Jamie Ballantine SURF SURF Sponsors surfconf18 Andy Milne SURF Which of the following sectors best describes the organisation you are representing today Community Group Central Government National Public body ID: 795052
Download The PPT/PDF document "2018 SURF Annual Conference, 23rd August" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
2018 SURF Annual Conference, 23rd August
Slide2Jamie Ballantine, SURF
Slide3SURF Sponsors
Slide4#surfconf18
Slide5Andy Milne, SURF
Slide6Which of the following sectors best describes the organisation you are representing today?
Community Group
Central Government / National Public body
Local Government / NHS board
Private sector
Third sector
Academic institution
Other
Community Group
Central Government / National Public body
Local Government / NHS board
Private sector
Third sector
Academic institution
Other
Slide7In broad terms. which geographical area is your organisation concerned with?
Scotland-wide
A region, district or city
Small town or neighbourhood (pop. under 10k)
Scotland-wide
A region, district or city
Small town or neighbourhood (pop. under 10k)
Slide8‘Governance and Power’
A SURF Debate 24.5.18
Slide9Elaine Cooper, SURF
Slide10Aileen Campbell MSP, Scottish Government, Cabinet Secretary.
Slide11Reeni Kennedy Boyle, Bute Island Alliance
Slide12Coffee, chat, pastriesMusic by
Fèis Phàislig
Slide13Token Gestures Coin Game
Slide14Coffee, chat, pastriesMusic by
Fèis Phàislig
Slide15Token Gestures Coin Game
Slide16Gerry McCartney,NHS Health Scotland
Slide17Inequalities and regeneration
Gerry McCartney
Consultant in Public Health &
Head of Public Health Observatory
NHS Health Scotland
Slide18Inequalities and regeneration (…and some health)
Gerry McCartney
Consultant in Public Health &
Head of Public Health Observatory
NHS Health Scotland
Slide19These data have been updated using the
ScotPHO
profiles published in June 2015 comparing the life expectancies in
Broomhill
(close to
Jordanhill
station) and
Parkhead
&
Barrowfield
(close to Bridgeton station) intermediate zones.
Slide20Education based Relative Index of Inequality (RII) for all-cause mortality, females
30-74 years, early to mid 2000s
Source:
Eikemo
T.A. &
Mackenbach
J.P. (
Eds
). EURO GBD SE: the potential for reduction of health inequalities in Europe.
Final Report. University Medical
Center
Rotterdam, 2012
Slide21Source:
Eikemo
T.A. &
Mackenbach
J.P. (
Eds
). EURO GBD SE: the potential for reduction of health inequalities in Europe.
Final Report. University Medical
Center
Rotterdam, 2012
Education based Relative Index of Inequality (RII) for all-cause mortality,
males
30-74 years, early to mid 2000s
Slide22Inequality in mortality between best and worst 10
%
of local authorities in Great Britain
(sources: Thomas 2010 and Dorling 2010)
Slide23What causes health inequalities?
Wider environmental influences
Economic & work
Physical environment
Education
& learning
Social & cultural
Services
Individual experiences
Fundamental causes
Global
forces &
political
priorities
leading to:
Unequal distribution of
power, money and resources
Effects
Inequalities in
health
Slide24Wider environmental influences
Economic & work
Physical environment
Education
& learning
Social & cultural
Services
Individual experiences
Fundamental causes
Global
forces &
political
priorities
leading to:
Unequal distribution of
power, money and resources
Effects
Inequalities in
health
Regeneration could do this!
Slide25What do we know about the impacts of regeneration from the research evidence?
A lot of the research is low quality
The better quality evidence usually looks at the health impacts of regeneration
We are generally operating on the basis of:
received wisdom
good intentions
‘practice based knowledge’
rather than robust evidence
Slide26Slide27Good evidence & positive impacts
Refurbishment of housing
improves thermal comfort, health, social relations, absence from school/work
Specific housing interventions – wiring in smoke alarms, energy efficiency
Slide28Uncertain impacts
Specific regeneration schemes (New Deal for Communities, Glasgow, Catalonia, DDA in Netherlands, Victoria)
Mixed tenure housing
Changing housing tenure
Employment and business support
Transport infrastructure and outcomes
Slide29Mixed impacts
Gentrification and
residualisation
Can be an aim of regeneration (to achieve greater mixed tenure
) or consequence
Changes in outcomes in an area are often due to population movements
Interaction with existing community organisations
Slide30Research implications
Robust evaluation of ‘regeneration’ activities is essential
…including the need for studies which follow people over time to account for movement in and out of areas
Need to assess the added value of regeneration on economic and employment outcomes by using careful comparison groups
Learning and evaluation needs to be an integral part of regeneration practice
Slide31Policy implications
To narrow inequalities (health or otherwise) we need action at the level of political economy
…but ‘regeneration’ activities could make a real difference by addressing employment, housing, physical environment, social environment, service availability, etc.
Refurbishment and improvements of housing has a strong evidence base
The impacts of other aspects of regeneration are much less clear – evaluation and learning is really important
We can’t assume ‘regeneration’ will always be positive
Don’t forget that this
is all about
people
Slide32Thank you for listening/heckling*Email:
gmccartney@nhs.net Twitter: @gerrymccartney1
Reference:
McCartney G, Hearty W,
Taulbut
M, et al. Regeneration
and health: a structured,
rapid literature review.
Public Health
(2017); 148: 69-87.
*delete as appropriate
Slide33Gerry McCartney,NHS Health Scotland
Slide34Reality Check – Voting Session
Slide35What is
real Community Led Regeneration best at?
Improving community cohesion and cooperation
Improving local public services
Creating local employment and skills opportunities
Meeting essential needs of vulnerable local people
Building more successful and inclusive local economies
Something else
Improving community cohesion and cooperation
Improving local public services
Creating local employment and skills opportunities
Meeting essential needs of vulnerable local people
Building more successful and inclusive local economies
Something else
Slide36What is most likely to help Community Led regeneration grow successfully?
Less form filling, red tape and reporting processes.
More and longer term core funding
More support for developing community leaders and entrepreneurs
More cooperation between local voluntary groups
Easier access to local government service contracts
Something else
Less form filling, red tape and reporting processes.
More and longer term core funding
More support for developing community leaders and entrepreneurs
More cooperation between local voluntary groups
Easier access to local government service contracts
Something else
Slide37Gerry McCartney (NHS HS)Reeni Kennedy Boyle (Bute Island Alliance)David Cowan (Scottish Government)
Jim Gray (Formerly Glasgow CC)Robin McAlpine (Common Weal)
Slide38Lunch and Community Marketplace upstairs
Slide39Darren McGarvey,Author and Performer
Slide40Darren McGarvey (Author)David Cowan (Scottish Government)Elaine Cooper (SURF)
Hazel Cross (Fife Council)Martin Cawley (Big Lottery Fund)
Slide41James Robertson,Poet and Author
Slide42Andy Milne, SURF
What’s Next?
Slide43•
Reduced membership fee:
SURF membership is
only £50
(plus VAT)
for organisations and
only £20
(plus VAT) for community groups and individuals
•
A free way to promote your organisation
•
Influence decision makers
•
Be in the know
Further information on membership benefits and application forms are available at the SURF webpage:
www.surf.scot/join-surf/
Or alternatively contact Emma Scott directly,
emma@surf.scot or 0141 440 6392
Are you a member of SURF?
Slide44Launched on
Tuesday 12th June
Open for applications until 5pm on
Monday 17th September
This year the 5 categories will be:
Community Led Regeneration
Youth Employability: Overcoming Barriers
Scotland’s Most Improved Place
Housing
Creative Regeneration
Annual Awards Dinner
at the Grand Central Hotel, Glasgow –
Thursday 6th December
Information available on the SURF website at:
https://www.surf.scot/surf-awards
/
Slide45Caption Competition
Slide46Community Marketplace (upstairs)
Slide47Thank you for coming!
Please leave your badges and feedback forms at the door
www.surf.scot
@
SURFscot
SURF