BOOK REVIEWS - PDF document

MLIF@V • Vol. 22 No. 2 • BOOK REVIEWS bpcebtba qeb qaph lc bumiafkfkd teaq tap prmmlpba ql bb obaifpba) aka qeaq fq tap mlppfbib) afpmaoadfkd qefp ap ‘tofqfkd obcfmbp…clo qeb cllh*pelmp lc qeb crqrob$+ ?rq fq fp bppbkqfai ql pelt qeaq teaq lkb caslrop fp) fkabba) mlppfbib+ Gaclbv fp ofdeq fk mlhfkd dbkqib crk aq qeb molcifsfqv lc pljb rqlmfakp clo qbiifkd rp elt mblmib$p aavp tfii bb lodakfpba) aka elt qebv tfii bb aobppba+ Efp cofqfcfpj) eltbsbo) pbbjp ql jb fkcloobcq fc fq fp qahbk pqofmb—albp klq easb ql aaaobpp hbv pqorcqroai fpprbp clkcbokfkd elt qeb plcfbqv qebv caslro tfii tloh+ Qeb Coakhcroq ‘kbdaqfsfpq$ qoaafqflk pbbjp ql jb mbokfcflrp mobcfpbiv bbcarpb fq aslfap qefp qaph) tefib aq qeb pajb qfjb fkslhfkd fabap qeaq lkiv jahb pbkpb fc pljbqefkd ifhb qeb Jaoufpq sfpflk tbob qbkabib+ Fq rpbp qeb obpriq ap a pqfch tfqe tefce ql bbaq croobkq plcfbqv) tefib fk cacq afpqakcfkd fqpbic colj qeb prbpqakqfsb clkqbkq lc Jaoufpj+A corcfai molbibj ebob—aka fq fp pqofhfkd qeaq Gaclbv albp klq afpcrpp fq aq aii—tap efdeifdeqba fk Eavbh$p ‘Fkardroai Aaaobpp$ aq qeb Ilkalk Pcelli lc Bclkljfcp+ Eavbh aodrba qeaq Picture Imperfect: Utopian Thought for an Anti-Utopian Columbia University Press, 2005, rppbii Gaclbv fp a R@IA*bapba efpqlofak tfqe a pqolkd fkqbobpq fk qeb Coakhcroq Pcelli+ Eb fp borafqb) aka tofqbp sbov tbii lk a telib oakdb lc fkqbobpqfkd qebjbp+ Qefp pjaii bllh fp a cliilt*rm ql efp Qeb Bka lc Rqlmfa %.666) a bofiifakq cofqfcai bkdadbjbkq tfqe qeb dofj pqaqb lc qeb ‘criqroai Ibcq$+ Gaclbv fp qebob ak bkqboqafkfkd Qeb kbt bllh fp tbii*tofqqbk) aka crii lc capcfkaqfkd jaqbofai—colj a clkqoapq bbqtbbk qeb qliboakq miroaifpj lc Qeljap Jllob$p Rqlmfa aka efp acqrai clkarcq lkcb fk mltbo) ql qeb fjmacq lc qbibsfpflk lk qoaafqflkai cefiaobk$p dajbp+ Gaclbv$p jafk qebjb) eltbsbo) fp a afpqfkcqfsb abcbkcb lc mlifqfcai rqlmfakfpj+ Eb fkfqfaiiv aodrbp qeaq fq eap klq Vol. 22 No. 2 • MLIF@V BOOK REVIEWS qeaq lro croobkq pfqraqflk—aka) pav) qeb krjbbo lc mblmib qeaq fq croobkqiv prpqafkp—fjmlpbp pfdkfficakq clkpqoafkqp lsbo teaq bipb tb cak al+ Fk maoq) fq fp qeaq tb easb ql al qefkdp fk a pvpqbjaqfc jakkbo) aka qeaq akv pvpqbj qeaq tb rpb tfii bofkd tfqe fq clkpqoafkqp ap ql teaq bipb fq fp aipl mlppfbib clo rp ql al) lo clo elt tb cak accljmifpe lqebo qefkdp tefce tb sairb+Teaq pbbjp ql jb baaiv tolkd tfqe Gaclbv$p acclrkq—aka tfqe qeb qoaafqflk qeaq ifbp bbefka fq—fp qeaq fq fp rqlmfak fk qeb pbkpb lc pfjmiv fdklofkd qebpb fpprbp+ Qeb obpriq fp qeaq qelpb tel cliilt Gaclbv jav fika qeaq qebv aob iba ql afpclkqbkq tfqe) aka mlppfbiv bsbk ql qov ql qeolt lcc) ‘ceafkp$ tefce aob) fk cacq) qeb lqebo pfab lc qeb sbov qefkdp qeaq aob kbbaba ql jahb abpfoabib cbaqrobp lc lro plcfbqv lmboaqb+ Lc clropb) akv prce pmbcffic ciafj fp caiifbib8 aka qebob fp a ilq lc ollj clo aodrjbkq ablrq elt qefkdp crkcqflk—lo jfdeq crkcqflk bbqqbo qeak qebv al—aka ablrq teaq clkpqoafkqp qebv fjmlpb+ %Qefp) lc clropb) fp ak aodrjbkq qeaq jrpq bb jaab klq lkiv fk obpmbcq lc erjak plcfai fkpqfqrqflkp) brq aipl fk bclildfcai qbojp+& Fq pbbjp ql jb qeaq) fk qeb bka) fq fp rmlk qefp corcfai abbaqb qeaq Gaclbv fp fksfqfkd rp ql qrok lro bachp+ Tefib efp bllh fp a fiopq*oaqb obaa) efp sfbtp pbbj ql jb aqqoacqfsb brq aakdbolrp—klq ibapq bbcarpb lc grpq elt mltbocri efp mobpbkqaqflk lc efp capb fp+Tebob albp qefp ibasb rp? F al klq pbb qeaq tb aob pqrch tfqe grpq elt qefkdp aob croobkqiv+ ?rq teaq fp kbbaba fc tb aob ql bumilob fabap ablrq a bbqqbo plcfbqv) fp fkabba ql qahb a obaifpqfc sfbt lc elt qefkdp croobkqiv tloh) aka ql qahb pboflrpiv qeb clkpqoafkqp qeaq bufpqfkd plcfai jbceakfpjp fjmlpb rmlk rp+ Tb kbba qebk ql bumilob teaq qeb lmqflkp aob ql jahb qefkdp acqraiiv crkcqflk fk kbt tavp+ Qeb ciafjp lc Eavbh aka Jfpbp ablrq jaohbqp pbbj ql jb qbiifkd+ ?rq fc qebv aob ofdeq) tb aob klq clkabjkba ql pqadkaqflk aka) plcfaiiv) grpq ql jlob lc qeb pajb+ Oaqebo) qeb ciappfcai ifbboai qoaafqflk lmbkp rm qeb mlppfbfifqv lc jahfkd rpb lc cljmbqfqflk ap a afpclsbov molcbarob) aka clo afsbopb clojp lc mofsaqb plcfai bumbofjbkqaqflk—molsfaba qeaq tb cak objlsb dlsbokjbkqai clkqolip qeaq croobkqiv ifjfq rp ql teaq brobarcoaqp aka qeb ibpp fjadfkaqfsb lc lro cbiilt*cfqfwbkp qefkh fp ‘plrka$+ ‘Qebob aob bbqqbo qefkdp ql al qeak saifaaqb lqebo mblmib$p jaohbqfkd iabbip bv qaihfkd rm dbkboaqflkai clkflfcq)$ tofqbp Ovak Ebaqe) a 22 vbao lia bumaqofaqb ifsfkd fk qeb RH+ Fq$p a obcobpefkd pqaoq ql efp bllh) pfjmiv bbcarpb jlpq cofqfcfpj afobcqba aq Ebaqe eap aodrba eb fp alfkd mobcfpbiv qeaq+ ?rq qeaq$p qeb qolrbib tfqe mbkkfkd a bllh ablrq dbkboaqflkai taocaob fpk$q fq? Vlr ibasb vlropbic lmbk ql accrpaqflkp lc iampfkd fkql pqvib aq Ql ak buqbkq fq$p qorb7 Ebaqe pqofkdbkqiv aslfap qrokfkd efp tloh fkql ak ‘acaabjfc qobaqfpb$) mlfkqbaiv rpfkd tloap prce ap ‘fkbccfcfbkq) rkcafo aka arjb$+ Qefkh crqb) capeflkabib iakdradb tfqe mibkqv lc bumibqfsbp qeoltk fk+ Pfjfiao fk dfpq ql Qlkv ?iafo$p Cabfak majmeibq Qeb Qefoa Tav7 Kbt Mlifqfcp clo qeb Kbt @bkqrov) qefp bllh rodbp rp ql eaokbpp camfqaifpj ql acefbsb plcfaiiv grpq dlaip+ Tebob qeb afccbobkcb aofpbp eltbsbo) fp fk fqp clcrp+ Abqafiba afpcrppflk lk tev) aka elt) ?abv ?lljbop pelria bb ‘ebia ql acclrkq$—aka mrpeba apfab—clojp qeb clob lc Ebaqe$p Qeb obpriq lc Ebaqe$p cloav fkql qeb dbkob fp qeaq eb pmbkap jrce Mibapb Grpq C' Lcc7 Fq$p Lro Qrok Klt aqqbjmqfkd ql abfab bv qeb rktofqqbk oribp lc dbkboaqflkai taocaob) tfqe jbjloabib ifkbp ifhb ‘Tao fp klq 21,4—qebob$p ilqp lc abaa qfjb—brq vlr easb ql bb obaav