between ISO/IEC (B.4.2.2, ISO/IEC Directives, Part 1)
Mode
Working modes of cooperation
Mode
1
Informative relation
One organization is fully entrusted with a specific work area and keeps the other fully informed of all progress.
Mode 2
Contributive relation
One organization should take the lead of the work and the other should make written contributions on where considered appropriate during the progress of this work. This relation also includes the
exchange of full information.
Mode 3 . Subcontracting relation
One organization is fully entrusted with the realization of the work on an identified item, but due to specialization of the other, a part of the work is subcontracted and that part is prepared under the responsibility of the second organization. Necessary arrangements shall be made to guarantee the correct integration of the resulting subcontracted work into the main part of the
programme
. The enquiry and approval stages are handled by the organization being the main contractor for the standardization task.
Mode 4 .
Collaborative relation
One organization takes the lead in the activities, but the work sessions and meetings receive liaison
representatives from the other. Such liaison representatives should have the right to intervene in
the debate but have no right to vote. The full flow of information is oriented through this liaison.
Mode 5 .
Integrated liaison
Joint Working Groups and Joint Technical Committees ensure integrated meetings for handling
together the realization of standards under a principle of total equality of participation.
Joint Working Groups between technical committees of the two organizations shall operate in
accordance with 1.12.6.
Slide7Basic concept on liaison between ISO and IEC
The allocation of work between ISO and IEC is based on the agreed principle that all questions relating to the international standardization in the electrical and electronic engineering fields are reserved to IEC, the other fields being reserved to ISO (B.2 General considerations, ISO/IEC Directives, Part 1)
The work will go forward without overwrap or duplication of effort (1.16.1 Liaison between ISO and IEC, ISO/IEC Directives, Part 1)
Slide8Heated
Tobacco products
(HTP)
Electronic-cigarettes
(E-cig)
The other fields
ISO/TC 126/WG 22
Tobacco Heating system
ISO/NP 5501
ISO/PWI 5622
ISO/PWI 6080
ISO/TC 126/SC 3
Vape and
vapour
products
ISO/TC 126/SC
3/
WG 3
Analytical methods for the testing of emissions of vapour productsISO/NP 24197ISO/NP 24198ISO/NP 24199ISO/NP 24211ISO/PWI 24193(CEN/TS 17287)Electrical and electronic engineering fields IEC/TC 6161/5952/NP(JISC, Japan)IEC/TC 6161/5953/NP(ANSI, USA)
Overview of international standards development in ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61
Slide9Why mode 4 is suitable?
Avoid overwrap or duplication of work between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61
ISO 24193 “Requirements and test methods for electronic cigarette devices”
includes the electrical and electronic engineering fields.
Allocate the matter to one of the suitable organizations if necessary.
Harmonize standards between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61
e.g. Terminology, Analytical
condition (ex. puffing regime)
Enhance productivity
Not written communication but face to face communication can boost productivity of discussion because useful input can be obtained timely.
Slide10ISO/TC 126/WG 22
(HTP)
ISO/TC 126/
SC 3
(e-cig)
IEC/TC 61
Liaison representatives
Liaison representatives
Mode 4 Collaborative relation
One organization takes the lead in the activities
, but the work sessions and meetings receive liaison representatives from the other. Such liaison representatives should have the right to intervene in the debate but have no right to vote. The full flow of information is oriented through this liaison.
Why mode 4 is suitable?
Slide11Appendix
Slide12Overview of liaison mode between ISO/IEC (B.4.2.2, ISO/IEC Directives, Part 1)
Mode
Working modes of cooperation
Mode
1
Informative relation
One organization is fully entrusted with a specific work area and keeps the other fully informed of all progress.
Mode 2
Contributive relation
One organization should take the lead of the work and the other should make written contributions on where considered appropriate during the progress of this work. This relation also includes the
exchange of full information.
Mode 3 . Subcontracting relation
One organization is fully entrusted with the realization of the work on an identified item, but due to specialization of the other, a part of the work is subcontracted and that part is prepared under the responsibility of the second organization. Necessary arrangements shall be made to guarantee the correct integration of the resulting subcontracted work into the main part of the
programme
. The enquiry and approval stages are handled by the organization being the main contractor for the standardization task.
Mode 4 .
Collaborative relation
One organization takes the lead in the activities, but the work sessions and meetings receive liaison representatives from the other. Such liaison representatives should have the right to intervene in the debate but have no right to vote. The full flow of information is oriented through this liaison.Mode 5 .Integrated liaisonJoint Working Groups and Joint Technical Committees ensure integrated meetings for handling together the realization of standards under a principle of total equality of participation. Joint Working Groups between technical committees of the two organizations shall operate in accordance with 1.12.6.
Slide13Application of liaison mode to liaison between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61 (Mode 1)
ISO/TC 126/WG 22
(HTP)
ISO/TC 126/
SC 3
(e-cig)
IEC/TC 61
Exchange a
ll progress
Exchange a
ll progress
Mode 1 Informative relation
One organization is fully entrusted with a specific work area
and keeps the other fully informed of all progress.
Slide14Application of liaison mode to liaison between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61 (Mode 2)
ISO/TC 126/WG 22
(HTP)
ISO/TC 126/
SC 3
(e-cig)
IEC/TC 61
Make Written contributions
Exchange a
ll progress
Make written contributions
Exchange a
ll progress
Mode 2 Contributive relation
One organization should take the lead of the work
and the other should make written contributions on where considered appropriate during the progress of this work. This relation also includes the exchange of full information.
Slide15Application of liaison mode to liaison between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61 (Mode 3)
ISO/TC 126/WG 22
(HTP)
ISO/TC 126/
SC 3
(e-cig)
IEC/TC 61
A part of work subcontracted
Mode 3 Subcontracting relation
One organization is fully entrusted with the realization of the work on an identified item
, but due to specialization of the other, a part of the work is subcontracted and that part is prepared under the responsibility of the second organization.
Mode 3 Subcontracting relation
Necessary arrangements shall be made to guarantee the correct integration of the resulting subcontracted work into the main part of the
programme
. The enquiry and approval stages are handled by the organization being the main contractor for the standardization task.
Slide16Application of liaison mode to liaison between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61 (Mode 4)
ISO/TC 126/WG 22
(HTP)
ISO/TC 126/
SC 3
(e-cig)
IEC/TC 61
Liaison representatives
Liaison representatives
Mode 4 Collaborative relation
One organization takes the lead in the activities
, but the work sessions and meetings receive liaison representatives from the other. Such liaison representatives should have the right to intervene in the debate but have no right to vote. The full flow of information is oriented through this liaison.
Slide17Application of liaison mode to liaison between ISO/TC 126 and IEC/TC 61 (Mode 5)
ISO/TC 126/WG 22
(HTP)
ISO/TC 126/
SC 3
(e-cig)
IEC/TC 61
Mode 5 Integrated liaison
Joint Working Groups and Joint Technical Committees ensure integrated meetings for handling together
the realization of standards under a principle of total equality of participation.