Dogear social bookmarking in the enterprise - PDF document

#=#D+(&"1D$D1+.+1&"$0C"2=#)$QD.==#2$01"2#()R$1"$+L#$5-4$`1'1+.=$a10(.(P,$-&==#D+1&")$&?$D1+.+1&")$D."$0#$D(#.+#2$/."C.==P$0P$(#.2#()$&($+L(&C'L$#S#DC+1&"$Q."2$.=#(+1"'R$&?$.$).;#2$)#.(DL,$$b#(L.M)$+L#$/&)+$?./1=1.($.MM(&.DL$+&$\(#F?1"21"']$1"?&(/.F+1&"$&"$+L#$N#0$L.)$0##"$+L#$C)#$&?$M#()&".=$0&&@/.(@)3$.)$)CMM&(+#2$0P$;.(1&C)$N#0$0(&N)#(),$V&($#S./M=#3$+L#$4&Z1==.$0(&N)#($)CMM&(+)$+L#$D(#.+1&"$&?$D&==#D+1&")$&?$c%a)3$NL1DL$D."$0#$.""&+.+#2$C)1"'$@#PN&(2)$&($?(##F?&(/$+#S+3$."2$+L#"$)&(+#2$&"$.$;.(1#+P$&?$21/#")1&")$Q#,',3$+1/#$=.)+$;1)1+#23$@#PN&(23$=&D.+1&"R,$5"$#.(=P$)+C2P$&?$0&&@F/.(@$C)#$)L&N#2$+L.+$M#&M=#$D(#.+#2$0&&@/.(@)$0.)#2$&"$+L#$UC.=1+P$&?$."2$M#()&".=$1"+#(#)+$1"$+L#$D&"+#"+3$L1'L$?(#FUC#"DP$&?$DC((#"+$C)#3$."2$.$)#")#$&?$M&+#"+1.=$?&($?C+C(#$C)#$^8_,$VC(+L#(/&(#3$+L#$"C/0#($&?$0&&@/.(@)$D&"+.1"#2$1"$."$1"21;12C.=$D&==#D+1&"$'(#N$)+#.21=P$."2$(&C'L=P$=1"#F.(=P3$."2$+L#$C)#$&?$?&=2#()$ !"#$%&&'3$5M(1=$77F7H3$766G3$4&"+(i.=3 V1".==P3$+L#(#$1)$.$)+(&"'$DC=+C(.=$"&(/$N1+L1"$+L#$&('."1Z.F+1&"$+&$C)#$/&(#$?&(/.=$"./#)$N1+L1"$+L#$D&(M&(.+#$.MM=1D.F+1&"),$$K+$)L&C=2$0#$"&+#2$+L.+$NL1=#$D(#.+1"'$M#()&".=$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&")$(#UC1(#)$.C+L#"+1D.+1&"$&?$(#.=$"./#$12#"+1+P3$1+$1)$M&))10=#$+&$0(&N)#$+L#$#"+#(M(1)#$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&"$."&"P/&C)=P,$TL1)$1";1)10=#$M.(+1D1M.+1&"$1)$.$?&(/$&?$\=C(@1"']$."2$.==&N)$+L#$0#"#?1+)$&?$0&&@/.(@$)L.(1"'$+&$#S+#"2$+&$+L#$#"+1(#$#"+#(M(1)#,$aC(@#($0#L.;1&($1)$D&C"+#2$ /.(@$Q`R,$TL#$C)#($D."$21(#D+=P$M1;&+F0(&N)#$+&$."$.C+L&(g)$0&&@F/.(@)$0P$D=1D@1"'$&"$+L#$.C+L&(g)$"./#3$&($.22$D&//#"+)$;1.$+L#$D&//#"+)$=1"@,$TL#$D&//#"+)$.(#$12#"+1D.=$1"$)+P=#$+&$+L#$D&//#"+)$&"#$D."$D(#.+#$1"$(#)M&")#$+&$0=&'$#"+(1#),$TL#$L1'L=1'L+#2$"C/0#()$QdR$1"21D.+#)$+L#$"C/0#($&?$&+L#($M#&M=#$NL&$L.;#$.=)&$0&&@/.(@#2$+L.+$c%al$D=1D@1"'$&"$1+$DL."'#)$+L#$;1#N$+&$.$=1)+$&?$0&&@/.(@)$?&($+L.+$c%a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g)$+.'),$5)$."$1==C)+(.F+1&"3$D=1D@1"'$&"$&"#$C)#(g)$+.'$'1;#)$.$=1)+$&?$.==$+L#1($0&&@/.(@)$NL1DL$L.;#$+L.+$+.',$TL1)$D."$&?+#"$(#)C=+$1"$.$;#(P$=&"'$=1)+$&?$0&&@/.(@)$0C+$+L#$C)#($D."$(#2CD#$+L1)$=1)+$0P$)M#D1?P1"'$."&+L#($+.'$+L.+$/C)+$0#$C)#2$1"$D&" 4 ;C"D+1&"$N1+L$+L#$?1()+,$V&($1")+."D#$.$C)#($/1'L+$?1()+$N."+$+&$=&&@$.+$)&/#&"#g)$\2#)1'"]$+.'3$."2$+L#"$(#.=1Z#$+L#P$"##2$+&$0#$/&(#$)M#D1?1D,$TL#$C)#($/1'L+$.22$+L#$\N#0]$+.'$.)$."&+L#($D&")+(.1"+3$)&$+L.+$+L#$(#)C=+$1)$.==$0&&@/.(@)$N1+L$0&+L$\2#F)1'"]$."2$\N#0]$.)$+.'),$TL#)#$1"+#()#D+1"'$+.')$.(#$)L&N"$.)$+L#$\5))&D1.+#2]$+.')$=1)+$1"$+L#$1"+#(?.D#$QpR$.)$)##"$1"$V1'C(#$8,$5)$+.')$.(#$.22#2$+&$+L#$DC((#"+$D&")+(.1"+$N#$(#M(#)#"+$+L#/$21(#D+=P$C"2#($+L#$\T.')]$+.0$.(#.$QKR$."2$1"$+L#$M.'#$+1+=#,$TL1)$;#()1&"$&?$M1;&+$0(&N)1"'$1)$)1/1=.($+&$+L#$=1"#.($\0(#.2$D(C/0]$+PM#$".;1'.+1&"$1"+#(?.D#$D&/F/&"=P$C)#2$1"$N#0)1+#)3$0C+$L#(#$+L#$".;1'.+1&"$1)$=#))$=1"F#.($.)$+L#$C)#($D."$.=)&$(#/&;#$."P$+.'$?(&/$+L#$DC((#"+$;1#Ng)$(#UC1(#/#"+),$K"$M.(+1DC=.(3$D=1D@1"'$&"$+L#$/1"C)F CHI 2006 Proceedings ¥ Social Computing 1 N1+L$)1Z#$."2h&($D&=&($1"$(#=.+1&"$+&$+L#$?(#UC#"DP$+L.+$+L#P$.(#$C)#2$1"$+L#$)P)+#/,$TL1)$L.)$+L#$#??#D+$&?$'1;1"'$+L#$C)#($.$+.'$=1)+$NL1DL$)1/C=+."#&C)=P$)L&N)$?(#UC#"DP$."2$.=ML.F0#+1D.=$1"?&(/.+1&"$.+$&"D#,$TL#$()*+,-$)#(;1D#$.=)&$M(&F;12#)$.$+.'$D=&C2$;1#N$&?$\5D+1;#]$+.')$QqR,$TL#$()*+,-$+.'$D=&C2$L.)$+N&$.221+1&".=$?#.+C(#),$TL#$?1()+$1)$.$)=12#($NL1DL$.==&N)$+L#$C)#($+&$2P"./1D.==P$(#2CD#$+L#$+.'$D=&C2$+&$+L#$/&(#$?(#UC#"+=P$C)#2$+.')$1"$+L#$DC((#"+$ .+,/ 115CHI 2006 Proceedings ¥ Social Computing 1 C/01,"#/'/1"5==$UC#(1#)$/.P$1"D=C2#$#1+L#($&($0&+L$&?$+L#$G"4*$."2$G;$M.(./#+#()3$NL1DL$)M#D1?P$+L#$(#)C=+$M.'#$."2$M.'#$)1Z#3$(#)M#D+1;#=P,$TL#)#$c%a)$.(#$D&")+(CD+#23$."2$+L#1($&C+MC+$M.()#2$."2$+(.")?&(/#23$#.)1=P$#"&C'L$+&$M#(/1+$;#(P$(.M12$D(#.+1&"$."2$2#M=&P/#"+$&?$C)#?C=$)#(;1D#)$NL1DL$(#+(1#;#3$.''(#F'.+#3$."2$(#M(#)#"+$&C($2.+.$N1+L$.$/1"1/C/$&?$M(&'(./F/1"',$$IA2FD"#6EDH"TL#$()*+,-$)#(;1D#$M(&+&+PM#$N.)$=.C"DL#2$?&($.$)/.==$?(1#"2=P$+(1.=$1"$4.(DL3$766X,$5$)/.==$'(&CM$&?$D&//1++#2$C)#()$UC1D@=P$?&(/#2,$5$/&(#$?&(/.=$?1#=2$+(1.=$&?$+L#$()*+,-$)#(;1D#$N1+L1"$+L#$D&(M&(.+#$1"+(."#+$0#'."$1"$pC=P$.)$M.(+$&?$.$"#N$+#DL"&=&'P$1"DC0.+1&"$M(&'(./3$."2$."F"&C"D#/#"+)$.0&C+$+L#$)#(;1D#$.;.1=.01=1+P$L.;#$0##"$/.2#$&"$1"+(."#+$N#0$)1+#),$5221+1&".=$0CZZ$.0&C+$+L#$.;.1=.01=1+P$&?$+L#$()*+,-$)#(;1D#$L.)$0##"$D(#.+#2$+L(&C'L$N&(2$&?$/&C+L$."2$)1'"1?1D."+$21)DC))1&"$&?$+L#$)#(;1D#$&"$+L#$D&(FM&(.+#$1"+(."#+$0=&'),$$O#$L.;#$0#'C"$+&$.))#))$+L#$C).'#$M.++#(")$&?$()*+,-g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pC=P$+&$*#M+#/F0#(3$766X,$`C(1"'$+L1)$C).'#$M#(1&23$GeG$1"21;12C.=)$N#(#$(#D&(21"'$C)1"'$+L#$ )CMM&(+)$+L#$2#)1'"$'&.=$&?$M(&;121"'$.$)&D1.=$0&&@/.(@1"'$)#(;1D#$?&($#"+#(M(1)#$Q)#DC(#R$N#0$M.'#),$5=)&$&?$"&+#$1)$+L.+$+L#$;.)+$�/.&(1+P$&?$()*+,-$0&&@/.(@)$.(#$)L.(#2,$a#))$+L."$+L(##$M#(D#"+$&?$.==$0&&@/.(@)$.(#$/.(@#2$M(1;.+#,$ )C)+.1"#2$"C/0#($&?$0&&@/.(@$.221+1&")$Q-%d5Td*R$N1+L$.$)=1'L+$1"D(#.)#$1"$C)#$&;#($+1/#,$5=)&$;1)10=#$1)$#;12#"D#$+L.+$M#&M=#$.(#$?&==&N1"'$+L#$0&&@/.(@)$+&$+L#$1"?&(/.+1&"$)&C(D#$Q)L&N"$.)$\-aK-q*]$1"$V1'C(#$9R,$O#$)##$;#(P$=1++=#$0&&@/.(@$\#21+1"']$2C(1"'$+L1)$+1/#3$NL1DL$N&C=2$0#$#;1F2#"D#$&?$0&&@/.(@$/.".'#/#"+$.D+1;1+1#)$)CDL$.)$(#?1"#F/#"+$&?$+.')$&($@#PN&(2)3$&($.221+1&".=$.""&+.+1&"$+&$+L#$0&&@/.(@,$TL1)$1)$"&+$)C(M(1)1"'$.)$N#$.(#$#.(=P$1"$+L#$+(1.=$."2$&+L#()$L.;#$)L&N"$+L.+$0&&@/.(@$/.".'#/#"+$1"FD(#.)#)$.)$+L#$)1Z#$&?$D&==#D+1&")$1"D(#.)#)$^8_,$0,000-00/00=00800.00� 9 ;00700,-/=8&#x -9 ;.N11*"$?"/,&'(B9+O1,"$?"'%/&$-?*3%$3@4:$A&:A(+$1$473*&R9&S/3*+%;&.+&%.4*"3&.#*3&*$40/&A*&#x/$#$;&#x/C& ;&#x-3 0;*;&=$*)%&/3$")9&E41"$?"/'.4"TO$$*+',*"*1;$,=4U"*1"D#$+L#$C)#$&?$+.')$Q&($@#PN&(2)R$1)$.$2#?1"1"'$DL.(.D+#(F1)+1D$&?$)&D1.=$0&&@/.(@1"'$)#(;1D#)3$N#$L.;#$#S./1"#2$+L#$C)#$&?$+.')$1"$()*+,-,$8IH8$21)+1"D+$+.')$L.;#$0##"$C)#2$N1+L1"$()*+,-3$N1+L$.$/#21."$&?$86$21)+1"D+$+.')$M#($C)#(,$O#$&0)#(;#2$.$)+(&"'$D&((#=.+1&"$0#+N##"$+L#$"C/0#($&?$+.')$C)#2$."2$+L#$"C/0#($&?$0&&@/.(@)$D(#.+#2$$-$9$,XG3$QM$u$,668R,$TL1)$D&((#=.+1&"$N.)$)+(&"'#($?&($()*+,- /.,2.@"2)*&H9&Q73#*C&3*;7)/;&.=&G*32*+*=$/;&.=&%.4*"3&&!?$M.(+1DC=.($1"+#(#)+$+&$C)$N#(#$+L#$0#"#?1+)$M(&;12#2$0P$+L1)$)&D1.=$0&&@/.(@1"'$)#(;1D#$1"$M#(?&(/1"'$;.(1&C)$1"F?&(/.+1&"$)##@1"'$+.)@),$TL#$M#(D#"+.'#$&?$(#)M&"2#"+)$NL&$.'(##2$N1+L$;.(1&C)$+.)@$0#"#?1+$)+.+#/#"+)$D."$0#$)##"$1"$T.0=#$J,$TL#)#$)C(;#P$(#)C=+)$.(#$'#"#(.==P$UC1+#$?.;&(.0=#,$5$/.&#x*$#*;&#x%& -; 00;&(F1+P$&?$(#)M&"2#"+)$.'(##$+L.+$()*+,- ()*+,- TN&$&?$+L#$/&(#$1"+#(#)+1"'$+&M1D)$.(#$M(#)#"+#2$0(1#?=P$L#(#,$TL#$?1()+$1)$.0&C+$1))C#)$.(&C"2$+L#$12#.$&?$\)&D1.=$0&&@/.(@1"']$1"$'#"#(.=,$!"#$0=&'$M&)+$).12$\#:.$28311$)/$8;+$4+/=38;$,11$8;+$2)$6)),1 ;&#x] TJ;&#x 0 T; ET;&#x BT ;�.14;R T; 10;&#x.02 ;� 0 ;.0; 43;.79;5 4;d.4;ॕ ;&#xTm /;õ.1;&#x 1 T; [ ;.,-,1 ;&#x] TJ;&#x 0 T; ET;&#x BT ;�.14;R T; 10;&#x.02 ;� 0 ;.0; 43;.79;5 4;d.4;ॕ ;&#xTm /;õ.1;&#x 1 T; [ ;3/*$8;3/*???$#$.+,/@$8;+-+$32$13881+$83.+$8)$*)$8;-)0*;$=;,8$.A$8)()$1328$;,2$1328+(@$8;,8$#$B0C$8)$/)=D$43/($13881+$E,10+$3/$+38;+-$,D$;+1C3/*$)8;+-2$*+8$8)$=;,8$#$43/($3/8+-+283/*@$,/($6D$023/*$)8;+-$C+)C1+:2$8,*2$8)$*+8$8)$3/8+-+283/*$28044?FxG/$8;+$413CH23(+@$#$ $+L#$=#.("1"'$M&(+.=,$!+L#()$L.;#$)C''#)+#2$'#++1"'$D&(M&(.+#$D&//C"1+1#)$&?$M(.D+1D#$Q#,',3$#D=1M)#$2#;#=&M#()R$+&$)+."2.(21Z#$&"$;.(1&C)$+.')$)&$+L.+$1"?&(/.+1&"$D."$0#$/&(#$#.)1=P$)L.(#2$./&"'$/#/F0#(),$O#$M=."$+&$/&"1+&($+L#)#$@1"2)$&?$+.'$"#'&+1.+1&")$+&$C"2#()+."2$L&N$+L#P$1"?=C#"D#$+L#$2#;#=&M/#"+$&?$+L#$()*+,-$?&=@)&"&/P,$I9/9,1"N$,*!"2Q3($&/&-."/01"F&-*4"!"#$&?$+L#$M(1/.(P$0#"#?1+)$&?$."$#"+#(M(1)#$)&D1.=$0&&@F/.(@1"'$.MM=1D.+1&"$1)$+L.+$1+$1)$."$#SM=1D1+$.))#))/#"+$&?$+L#$C+1=1+P$&($;.=C#$&?$;.(1&C)$1"+#("#+$."2$1"+(."#+$1"?&(/.+1&"$(#)&C(D#),$5)$."$1"?&(/.+1&"$(#)&C(D#3$+L#(#$.(#$/."P$M&F+#"+1.=$1"+#'(.+1&"$M&1"+)$N1+L$&+L#($D&(M&(.+#$.MM=1D.+1&"),$*#;#(.=$&?$+L#)#$.(#$21)DC))#2$L#(#,$TL#$?1()+$".+C(.=$1"+#'(.+1&"$M&1"+$N&C=2$0#$+&$C)#$)&D1.=$0&&@/.(@$=1"@$)+(CD+C(#$+&$.C'/#"+$#"+#(M(1)#$)#.(DL$.MM=1FD.+1&"),$O#0$(#)&C(D#)$N1+L$L1'L$0&&@/.(@$D&C"+)$.(#$=1@#=P$+&$0#$(#=#;."+$."2$C)#?C=,$K"21D#)$&?$(&=#$&($+#./F0.)#2$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&")$D."$0#$)M#D1.==P$N#1'L+#2$1"$+#./$."2$(&=#$0.)#2$)#.(DL$+&&=),$5"$#.(=P$;.(1."+$&?$+L1)$)#.(DL$1"+#'(.+1&"$L.)$.=(#.2P$0##"$2#;#=&M#2$.)$.$V1(#?&S$M=C'F1",$K"+(."#+$)#.(DL#)$.(#$.C'/#"+#2$N1+L$.$)CMM=#/#"F+.=$)#.(DL$&?$+L#$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&"3$."2$0&&@/.(@$/.+DL#)$.(#$M(#)#"+#23$.)$.$'(&CM3$1"$+L#$)#.(DL$(#)C=+$=1)+,$K?$+L#$#S+#")1&"$(#D&'"1Z#)$+L#$DC((#"+$0(&N)#($=&D.+1&"$.)$.$M.'#$&?$)#.(DL$(#)C=+)3$1+$/.@#)$."$WTTb$(#UC#)+$+&$+L#$()*+,-$)#(;#(3$."2$1"�#D+)$+L#$(#)C=+1"'$WT4a$1"+&$+L#$M.'#3$1"$.$/.""#($D&")1)+#"+$N1+L$+L#$M.'#$2#)1'",$O#$L.;#$D(#.+#2$)#.(DL�F1"#D+1&"$&C+MC+$?&(/.+)$?&($&C($&N"$1"+(."#+$)#.(DL$#"'1"#3$."2$?&($Y&&'=#,$TL1)$.MM#.()$+&$0#$M(&/1)F1"'$.)$+L#$1"+(."#+$)#.(DL$1"�#D+1&")$L.;#$0##"$&0)#(;#2$G66J$+1/#)$2C(1"'$?1#=2$+(1.=$."2$IGJ$()*+,-F0&&@/.(@#2$=1"@)$L.;#$0##"$)#=#D+#2$1"$M(#?#(#"D#$+&$+L#$(#)C=+)$(#F+C("#2$0P$+L#$D&(M&(.+#$)#.(DL$#"'1"#,$$5$)#D&"2$1"+#'(.+1&"$N&C=2$0#$+&$D&/01"#$."$1"21;12C.=g)$0&&@/.(@)$N1+L$&+L#($1"?&(/.+1&"$)&C(D#)$M(&;12#2$0P$+L.+$1"21;12C.=,$5$(#)#.(DL$M(&+&+PM#$&?$."$#"L."D#2$D&(M&(.+#$21(#D+&(P$)#(;1D#$L.)$.=(#.2P$#/0#22#2$M&(+1&")$&?$."$1"21F;12C.=g)$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&"$1"$+L#1($21(#D+&(P$1"?&(/.+1&",$TL#$12#.$L#(#$1)$+L.+$."$1"21;12C.=g)$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&"$1)$/#."1"'?C=$(#?=#D+1&"$&?$+L#$@1"2)$&?$+&M1D)$&?$'#"#(.=$1"F+#(#)+$+&$+L#/,$TL1)$/.P$0#$.$M&N#(?C=$/#DL."1)/$+&$M(&F;12#$2P"./1D$CM2.+#)$+&$+L#$\DC((#"+$1"+#(#)+)]$M(&?1=#)$?&($1"21;12C.=),$K"$.$)1/1=.($/.""#(3$D&(M&(.+#$0=&''#()$L.;#$#/0#22#2$.$=1)+$&?$(#D#"+$M#()&".=$0&&@/.(@)$1"+&$+L#1($L&/#$0=&'$M.'#$0P$C)1"'$+L#$p.;.*D(1M+$?&(/.+$M(&;12#2$0P$2&'#.(,$$5$+L1(2$".+C(.=$1"+#'(.+1&"$M&1"+$N&C=2$0#$+&$D&/01"#$0&&@/.(@$D&==#D+1&")$?(&/$.$'(&CM$&?$1"21;12C.=)$1"+&$N#0$)1+#)$/.1"+.1"#2$+&$)CMM&(+$;.(1&C)$+#./)$&($�M(&#D+),$O#$L.;#$.=(#.2P$&0)#(;#2$&"#$+#./3$NL1DL$1)$?&DC)#2$&"$#F=#.("1"'3$#/0#2$.$D&==#D+1&"$&?$0&&@/.(@)$&"$.$+#./$N#0$)1+#,$5'.1"3$C)1"'$+L#$)C0)D(1M+1&"$)#(;1D#)$)CMM&(+#2$0P$+L#$0&&@/.(@1"'$.MM=1D.+1&"$.==&N)$.C+&/.+1D$CM2.+1"'$&?$0&&@/.(@)3$M(&/&+1"'$+1/#=P$)L.(1"'$&?$1/M&(+."+$1"?&(/.F+1&"$./&"'$+#./$/#/0#(),$8CB8FE#ACB"OL1=#$N#$L.;#$�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hhNNN,?=1D@(,D&/h$8F!Y&=2#(3$*,$."2$WC0#(/."3$o,$5,$766X$TL#$*+(CD+C(#$&?$-&==.0&(.+1;#$T.''1"'$*P)+#/),$T#DL"1D.=$(#M&(+3$K"F?&(/.+1&"$`P"./1D)$a.03$Wb$a.0),$.F!q.".N.+13$%,$."2$4.=#@3$4,$7667,$5$/C=+1F.'#"+$)P)+#/$?&($D&==.0&(.+1;#$0&&@/.(@1"',$K"$R-)(3/*2$)4$8;+$L3-28$3/8+-/,83)/,1$Z)3/8$!)/4+-+/)/$W08)/).)02$W*+/82$,/($X0183,*+/8$MA28+.2\$R,-8$]$Qo&=&'".3$K+.=P3$pC=P$8X$F$8I3$7667R,$5545*$y67,$5-4$b(#))3$m#N$f&(@3$mf3$88JHF88Je,,$&#x+$ -;ͅ ;F!q#==#(3$%,$4,3$O&=?#3$*,$%,3$-L#"3$p,$%,3$%.01"&N1+Z3$p,$a,3$."2$4.+L#3$m,$8IIH,$5$0&&@/.(@1"'$)#(;1D#$?&($&(F'."1Z1"'$."2$)L.(1"'$c%a),$K"$M+1+(R,C+-2$L-).$8;+$M3^8;$3/8+-/,83)/,1$!)/4+-+/)/$I)-1($I3(+$I+6$Q*."+.$-=.(.3$-.=1?&("1.3$c"1+#2$*+.+#)R,$886JF8889,$$7F!4.(.1)3$W,$."2$oL.(.+3$q,$8IIH,$*CMM&(+1"'$D&&M#(.+1;#$."2$M#()&".=$)C(?1"'$N1+L$.$2#)@+&M$.))1)+."+,$K"$R-)H()4$8;+$P&8;$W//0,1$W!X$MA.C)230.$)/$_2+-$3/8+-4,M)48=,-+$,/($T+/)1)*A$Qo."??3$5=0#(+.3$-.".2.3$!D+&0#($89$F$8H3$8IIHR,$cK*T$yIH,$5-4$b(#))3$ CHI 2006 Proceedings ¥ Social Computing 1