Formalisation policies,informal resource sectors and thede-/re-centra - PDF document

Formalisation policies,informal resource sectors and thede-/re-centralisation of powerGeographies of inequality in Africa and AsiaSamuel J. SpiegelCenter for International Forestry ResearchDecember 2012 5%,8,/*2,-*&,$/'*/6'5%*5[6$J/-'RBCCN]BCDCS'Dc'O:'E*-"'-&163K'E$/&"-&"6'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'#$2,53'*/6'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)'2,"2,+$$6-',/'F/6$/"-,*'Db'O:D:'G$%8*2,-*&,$/',/'F/6$/"-,*_-'8,/,/)'-"5&$%'Db'O:B:'E$/&"Z&1*2,-,/)'8,/"%*2'%")12*&,$/'6"&#x -1 ;*&"-',/'F/6$/"-,*O:`:'($"%/,/)'8,/"%*2-',/'&+"'^6"5"/&%*2,-*&,$/_'"%*K'!"-5*2,/)')$"%/*/5"?'%,)+&-' .$%'"/&"%#%,-":_D'f"'7$&$_-'�$$['*%)1"6'&+*&'^5*#,&*2,-8'-155""6-',/'&+"'\"-&_'*/6'&+*&'#$$%"%'5$1/&%,"-'J"%"'.*,2,/)'&$'8,%%$%'&+"'-155"--"-'$.',/61-&%,*2,-"6'5$1/&%,"-'�"5*1-"'$.'&+"'.*,21%"'&$' 7V**-&*6'*/6'E$1-,/-?'BCCTS:'M"/V*8,/-"/'%$'+.:'RBCCNS'-1))"-&'&+*&'815+'$.'&+"'-5+$2*%-+,#'$/'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'$"%2$$[-'^%,-[-',/+"%"/&',/'&+"'.$%8*2,h*&,$/'#%$5"--',&-"2._'*/6'&+"'^#%&#x -2 ;$2"8'$.'.$%8*2,h,/)'"Z,-&,/)',/"01*2,&,"-_'R#:'cS:'4')%$J,/)'&#x -2 ;$63'$.'-"5&$%H-#"5,.,5'%"-"*%5+'6$518"/&-'+$J'#$$%"%'#$#12*&,$/-'$.'-8*22H-5*2"'#%$615"%-'+*"'&#x -1 ;""/'8*%),/*2,-"6'&#x -1 ;3'&+"'5$8#2"Z'%"),$/*2'*/6')2&#x -1 ;$*2',/-&,&1&,$/*2'#%$5"--"-'&+%$1)+'J+,5+'.$%8*2'%,)+&-'52*,8-'*%"'5$/&"-&"6?'+,)+2,)+&,/)'+$J'&+"'-$5,$H"5$/$8,5'&#x -1 ;"/".,&-'$.'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'*%"'1/""/23'6,-&%,&#x -2 ;1&"6',/'-$5,"&3'RE$1-,/-?'BCCTj'X*5$/*5+,"'*/6'i,2-$/?'BCDDj'W*%-*'%$'+.:?'BCDDj'7,")"2'*/6'a",)*?'BCCej'7V**-&*6'*/6'E$1-,/-?'BCCTj'P$128,/?'BCCTS:''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''D'l1$&,/)'P+*&5+"%',/'f3*2HE+*/6'RBCCb?'#:'NCS:' ,-"6'.$%8*2,-*&,$/' &,$/'*-'*'5%$--H-"5&$%'5+*22"/)"'&+*&'5*22-',/&$'01"-&,$/'&+"'812&,H-5*2*%'#$2,&,5-'$.')2$�*2'*/6'/*&,$/*2'"..$%&-'&$'5"/&%*2,-"'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'%"),8"-:'48$/)'$&+"%',8#2,5*&,$/-?',/'*/'"%*',/'J+,5+'%"-#$/-,�2"'/*&,$/*2')$"%/*/5"',-',/5%"*-,/)23'&#x 2 0;",/)'&$1&"6'*-'*'6""2$#8"/&'-$21&,$/'*&';/,&"6'k*&,$/-'R;kS'5$/."%"/5"-?'&+,-'-&163'-1))"-&-'&+*&'8$%"'5*%".12'*&&"/&,$/'-+$126'&#x 2 0;"'),"/'&$'#$--,&#x -2 ;,2,&,"-'.$%' '('*8+0"#$%&'(%)'"*B+C'*D6'*+*%##%)'E.(+%*2+F"#2.#.2/+8#'2&'G.+(,%-.(H+'\+,2"'&+"'^.$%8*2,-*&,$/_'6$5&%,/"']'&+"',6"*'&+*&',/.$%8*2'"5$/$8,"-'/""6"6'&$'�"'�%$1)+&',/&$'&+"'.$%8*2'-"5&$%'*/6'%")12*&"6']'�")*/'&$'*-5"/6'*-'*'#%,$%,&3'$/'&+"'*)"/6*'$.',/&"%/*&,$/*2'6""2$#8"/&'*)"/5,"-',/'&+"'DebC-'*/6'"*%23'DeTC-?'&+,-'6$5&%,/"'"8"%)"6',/,&,*223'&$'%".$%8'"5$/$8,5'-"5&$%-'-15+'*-'*)%,512&1%"'*/6'8*/1.*5&1%,/)?'J+$-"'2&#x 2 0;*$1%'#%$&#x 2 0;2"8-'+*6'&#x 2 0;""/'J,6"23'6,-51--"6'&#x 2 0;3'-5+$2*%-'*/6'6""2$#8"/&'*/*23-&-:c'M"2,",/)'&+"'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'$.'#%$#"%&3'%,)+&-'&$'&#x 2 0;"'*'J,/ b'9*8"-'G"%)1-$/'RBCCbS'"Z&"/6-'X,&5+"22_-'*%)18"/&-'J+,2"'*--"--,/)'#$-&H W2*&&"*1'RDeeNS'*%)1"-'&+*&'&+"'6$8,/*/&'.%*8"J$%['"8#2$3"6'�3'8*,/-&%"*8'"5$/$8,-&-'&$'1/6"%-&*/6'2*/6'&"/1%"'5+*22"/)"-',/'#$$%"%'5$1/&%,"-',-'^&+"'"21&,$/*%3'&+"$%3'$.'2*/6'%,)+&-_'R#:'BeS']'*'&+"$%3'&+*&'*--18"-'&+*&'-$5,"&,"-'"$2"'&$J*%6-'#%,*&"',/6,,61*2'$J/"%-+,#'$.'2*/6',/'*/'"01,&&#x 1 0;*2"'.*-+,$/'$"%'&,8"'*/6'&+*&'&+,-'"$21&,$/',-'*'/"5"--*%3'-&"#'.$%'6"2$#8"/&:'W2*&&"*1'5%,&,01"-'\$%26'M*/['#$2,5,"-'&+*&'*6+"%"'&$'&+,-'&+"$%3'*/6'*%)1"-'&+*&'^&+"%"',-'*')%"*&'%,-['&+*&'&+"'*6V16,5*&,$/I%"),-&%*&,$/'#%$5"--'J,22'&#x" -1;&#x 000;"'8*/,#12*&"6'&#x" -1;&#x 000;3'&+"'"2,&"'&$',&-'*6*/&*)"_'RDeeN?'#:'c`S:'b'X,&5+"22'J%,&"-',/'#*%&,512*%'$.'&+"',/"01*2,&,"-'$.'2*/6'%,)+&-'*501,-,&,$/?'-&*&,/)?'^P+"',%&1"-'$.'*'1/,"%-*2'%,)+&'$.' + F/'&+"'.,)1%"?'&+"'6,.."%"/&,*&"6'"5$/$8,5'2$),5-'$.'^"5$/$8,5')%$J&+_'*/6'^2,"2,+$$6-_'/""6'/$&'/"5"--*%,23'&#x -3 ;"'-""/'*-'5$/-&,&1&,"'$.'*')*#'&+*&',-'-3-&"8*&,5*223'8$%"'"/&%"/5+"6',/'&+"'$..,5,*2'6"5,-,$/H8*[,/)'#$2,&,5-'$.'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&-'5$8#*%"6'J,&+'2$5*2H2""2'6"5,-,$/H8*[,/):'i$J""%?'*'/18&#x 4 0;"%'$.'-&16,"-'%""*2'&+*&'/*&,$/*2'*1&+$%,&,"-'+*"')%*,&*&"6'&$J*%6-'%"-$1%5"'5*#&1%"'"..$%&-'""/'*.&"%'6"5"/&%*2,-*&,$/'#$2,5,"-'*%"'-1##$-"623'"/*5&"6?'-1&#x -1 ;"%&,/)'6"8$5%*&,5'$##$%&1/,&,"-'.$%')$"%/,/)'2,"2,+$$6-'*/6'"/,%$/8"/&-:'!,&#x 2 0;$&'%$'+.:'RBCCNS'6,-51--'+$J'^5"/&%*2')$/8"/&-',/'-,Z'5$1/&%,"-']'7"/")*2?';)*/6*?'k"#*2?'F/6$/"-,*?'M$2,,*?'*/6'k,5*%*)1*']'1-"'*'%,"&3'$.'-&%*&"),"-'&$'$&#x* -1;&#x 000;-&%15&'&+"'6"8$5%*&,5'6"5"/&%*2,h*&,$/'$.'%"-$1%5"'8*/*)"8"/&'*/6?'+"/5"?'%"&*,/'5"/&%*2'5$/&%$2_'R#:'DTNcS:'E"%1&&,'*/6'P*55$/,'RBCCTS'#%$,6"'.1%&+"%'",6"/5"'$.'+$J'5"/&%*2'-&*&"-'R":):',/'&+"'5*-"'$.' &%,5&'5*#*5,&3',--1"-'�1&'*2-$'#$J"%'63/*8,5-'%"2*&,/)'&$'�$&+'/*&,$/*2'*/6')2�$*2',/-&,&1&,$/*2'6"5,-,$/H8*[,/):'E4XWGF!=?'&+"'E$881/*2'4%"*-'X*/*)"8"/&'W%$)%*88"'.$%'F/6,)"/$1-'!"-$1%5"-?',-'*'#%$)%*88"'.$%'6"5"/&%*2,-"6'J,262,."'8*/*)"8"/&?'$/"'&+*&'$-&"/-,�23'J*-'6"-,)/"6'&$'"8#$J"%'!1%*2'f,-&%,5&'E$1/5,2-:'M*2,/&'*/6'X*-+,/3*'RBCCNS'*%)1"'&+*&'^J,&+6%*J*2'$.'$1&-,6"'*)"/5,"-'%"-#$/-,�2"'.$%'$"%-,)+&'*/6'*--,-&*/5"_'+*6'*'5$/-,6"%*&#x -2 ;2"',/.21"/5"'$/'&+"'.*,2"6'E4XWGF!='6"$21&,$/'8$6"2?'*-'6,6'.*,21%"'$.'2$5*2'2"*6"%-+,#'*/6'/*&,$/*2')$/*/5"'6"&"%,$%*&,$/'R#:'TCOS?'#%$6,/)'*'812&,H-5*2*%'*/*23-,-'&+*&',/,&"-'*&&"/&,$/'&$'&+"'.%*),2,&3'$.'2$5*2')$"%/*/5"'-1##$%&'-&%15&1%"-:''I7@7 ?*).#,#.)'*8+-3%&&.*8.(+'*+($%&& 'F/,&,*&,"-'*8$/)'.,%8-K'-+,.&'&$'2")*2,-*&,$/'*/6'"/,%$/8"/&*2'-"2.H �"5*1-"'$.',&-',/.$%8*2,&3:'G$%'-$8"'J%,&"%-',/'&+,-')%$1#?'1/2,5"/-"6'47X',-'/$&'6,-8,--"6'/")*&,"23'*-'*/*%5+,5'*/6',22")*2?'&#x 2 0;1&'%*&+"%?',&',-'1/6"%-&$$6'*-'J$%['&+*&'+*-'2$),5'J,&+,/'&+"' �,22'"'-J,.&23')%*/&"6'*/6'%"5$%6"6_'R#:'BceS:'7,")"2'*/6'a",)*'RBCCeS'$.."%'*/'$#&,8,-&,5'5$/5"#&'$.'.$%8*2,-*&,$/',/'-,8,2*%'.*-+,$/?'-&*&,/)'&+*&'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'-+$126'�"'-""/'*-'^&+"'8"*/-'$.'*�-$�%,/)'"Z,-&,/)'51-&$8*%3'#%*5&,5"-r6""2$#"6',/.$%8*223'&#x 2 0;3'8,/"%-r,/&$'&+"'8*,/-&%"*8'$.'*'5$1/&%3_-'2")*2'*/6' '.$%5"'1/2,5"/-"6'8,/"%-'&$'*6+"%"'&$'2*J-:'4')%$J,/)'�$63'$.'-5+$2*%-+,#'6$518"/&-'+$J'#$2,5"'*/6'8,2,&*%3'-&%*&"),"-'&$'5$/&%$2',22")*2'8,/,/)?'#*%&,512*%23',/'4.%,5*?'*%"'5$%"'."*&1%"-'$.'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'6$5&%,/"-?'*-'&+"-"'*%"'5$88$/23'#%,$%,&,-"6'-&*&"'8"5+*/,-8-'.$%'"/.$%5,/)'&+"'#%,/5,#2"-'$.'#%,*&"'#%$#"%&3'*/6'2")*2'-&*&1&"-'$/'%"-$1%5"'8*/*)"8"/&:'\+,2"'&+"-"'&%"/6-'*%"'"Z&"/-,"23'6$518"/&"6?'.$%',/-&*/5"?',/'&+"'5$/&"Z&'$.'/*&,$/*2')$"%/8"/&'#$2,5,/)'"..$%&-',/'(+*/*'Ri,2-$/'*/6's*[$2"*?'BCCbj'M1-+?'BCCeS'*/6'4/)$2*'RY"'M,22$/?'BCCTS?'d,8&#x 1 0;*&#x 1 0;J"'*/6'F/6$/"-,*'#%$,6"'#*%&,512*%23',8#$%&*/&'*/6'&,8"23'5*-"'-&16,"-'.$%',/"-&,)*&,/)')2&#x 2 0;$*2'/*%%*&,"-'$.'.$%8*2'2*J'*/6'$%6"%',/'&+"'8,/,/)'-"5&$%:'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' d,8��*J"_-'6""2$#8"/&:'L/"'$.'&+"'["3'"/61%,/)'2")*5,"-'$.'5$2$/,-*&,$/'J*-'&+"'#%,$%,&,-*&,$/'$.'8,/,/)'*-'*'5"/&%*2'#,22*%',/'&+"'/*&,$/*2'"5$/$83'Ri$22*J*3?'DeebS:'dJ*/"'%$'+.:'RBCCNS'$&#x 1 0;-"%"'&+*&'^&+"'X,/"-'*/6'X,/"%*2-'45&'m6""2$#"6',/,&,*223'1/6"%'5$2$/,*2'%12"n'%"8*,/-'&+"'8$-&'#$J"%.12'2"),-2*&,$/_?'-15+'&+*&'8,/,/)'2*J-'5$/&,/1"'&$'$"%%,6"'#$2,5,"-'.$%'$&+"%'%"-$1%5"'-"5&$%-'*/6',/'$&+"%',/-&,&1&,$/-'R":):'*)%,512&1%"?'&$1%,-8?'"&5:S:'P+"3'/$&"'+$J?'+,-&$%,5*223?'*/6'2*%)"23'*-'*'2")*53' )$/8"/&*2'*##%$*5+"-'.$%'#$&3H%"615&,$/H$%,"/&"6'6""2$#8"/&'*--,-&*/5"'.$%'47X'J$%["%-j'&+"-"')1,6"2,/"-'+*"'&#x 1 0;""/'+"%*26"6'*-'*'1-".12'8$6"2'*%$1/6'&+"'J$%26?'%"."%"/5"6',/'2,&"%*&1%"'$/'47X'*5%$--'4.%,5*'Rf%"-5+2"%?'BCCDj'i,/&$/?'BCCNS'*/6'""/',/'%"-"*%5+'2,&"%*&1%"'6,-51--,/)'8,/,/)'#$2,53'$#&,$/-',/'4-,*'RM1%["?'BCCNS:'P+"'#$2,53',-,$/'"Z#%"--"6',/'&+"'i*%*%"'(1,6"2,/"-'%".2"5&"6'&+"',-,$/'-+*%"6'&#x -2 ;3')$"%/8"/&'*)"/5,"-'*/6'6""2$#8"/&',/-&,&1&,$/-'&$'#%$8$&"'&+"'2")*2,-*&,$/'$.'47X'*5&,,&3'*/6'%"5$)/ %$'+.:'RBCCBS'6"-5%,�"'+$J',/5$8"-'$.'*%&,-*/*2'8,/"%-',/,&,*223'%$-"'�3'1#'&$'`Cq',/'&+"'"* E"/&%"'"Z#"%,"/5"'J,&+'*'-"/-"'$.'&+"%"'+*/)'&#x, 3 ;""/'*/'$##$%&1/,&3'2$-&?'&+"'8,22'5"/&%"_-'8*/*)"8"/&'J*-'""/&1*223'-+,.&"6'.%$8'6$/$%-'&$'*')%$1#'$.'^"-&*&#x 7 0;2,-+"6_'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/"%-'J+$'J"%"'^/$&'5$/5"%/"6_'*&#x 7 0;$1&'&+"'#$$%"%'J$%["%-:'P+,-'""/&1*223'5%"*&"6'6,-&%1-&',/'&+"'8*/*)"8"/&'$.'&+"'8,22?'J+,5+?'$"%'&,8"?'2"6'&$'1/6"%H1&,2,-*&,$/'*/6'*&#x 2 0;*/6$/8"/&:D`''F/&"%,"J-'*&'$&+"%'8,22-'5$/.,%8'&+*&'7+*8*_-'#%$&#x -3 ;2"8'J*-'/$&'*/',-$2*&"6'5*-":'7,8,2*%'5%,&,5,-8-'*%"'"Z#%"--"6'&#x -3 ;3'8,/"J$%["%-'J+$'J"%"',/$2"6',/'$&+"%'#%$V"5&-?'J+$'+*"'*%)1"6'&+*&'$1&-,6"%-'R)$"%/8"/&'*)"/&-?'6$/$%-'*/6'.$%",)/'"Z#"%&-S'/""6'&$'&#x -2 ;"'8$%"'-"/-,&,"'&$'5$8#2"Z,&,"-'$.'8,/"%-_'$%)*/,-*&,$/*2'-&%15&1%"-'J+"/'#%$8$&,/)'2*&#x -2 ;$1%'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'*/6'&"5+/$2$)3',8#%$"8"/&:'91-&'*-'6$/$%-'#122"6'$1&'#%"8*&1%"23'.%$8'&+"'7+*8*'#%$V"5&?'*/'=;H.1/6"6')$26'8,22,/)'#%$V"5&',/'F/-,h*'f,-&%,5&'-1.."%"6'*'-,8,2*%'.*&":'E$/.1-,$/?'8,-&%1-&'*/6'#$$%'8*/*)"8"/&'*&' &,$/'#%$)%*88"-:'d,8�*�J"'*2-$'+*6'-$8"'#*%&,512*%23'/$&*�2"'"Z#"%,"/5"-'J,&+')$"%/8"/&'8,5%$.,/*/5"'#%$)%*88"-'.$%'8,/"%-'J+,5+?'*2&+$1)+',8#"%."5&'*/6'-1&#x 2 0;V"5&'&$',/-&,&1&,$/*2'#%$&#x 2 0;2"8-',/'-"%,5"'6"2,"%3?'*-'-$8"'8,/"%-'"8#+*-,-"6',/'83',/&"%,"J-?Dc'&#x -3 ;"5*8"'#%$.,2"6'*&'*';k'5$/."%"/5"'*-'$/"'$.'&+"'8$-&'#%$*5&,"'"Z*8#2"-'$.'+$J'.$%8*2,-*&,$/'5$126'2"*6'&$'&#x 2 0;"/".,&-'-15+'*-'5%"6,&'*55"--:'P+"'5$/."%"/5"?'J+,5+'J*-'+$-&"6',/'&+"'&$J/'$.'@*6$8*'*/6'J+,5+'&#x 2 0;%$1)+&'&$)"&+"%')$"%/8"/&'$..,5,*2-'*/6';k'&%*,/,/)'-&*..'.%$8'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''Dc'4-'$/"'8,/"%'/$&"6',/'*/',/&"%,"J'&+*&'.$51-"6'$/'&+"'8,5%$.,/*/5"'.*5,2,&,"-'8*/*)"6'&#x 2 0;3'&+"')$"%/8"/&?'^4'."J'$.'&+"'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/"%-',/'d,8&#x 2 0;*&#x 2 0;J"'%"5",6'2$*/-'m.%$8'*')$%/8"/&H8*/*)"6'8,5%$H2$*/'#%$)%*88"n'V1-&'&#x" -1;&#x 000;".$%"'&+"'"2"5&,$/:'F&'J*-'*5&1*223'*/'"2"5&,$/ BCCN?'6,-&%,5&'5$1/5,2'$..,5,*2-',/'F/-,h*'f,-&%,5&',/.$%8"6'8"'&+*&'F'J*-'&+"'.,%-&'#"%-$/'&$'2"&'&+"8'[/$J'&+*&'&+"'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'+*6'%"#"*2"6'&+,-'2*Jj'&+"' #%,8*%3'$%"')$26H8,/,/)',/'%"8$&"'.$%"-&'*%"*-'&$'"*6"'#$2,5"j'*/6',/'$&+"%'5$/&"Z&-?'8,/"%-'J"%"',8#%,-$/"6'.$%'*-'2$/)'*-'.,"'3"*%-'.$%',22")*2'#$--"--,$/'$.')$26:''F/'&+"'8"6,*?'&+"'d,8&#x -3 ;*&#x -3 ;J"_-'8,/,/)'-"5&$%')$"%/*/5"&#x -3 ;'"5*8"',/5%"*-,/)23'5+*%*5&"%,-"6'*-'#*%&'$.'*'^&#x -3 ;%1&*2'%"),8"_'$.'^#,22*)"'*/6'#*&%$/*)"_'J,&+',/V1-&,5"-'*&#x -3 ;$1/6,/)',/'&+"')$"%/*/5"'$.'8,/"%*2' ,/)'6$J/'$/'8,/,/)'5$881/,&,"-:;'-.*('*8+(,.-'0'-%)'"*(+%*2+)3.+1*.E.*+2'()#':1)'"*+"0+6'**.#(+%*2+&"(.#(K'4'-"5$/6'8*V$%',8#*5&'$.'&+"'5%*5[6$J/'J*-'&+"',/5%"*-"6'5$/5"%/',/'8,/,/)'5$881/,&,"-'*�$1&'&+"',/"01*2,&,"-',/'*55"--,/)'2,5"/5"-:'7$8"'*%&,-*/*2'8,/"%-'6,6'/$&'+*"'*'2,5"/5"'&#x -3 ;1&'6"#"/6"6'$/'*'%"2*&,$/-+,#'$.'&%1-&'J,&+'%"),-&"%"6')$26'8,22"%-j'+$J""%?'8*/3'$.'&+"-"'%"2*&,$/-+,#-'R":):',/' -1##$%&']'",&+"%'.%$8'&+"'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'$%'.%$8'6$/$%-']'.$%'%")12*&,/)'*/6'8*/*),/)'%,-[-'*--$5,*&"6'J,&+')$26'#*//,/):'\+,2"'F/-,h*'f,-&%,5&'E$1/5,2'8"8&#x 1 0;"%-'-#$["'$.'#2*/-',/'BCCe'$.'%"H2")*2,-,/)')$26'#*//,/)?'&+,-'J$126'$/23'&#x 1 0;"'#$--,&#x 1 0;2"',.'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'*1&+$%,&,"-'*##%$"6'&+",%'%"01"-&?'J+,5+'J$126'&#x 1 0;"'5$/6,&,$/*2'1#$/'&+"'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'&#x -2 ;"2,",/)'&+*&'2$5*2'5*#*5,&,"-'J"%"',/'#2*5"'&$'2")*2,-"'#*//,/):'4-'/$'-1##$%&'J*-'**,2*&#x 2 0;2"'.$%'"8#$J"%,/)'6,-&%,5&')$"%/*/5"'-&%15&1%"-'REFf4'*/6'$&+"%'6$/$%'*)"/5,"-'J"%"'/$'2$/)"%',/$26j' 8,/,/)'."6"%*&,$/-'"Z,-&"6'*/6'+*6'2$��,"6'.$%'&+",%',/&"%"-&-'*/6'%,)+&-'J,&+'-$8"',8#%"--,"'6")%""'$.'$%)*/,-*&,$/j'&+1-?'#%$-#"5&-'.$%'^6"5%,8,/*2,-,/)_')$26'8,/"%-'*/6'%"),$/*2'-$5,*2'8$&#x 5 0;,2,-*&,$/'63/*8,5-'/"5"--*%,23'+*"'&$&#x -3 ;'"'5$/5"#&1*2,-"6',/'6,.."%"/&'.$%8-:'4-',/'d,8&#x -3 ;&#x -3 ;*J"?'F/6$/"-,*_-'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/"%-'+*"'&#x -1 ;""/'+"*,23'5%,&,5,-"6'$/'"/,%$/8"/&*2')%$1/6-?'*&'&,8"-'&$'&+"'#$,/&'&+*&'"/&,%"'&#x 2 0;*/-'$/'5"%&*,/'[,/6-'$.'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)'+*"'&#x -1 ;""/'*6$#&"6:''W*-&'- *-'^,22")*2'8,/,/)_?'+*"'"Z#*/6"6'$"%'&+"'#*-&'6"5*6"',/'/18"%$1-'%"),$/-'$.'F/6$/"-,*'R4-#,/*22?'BCCDj'=&"8*6'*/6'7*28*-,?'BCC`j'712*,8*/'%$'+. �*-"6' &"-'&$'#*%&,5,#*&"',/'8,/,/)'6""2$#8"/&?'&+"'6""2$#8"/&'$.'&+"'8,/,/)'-"5&$%'J*-'.*%'8$%"',)$%$1-23'#1%-1"6',/'&+"'#$-&H5$2$/,*2'"%*:Db'F/'DeOT?'&+"'($"%/8"/&'$.'F/6$/"-,*'#*--"6'G$%",)/'F/"-&8"/&'Y*J'k$:'bT?'J+,5+'-$1)+&'&$'&#x 1 0;$$-&',/"-&8"/&?'&#x 1 0;1&?'),"/'&+"'*/'1/-&*&#x 1 0;2"'#$2,&,5*2'*/6'"5$/$8,5'52,8*&"?'&+"'2*J'6,6'2,&&2"'&$'*&&%*5&'8*V$%',/&"%/*&,$/*2'8,/,/)',/"-&$%-'*&'&+"'&,8"'R=&"8*6'*/6'7*28*-,?'BCC`S:'G$22$J,/)'&+"'*&#x 2 0;$%&,"'5$1#'*&&"8#&'$.'DeNO?DT'&+"'k"J'L%6"%'($"%/8"/&'1/6"%'W%"-,6"/&'71+*%&$'5*%%,"6'$1&'-J""#,/)'%".$%8-',/'&+"'%"-$1%5"-'-"5&$%?'5%"*&,/)'/"J'%"),8"-'.$%'8,/"%*2'"Z#2$,&*&,$/:'F/'DeNN?'&+"'P"8#$%*%3'W"$#2"_-'E$/-12&*&,"'4--"8&#x 2 0;23'#*--"6'f"5%""'k$:'uuFFF?'%".$%8,/)'"5$/$8,5'#$2,5,"-'.$%'&+"'#1%#$-"'$.'%",,/)'&+"'%"-$1%5"-',/61-&%3',/'&+"'J*["'$.'&+"'5%,-,-:'P+"'6"5%""'#%$,6"6'&+*&'/*&1%*2'%"-$1%5"-'J,&+,/'F/6$/"-,*'-+*22'&#x 2 0;"'"Z#2$,&"6'-$'&+"3'5*/'&#x 2 0;"'&1%/"6',/&$'^/*&,$/*2'"5$/$8,5'6""2$#8"/&_'*/6'-&%"--"6'&+*&',/"-&8"/&'5*#,&*2'*/6'"Z#"%&,-"'.%$8'*&#x -3 ;%$*6'81-&&#x -3 ;'"'-$1)+&:'M*-"6'$/'&+"'6"5%""?'&J$'2*J-'J"%"',/&%$615"6'&$'%"#2*5"'Y*J'k$:'bT'$.'DeOT'*/6'Y*J'k$:'`b'$.'DeNCK'G$%",)/'F/"-&8"/&'Y*J'k$:'D'$.'DeNb'*/6'X,/,/)'Y*J'k$:'DD'$.'DeNb:''P+"'&#x -3 ;*$"'2*J-'+*"'5$8"'&$'&#x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eeC-'RP-,/)?'BCCOj'\*&[,/-'%$'+.:?'BCCNS:'4-'$..,5,*2-'2*8"/&"6'&+"'2$JH2""2'5*#*5,&3'$.'&+"'-&*&"?'4%&,52"'DC'$.'&+"'X,/,/)'Y*J'-&,#12*&"6'&+*&'6""2$#8"/&'$.'-&%*&"),5'*/6',&*2'8,/"%*2-'5$126'&#x 2 0;"'1/6"%&*["/'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''Db'F/,&,*&"6&#x 2 0;'3'F/6,*/-'*/6'E+,/"-"',/'718*&%*'*/6'@*2,8*/&*/?'8,/"%*2'"Z#2$,&*&,$/'J*-'"Z#*/6"6'61%,/)'&+"'f1&5+'5$2$/,*2'#"%,$6'.%$8'DNeO'&$'DecB?'*/6'+,-&$%,5*2'%"5$%6-'-1))"-&'&+*&'8*/3'$.'&+"'8,/"%*2'6""2$#8"/&-'5$/615&"6'/$J*6*3-'*%"'5$/&,/1*&,$/-'$.'8,/"-'"-&*&#x -1 ;2,-+"6'61%,/)'&+"'f1&5+'5$2$/,*2'#"%,$6:'P+"',/.21"/5"'$.'&+"'f1&5+'*68,/,-&%*&,"'-3-&"8'5*/'*2-$'&#x 1 0;"'.$1/6',/'*-#"5&-'$.'8,/,/)'2*J-'*-'&+"3'*%"'*##2,"6'&$6*3j',/'#*%&,512*%?'&+"'*-#"5&-'$.'8,/"%*2'2*J'&+*&'*1&+$%,-"'&+"'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'&$',--1"'8,/"%*2'#"%8,&-'.$%')$26'*/6'&+*&')%*/&'&+"'#%$,/5,*2')$/8"/&'&+"'%,)+&'&$',--1"'2,8"-&$/"'*/6'52*3'6"$#8"/&'#"%8,&-'#%$6"'-$8"'$.'&+"'52"*%"-&'#%$$.'$.'&+,-',/.21"/5":'4-'&"5+/$5%*&,5'-5,"/&,.,5'2,&"%*&1%"'$.&"/'$"%-,8#2,.,"-'$%'$8,&-'&+"'6,-51--,$/'$.'+,-&$%,5*2',/.21"/5"-'$/'5$/&"8#$%*%3'#$2,53',/-&,&1&,$/-'*/6'$.')2$&#x 2 0;*2'#$2,&,5*2'#%"--1%"-'&+*&'-+*#"'6$8"-&,5'%"-$1%5"'8*/*)"8"/&'.%*8"J$%[-?',&'+*-'&#x 2 0;""/'*%)1"6'&+*&'/$'-&163'$.'F/6$/"-,*/'8,/,/)'#$2,53'-+$126'#%$5""6'J,&+$1&'%"5$)/,-,/)'#*-&',/.21"/5"-'$/'8,/"%*2'2*J-'&#x 2 0;"),//,/)'J,&+'5$2$/,-*&,$/'*/6'+$J'&+"-"'+*"'"$2"6'&+%$1)+'&%*/-,&,$/,/)'#*&&"%/-'$.',/&"%/*&,$/*2',/.21"/5"'R\*&[,/-'%$'+.:?'BCCNj'M%,6)"?'BCCcj'M*22*%6'*/6'M*/[-?'BCC`j'P-,/)?'BCCOS:'i,-&$%,5*2'%"5$%6-',/6,5*&"'&+*&',&'J*-'/$&'1/&,2'DTee'&+*&'*'8,/,/)'-&*&1&"'J*-'"-&*&#x 5 0;2,-+"6'*-'F/6$/"-,*_-'2")*2'.$1/6*&,$/'.$%'8,/,/)'"Z#2$%*&,$/'*/6'"Z#2$,&*&,$/:'P+"'&#x 5 0;*-,5'8,/,/)'2*J-'&+"/'J"%"'&+"'DTee'F/6,-5+"'X,V/J"&?'J+,5+'J*-'8$6,.,"6',/'DeDC'*/6'DeDT?'*/6'&+"'X,V//$%6$/*/&,"'RX,/,/)'L%6,/*/5"S'$.'DeCN:'P+"-"'2*J-'#%$,6"6'&+"'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'J,&+'%,)+&-'&$'*68,/,-&"%'*22'8,/,/)'2,5"/5"-'.$%'$,2?'8"&*2?'5$*2?'6,*8$/6-'*/6'$&+"%'8*,/'8*&"%,*2-:'X*&"%,*2-'J+ X,/"%*2-_'R,/5216,/)'$,2?'5$*2'*/6'&,/?'*8$/)'$&+"%-Sj'(%$1#'M']'^a,&*2'X,/"%*2-_'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''De'4%&,52"'DD'-1))"-&-'&+*&'&+"'#1%#$-"'$.'^W"$#2"_-'X,/,/)_',-'&$'#%$,6"'%"),$/*2')$/8"/&-'*/6'2$5*2'5$881/,&,"-'J,&+'&+"'$##$%&1/,&3'&$'"Z#2$,&'8,/"%*2-'.$%'&+"')%"*&"-&'&#x"% 2;&#x 000;"/".,&'$.'&+"'-&*&"'&#x"% 2;&#x 000;*-"6'$/')1,6*/5"'.%$8'&+"'5"/&%*2')$/8"/&:';/6"%'&+"'X,/,/)'Y*J?'@W-'5*/'$/23'&#x"% 2;&#x 000;"')%*/&"6'&$'F/6$/"-,*/',/6,,61*2-'*/6'2")*2'"/&,&,"-:'\*&[,/-'"&'*2:'RBCCNS'/$&"?'+$J""%?'&+*&'^*2&+$1)+'&+"'X,/,/)'Y*J'5$/&"8#2*&"-'&+*&'&+"'@W'+$26"%'+*-'*'6"8$/-&%*&#x -2 ;2"'5*#*5,&3'&$'"Z#2$,&'8,/"%*2-',/',&-'@W'*%"*?'&+,-',-'$.&"/'/$&'&+"'5*-":'4-'*'%"-12&?'@W'+$26"%-'$/'$55*-,$/'"/&"%',/&$'*)%""8"/&-'J,&+'.$%",)/'8,/,/)'5$8#*/,"-'&$'5*%%3'$1&'8,/,/)'*5&,,&,"-'$/'&+",%'&#x 2 0;"+*2.:_'7$8"'@W-'5$/&*,/'5$/6,&,$/-'%"01,%,/)'*##%$*2'$.'-15+'*)%""8"/&-'R-$8"&,8"-'%"."%%"6'&$'*-'^5$$#"%*&,$/'*)%""8"/&-_S'&#x 2 0;3'&+"',--1,/)'*1&+$%,&3:'($"%/8"/&'!")12*&,$/'k$:'bO'$.'BCCD'*1&+$%,-"-'@*&#x 3 0;1#*&"/'m%")"/5,"-n'&$',--1"'@W'#"%8,&-?'*/6'*'@W'5*/'&#x 3 0;"'&"%8,/*&"6'&#x 3 0;*-"6'$/'&+%""')%$1/6-K'R,S'"Z#,%*&,$/'$.',&-'&"%8?'R,,S'5*/5"22*&,$/'61"'&$'.*,21%"'&$'5$8#23'J,&+')$"%/8"/&'%")12*&,$/-'*/6'%"01,%"8"/&-'*/6'R,,,S1/"5$/$8,5'%"*-$/-:'4.&"%'5$8#2"&,$/'$.'&+"'8,/,/)'.$%'8,/"%*2-',/'*'5"%&*,/'8,/"?'&+"'+$26"%'$.'&+"'%"2"*/&'8,/,/)'*1&+$%,-*&,$/',-'$&#x 2 0;2,)"6'&$'%"-&$%"'&+"'2*/6'&$'-15+'*'5$/6,&,$/'-$'*-'/$&'&$'5%"*&"'*/3'6*/)"%'$.'6,-"*-"'$%'*/3'$&+"%'6*/)"%'&$'&+"'#"$#2"'2,,/)',/'&+"'"/,%$/8"/&'$.'&+"'8,/":'P+"'2*J'*2-$'#%$,6"-'#"/*2&,"-'.$%'#"$#2"'J+$',22")*223'5$/615&'8,/,/)'$#"%*&,$/-:'BC'X,/,/)'5$8#*/,"-'$.&"/'-&%"--'&+*&'&+"'F/6$/"-,*/')$"%/8"/&'+*-'5%"*&"6'1/5"%&*,/&3'.$%',/"-&8"/&'&#x 6 0;3'&+%"*&"/,/)'&$',8#$-"'+,)+"%'%$3*2&3'%*&"-:'i$J""%?',&'-+$126'*2-$'&#x -1 ;"'/$&"6'&+*&'.$%",)/'8,/,/)',/"-&8"/&-'%$-"'5$/-,6"%*&#x -2 ;23',/'&+"'3"*%-'2"*6,/)'&$'BCCT:'X,/,/)',/-&8"/&'%$-"'&$';7vD:N'&#x" -1;&#x 000;,22,$/',/'BCCT?'1#'.%$8';7vD:B'&#x" -1;&#x 000;,22,$/',/'BCCb:'X$%"',8#$%&*/&23?'J,&+',/5%"*-"-',/'8,/"%*2'#%,5"-?'#%$.,&'8*%),/-'%$-"'*&'*'815+'.*-&"%'%*&"'&+*/',/"-&8"/&'&#x 1 0;"&J""/'BCC`'*/6'BCCb'RW%,5"J*&"%+$1-"E$$#"%-?'BCCbS:'BD'M*22*%6'*/6'M*/[-'RBCC`S'#%$,6"'*'2"/)&+,"%'6,-51--,$/'$.'&+"'6,-5$1%-"-'$.'k(L-'&+*&'*6$5*&"'.*,%"%'5$%#$%*&"')$/*/5"',/'8,/,/)?'-15+'*-'94P4X',/'F/6$/"-,*'*/6'X,/,/)\*&5+',/'E*/*6*:'BB'P+"%"',-'*'6,.."%"/5"?'*-'-$8"',/&"%,"J""-'.%$8'9*[*%&*'k(L-'&$26'8"?'&#x 1 0;"&J""/'#$2,5,"-'&$'#%$8$&"'@W-'*/6'5$/-&,&1&,$/*2'#%$-,$/-'.$%'W"$#2"_-'X,/,/):'E$/-&,&1&,$/*2'#%$-,$/-?'&+"3'*%)1"?'J$126'),'8$%"'J",)+&'&$'#$2,5,"-'*/6'%")12*&$%3'8"*-1%"-?'""/',.'&+"%"'J"%"'/$'/"J'-1&#x -2 ;-&*/&,"'5+*/)"-'&$'&+"')$"%/*/5"'*##%$*5+:'i$J""%?'*-'&+"%"',-'/$'-15+'5$/-&,&1&,$/*2'#%$&"5&,$/'.$%'#"$#2"_-'8,/,/)?'*/6'*-'&+"'E$/-&,&1&,$/'$.'F/6$/"-,*'-&,22'-&-'8,/"%*2'$J/"%-+,#'*&'&+" #$$%'*/6'#%$H"/,%$/8"/&'6""2$#8"/&'-&%*&")3: 5$%#$%*&,$/-'&$$?'*-',22")*2'8,/"%*2H-""["%-'^2"*6'5$8#*/3'#%$-#"5&$%-'&$'&+"'�"-&'-#$&-_'*/6'&+"/?'2*&"%'$/?'^&+"'5$8#*/,"-'6,-#2*5"'&+"8t*/6'5$8#2*,/'*�$1&'&+"',22")*2-?�'2*8,/)'&+"8'.$%'"/,%$/8"/&*2'#%$&#x 1 0;2"8-?'&+1-'#%$&"5&,/)'&+",%'$J/'%"#1&*&,$/_'R#:'NbS:'X*/1-'RBCCOS'*66"6'&$'-15+'5$/5"%/-'&#x 1 0;3'2*8"/&,/)'&+*&'&+"', 6"2,�"%*&"23'8,-2"6')2�$*2',/"-&$%-'*&#x 2 0;$1&'&#x 2 0;1-,/"--'#%$-#"5&-'*/6'2$5*2'%"-$1%5"',*&#x -1 ;,2,&3',/' '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' $551%',/5%"*-,/)23',/'(*2*/)*/',/'BCCe?'$-&"/-�,23'&$'-&$#',22")*2'*5&,,&3:'D: A.*.6.2+0"-1(+"*+*%)'"*%&+$"2.&(+0"#+.-"&"8'-%&+$"2.#*'(%)'"*+%*2+,#").-)'"*+%(+:%##'.#(+)"+&'E.&'3""2+0"#$%&'(%)'"*K'4-',/'&+"'5*-"'$.'d,8&#x 1 0;*&#x 1 0;J"?'F/6$/"-,*_-'8,/,/)'-"5&$%'%""*2-'*&#x -4 ;',*-'&$J*%6-'&#x -4 ;1%"*15%*&,5'=F4'%"01,%"8"/&-'&+*&'*22'8,/"%-']'J+"&+"%'*%&,-*/*2?'-8*22H-5*2"'$%'2*%)"H-5*2"']'+*"'&$'5$8#2"&":'L/"',/&"%,"J""?'*'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/"%',/'+,-'2*&"'.$%&,"-?'-1&#x 2 0;8,&&"6'*'2,5"/5"'*##2,5*&,$/',/'BCCT&#x 2 0;'1&'/$J'"Z#"5&-'/$&'&$'-""'&+"'*##2,5*&,$/'#%$5"--"6'.$%'3"*%-?',.'*&'*22:'i"'5,&"6'&+"',/&#x 2 0;*,2,&3'&$'-"51%"'*'2")*2'&#x 2 0;1-,/"--'*-'*'5*1-"'$.',88"/-"'-&%"--'*/6'*/Z,"&3'*/6'/$&"6'&+*&'&+,-'6$518"/&'+*-'&$')$'&+%$1)+'/*&,$/*2'8,/,-&%,"-'*/6'2$5*2'6,-&%,5&'*1&+$%,&,"-_'%","J'#%$5"--"-?'J+,5+'+"'&#x -2 ;"2,""-'5$126'&*["'3"*%-:'P+"'8$%"'-,)/,.,5*/&'"/,%$/8"/&*2'&#x -2 ;*%%,"%'&$'.$%8*2,-,/)'2,"2,+$$6-',/'&+"'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)'-"5&$%?'+$J""%?',-' +*&'&+,-'*%"*_-'.$%"-&',-'*2%"*63'52"*%H51&']'#$-"-'5$/-,6"%*�23'2"--'$.'*/'"5$-3-&"8'&+%"*&'&+*/'$&+"%'&3#"-'$.')$26H8,/,/)',/'%,"%-'/"*%&#x 7 0;3?'J+"%"'$/)$,/)'6%"6),/)'"%$6"-'*/6'5$/&*8,/*&"-'&+"'%,"%:'f%"6),/)'5%"*&"-'6,"-"2'#$221&,$/'*/6'8"%51%3'5$/&*8,/*&,$/'$.'J*&"%-'1-"6'&#x 2 0;3'5$881/,&3'8"8&#x 2 0;"%-'*/6'-""%"'-"6,8"/&*&,$/'&+*&'+*-'+*6'/")*&,"',8#*5&-'$/'.,-+'-1##2,"-j'/18"%$1-',/&"%,"J""-'8*6"'&+"-"'#$,/&-'&$'5$/&%*-&'6%"6),/)'&$'2*/6H&#x 2 0;*-"6'8,/,/)',/'(*2*/)*/:'L/"'8,/"%'&$$['8"'$/'*'&#x 2 0;$*&'&%,#'&$'-""'&+"'6%"6),/)'1#'52$-"',/'&+"'@*+*3*/'!,"%']'J+,5+',-'.*%'2"--'#$2,5"6'*/6'2"--'*55"--,&#x 2 0;2"'&+*/'&+"' -"5&$%'61%,/)'&+"'-&163'#"%,$6'RBCCO]BCDCS:'F/'-$8"'-"/-"?'&+"'.$51-'$/'^%"5"/&%*2,-,/)'#$J"%_'*&'*'/*&,$/*2'-5*2"'&+1-'-#"*[-'&$'&+"'+,-&$%,5*2'#*%&,512*%,&,"-'$.'&+,-'-&163:'k$/"&+"2"--?'J+,2"'.$51-,/)'$/'5$/&"8#$%*%3'"Z#"%,"/5"-'$.'^%"5"/&%*2,-*&,$/_?'*/'$##$%&1/,&3'*%,-"-'&$'%"5$/5"#&1*2 )12=+?*2"*.('%+\"&24N'*'*8+O%(.+)12=+q'$.'*%"*'5$"%"6'&#x 5 0;3'2*%)"'$%'8"6,18H-5*2"'5$8#*/,"-_'8,/,/)I"Z#2$%*&,$/'2,5"/5"-'eOq'$.'(%"*&'f3["'*%"*'5$"%"6'R-$1%5"K'd,8&#x 1 0;*&#x 1 0;J"'X,/"%-'G"6"%*&,$/?'BCCbS'X$-&'$.'(*2*/)*/'1/6"%'h,%5$/'5$8#*/3'5$/5"--,$/'R&#x 1 0;1&'/$')$26H8,/,/)'2,5"/5"-',--1"6S'@"3'#$2,5,"-'.$%'8,/,/) .%$8'&+"'.*%8"%'.,%-&:'4-'f*,6'Y$"']'$/"'$.'d,8&#x -2 ;*&#x -2 ;J"_-'2"*6,/)'"/,%$/8"/&*2'2*J'"Z#"%&-']'/$&"-?'&+"'8,/"%',-'8"%"23'%"01,%"6'&$',/.$%8'&+"'.*%8"%'*/6'*501,%"'&+"'/"5"--*%3'2,5"/5"-'*/6'#"%8,--,$/'.%$8'&+"'X,/,-&%3'$.'X,/"-'*/6'X,/,/)'f""2$#8"/&'RY$"?'BCCOS:Bb'f"-#,&"'&+,-'2")*2'&#x -2 ;,*-',/'.*$1%'$.'8,/,/)?'J+,5+'Y$"',6"/&,.,"-'*-'*'2")*53'$.'5$2$/,*2'2*J?'&+,-'*%%*/)"8"/&'+*-'/$&'/"5"--*%,23'/".,&"6'#$$%"%'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)'J$%["%-:'X,/,/)'5$881/,&,"-'*%"'.*%'.%$8'+$8$)"/"$1-?'*/6'*2&+$1)+'#$2,5,"-'+*"'&#x 1 0;""/'6"-,)/"6'J,&+'&+"',/&"/&'$.'-&*/6*%6,-,/)'*##%$*5+"-'.$%'2"),&,8*&"'"Z&%*5&,$/?'&+,-'-&*/6*%6,-*&,$/'+*-'2"6'&$'/"J'#%$&#x 1 0;2"8-:'d,8&#x 1 0;*&#x 1 0;J"'*/6'F/6$/"-,*'*%"'&#x 1 0;$&+'"Z*8#2"-'J+"%"?'*2&+$1)+'#%$-#"5&,"'$#"%*&$%-'*%"'%"01,%"6'&$'1/6"%&*["'*'-"%,"-'$.'6%*J/H$1&'&#x 1 0;1%"*15%*&,5'&*-[-',/'$%6"%'&$'-"51%"'*'#*%5"2'$.'%"-$1%5"'%,)+&-'&+%$1)+'2")*2'5+*//"2-?',/.$%8*2H-"5&$%'J$%["%-'8*3'$%'8*3'/$&'+*"'&+"'#$2,&,5*2'5$//"5&,$/-'/"5"--*%3'.$%'*501,%,/)'&+"-"'%,)+&-?'&+"'5*#*5,&3'$%'&+"'[/$J2"6)"'$.'+$J'&$'8*["'&+"'2")*2,-*&,$/'#%$5"--'J$%[:'\+"%"'*'^-5*2*%_'5%,&,01"'5*/'*--,-&'&+,-'6,-51--,$/',-'&#x -1 ;3'5$/-,6"%,/)'+$J'&+"'&"5+/$5%*&,5'6"-,)/'*/6',8#2"8"/&*&,$/'$.'/*&,$/*2'%")12*&,$/'%"),8"-'8,)+&'-"%"'*%,$1-'#$2,&,5*2',/&"%"-&-'&+*&'6".3'-,8#2"'2,/"*%'5$/5"#&1*2'8$6"2-'$.'%")12*&,$/?'&+*&'8,)+&'&#x 2 0;"'-+*#"6'&#x 2 0;3'6,%-"'*5&$%-'*&'6,.."%"/&')"$)%*#+,5*2'-5*2"-?'*/6'&+*&'8,)+&'&#x" -1;&#x 000;"'-1&#x" -1;&#x 000;"%&"6',/'5$8#2"Z'J*3-'&$$?'%"/6"%,/)?',/'&1%/?'5$8#2"Z,&,"-'.$%',8*),/,/)'&+"'#$--&#x -1 ;,,2,&3'.$%'%"-,-&,/)'%"),8"-'$.',/6,-5%,8,/*&"'%1%*2'5%,8,/*2,-*&,$/: 75*2"'($26'X,/,/)'R-""'7#,")"2'*/6'a",)*?'BCDCS?'�1&'*&'#%"-"/&?'8*/3')$"%/8"/&-'5$/&,/1"'&$'*6+"%"'&$'"/,%$/8"/&*2'*/6'%1%*2'#2*//,/)'8$6"2-'&+*&'5$/.$%8'&$'&+"'8$6"2-'$.'2*%)"%H-5*2"'$#"%*&,$/-?'/$&'-8*22H-5*2"'#%$615&,$/?'*/6'&+"'#%*5&,5"-'$.'%16,8"/&*%3'47X'*%"'-&,22')"/"%*223'/$&'%"5$)/,-"6',/'/*&,$/*2'2"),-2*&,$/'$%'#$2,53:'G1%&+"%8$%"?'*-')2&#x 1 0;$*2',/,&,*&,"-'-15+'*-'!=ff'*%"'&#x 2 0;",/)'*55$8#*/,"6'&#x 2 0;3'5"/&%*2')$"%/8"/&'"..$%&-'&$',8#$-"'8$%*&$%,18-'*/6'&#x 2 0;2$5['2$5*2'6,-&%,5&-'.%$8'2,5"/-,/)'8,/,/)'R":):'*-',/'@*&,/)*/'f,-&%,5&?'F/6$/"-,*S?',&'%"8*,/-'&$'&#x 2 0;"'-""/'J+"&+"%'2$JH,/5$8"'-8*22H-5*2"'#%$615"%-'J,22'&#x 2 0;"'*&#x 2 0;2"'&$'.,/6'".."5&,"'8"*/-'$.'/")$&,*&,/)'^.$%8*2'2"),&,8*53_'J+"/'2,5"/-,/)'$#&,$/-'6$'/$&'-""8'&$'&#x 2 0;"'**,2*&#x 2 0;2":'Y*%)"H-5*2"'8,/,/)'5$8#*/,"-' ?'7J"6"/:''E2*1-"/?'M*%%"&$?'Y:?'*/6'4&&*%*/?'4:'BCDD'W%$#"%&3'%,)+&-'&+"$%3'*/6'&+"'%".$%8'$.'*%&,-*/?*2'*/6'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)',/'6""2$#,/)'5$1/&%,"-:'E(9&/+.'()'4(.-$-0#'+/;':+A'cRDSK'DOHBN:'E$1-,/-?'M:'BCCe:'E*#,&*2,-8'&#x 6 0;$-51%"6K'&+"'2,8,&-'$.'2*J'*/6'%,)+&-H&#x 6 0;*-"6'*##%$*5+"-'&$'#$"%&3'%"615&,$/'*/6' 'f%"-5+2"%?'M:'BCCD:'78*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)'*/6'-1-&*,/*�2"'6""2$#8"/&'J,&+,/'&+"'74fE'%"),$/:'Y$/6$/K'F/&"%/*&,$/*2'F/-&,&1&"'$.'=/,%$/8"/&'*/6'f""2$#8"/&'*/6'\$%26'M1-,/"--'E$1/5,2'.$%'71-&*,/*&#x -3 ;2"'f""2$#8"/&:'f3*2H =(&96')(&'D%5%.(,6%/$'G$9;-%# VaN'b` 'X,&5+"22:'P:'BCCB:'%'()'FR,%&$#N'F8",$S'2%01/(74(.-$-0#S'!(;%&/-$"M' X1)$*?'4:'BCCD:'W%"-"/&*&,$/K'&+"'7+*8*'X,/,/)'E"/&%"'W%$V"5&:'XX7f'\$%[-+$#'$/'4%&,-*/*2'78*22H75*2"'X,/,/):'Y$/6$/?';@?'De]BC'k$"8&#x 1 0;"%:'X1-"8&#x 1 0;,'E:'BCCbM'f"'7$&$'*/6'2*/6'%"2*&,$/-',/'%1%*2'4.%,5*K'&#x 1 0;%"*&+,/)'2,."',/&$'6"*6'&+"$%,"-'*&#x 1 0;$1&'#%$#"%&3'%,)+&-M'21-&;'C(&.;'d9+&$%&."'BTRTSK'DcObQDcbTM'k$81%*?'@:'BCCT:'P+"'#$2,&,5-'$.'#*%&,5,#*&,$/',/'.$%"-&'8*/*)"8"/&K'*'5*-"'.%$8'6"8$5%*&,h,/)'F/6$/"-,*:'E(9&/+.'()'F/5-&(/6%/$'+/;'D%5%.(,6%/&'DbRBSK'DNN]DeD:'&#x 1 0;L,6h,/-[,?'@:'BCCc:'F22")*2'2$)),/)'*/6'&+"'.*&"'$.'F/6$/"-,*_-'.$%"-&-',/'&,8"-'$.'%"),$/*2'*1&$/$83:'W*#"%'#%"#*%"6'.$%'&+"'DC&+'E$/."%"/5"'$.'&+"'F/&"%/*&,$/*2'4--$5,*&,$/'.$%'&+"'7&163'$.'E$88$/'W%$#"%&3'RF47EWS?'L*Z*5*?'X"Z,5$?'eHD`'41)1-&'BCCc:'L_G*,%5+"*22*,)+?'E:'*/6'42,?'7:'BCCT:'F+&$1'!+$$%&#N'J/;-8%/(9#'4%(,.%#S'$1%'FR$&+0$-5%'J/;9#$&-%#'+/;'*(&,(&+$%' 7$[J*/"2"'RE,,5'45&,$/'71##$%&'(%$1#S:'BCCb:'W,22*)"'*/6'#*&%$/*)"K'+18*/'%,)+&-'&#x 1 0;*1-"-',/'d,8&#x 1 0;&#x 1 0;*J"_-',/.$%8*2')$26'8,/,/)'-"5&$%:'Bb'9*/1*%3:'7#,")"2?'7:9:'BCCe:'!"-$1%5"'#$2,5,"-'*/6'-8*22H-5*2"')$26'8,/,/)',/'d,8&#x 1 0;*&#x 1 0;J":'#(9&0%#'4(.-0"'`cK'`e]cc:'7#,")"2?'7:9:'*/6'a",)*?'X:'BCCO:'M1,26,/)'5*#*5,&3',/'-8*22H-5*2"'8,/,/)'5$881/,&,"-K'+"*2&+?'"5$-3-&"8'-1-&*,/*&#x% 2 ;,2,&3'*/6'&+"'(2$&#x% 2 ;*2'X"%51%3'W%$V"5&:'F0(P%+.$1'BRcSK'D]DC:'7#,")"2'7:9:'*/6'a",)*?'X:X:'BCDC:'F/&"%/*&,$/*2')1,6"2,/"-'$/'8"%51%3'8*/*)"8"/&' '+/;'M1)/$-"/?'=:X:'Dee`M'7+*8*'X,/,/)'E"/&%"'f"8$/-&%*&,$/'W%$V"5&K'*/'"Z*8#2"'$.',/&"%/*&,$/*2'*/6'2$5*2'k(L'5$22*&#x 1 0;$%*&,$/'#%$)%"--'*/6'#%$&#x 1 0;2"8-'&$'6*&":' Center for International Forestry Research CIFOR advances human wellbeing, environmental conservation and equity by conducting research to inform policies and practices that aect forests in developing countries. CIFOR is a CGIAR Consortium Research Center. cifor.orgblog.cifor.org This research was carried out by CIFOR as part of the CGIAR Research Programme, ‘Forests, Trees and Agroforestry: Livelihoods, Landscapes and Governance’. The Programme aims to enhance management and use of forests, agroforestry and tree genetic resources across the landscape from forests to farms. CIFOR leads the collaborative Programme in partnership with Bioversity International, the International Center for Tropical Agriculture and the World Agroforestry Centre.