Kayde Cox Emily Jennings Daniel Schwartz and Sylvia Zaki Queens College What is the problem Whats the plan What have we decided What can we do References 1 Plug the drain With specially engineered inflatable plugs that will fill a tunnel ID: 269787
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Combatting Storm Surge Flooding in Lower..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Combatting Storm Surge Flooding in Lower Manhattan and its Effects on the NYC Subway
Kayde Cox, Emily Jennings, Daniel Schwartz, and Sylvia Zaki, Queens College
What is the problem?
What’s the plan?
What have we decided?
What can we do?
References
1.
Plug the drain!
With specially engineered inflatable plugs that will fill a tunnel Will act as a plug would in a sink, not letting water get through, preventing flooding due to storm surgePressurized in 30-minutesNeed minimal adjustments in order to fit each tunnelCost: About $400,000 per plugFigure 1 breaks down the infrastructureNeeds further development
Strategies to safeguard subway tunnels will focus on:
Installing subway plugs prior to periods of predicted heavy storm surgeCost-efficient: $400,000/plugSimple to implement: 30-minute pressurization time and fits to contour of tunnelDurable: Can withstand 500,000 pounds of forceElevating subway grates 6-18 inches above the sidewalkUnnecessary grates can be sealedElevated grates already in use in Hillside Avenue zone216 raised, 353 sealed—cost valued at several millionCost efficient, aesthetically pleasingDiverts moderate floodwater and rubbish from tunnelsFurther research needs to be conducted about the feasibility of integrating elevated subway station entrances into lower ManhattanEffective long-term strategy for waterproofing stationsAlready in use in Taipei and Bangkok (Figure 3)Will allow uninterrupted subway service throughout category 2 hurricanes and less intense storms
Storm surge flooding events in lower Manhattan that normally occur once every hundred years are expected to occur every three to 20 years (Lin et al.)This increase in flooding is exacerbated by climate changeEast River subway tunnels below Canal Street are vulnerable to floodingWithout prior preparation, complete flooding of these tunnels could take 29 days to recover from (Jacob et al. 2011)This would cost New York City approximately $23 million per day that the subway system is shut down (Jacob et al. 2011)GOAL: East River subway tunnels must be completely protected from flooding in the event of a category two hurricane or lower by the year 2080.
Ahlers
, Mike M. “Huge Plugs Could Have Spared Subways from Flooding, Developers Say –
CNN.com.” CNN. Cable News Network, 01 Nov. 2012. Web. 30 Nov. 2012.Department of Homeland Security. Plugging Up a Subway Tunnel. Digital image. Nytimes.com. The New York Times, 19 Nov. 2012. Web. 1 Dec. 2012.Duap, David W. “New Subway Grates Add Aesthetics to Flood Protection.” The New York Times. N.p., 19 Sept. 2008. Web. 14 Nov. 2012.Fernquest, John. “Can It Flood in the Subway?” Bangkok Post: Learning. Bangkok Post, 28 Oct. 2011. Web. 30 Nov. 2012.Jacob, Klaus H., et al. Risk Increase to Infrastructure Due to Sea Level Rise. Rep. Metropolitan East Coast Regional Assessment. CIESIN Columbia University, 2001. Web. 20 Nov. 2012.Jacob, Klaus, et al. “Transportation.” Responding To Climate Change In New York State: The CLIMAID Integrated Assessment For Effective Climate Change Adaptation In New York State: Final Report. Vol. 1244. Oxford: Blackwell Science Publ, 2011. 299-362. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. Web of Science. Web. 14 Nov. 2012.Lin, Ning, et al.“Physically Based Assessment of Hurricane Surge Threat Under Climate Change.” Nature Climate Change 2.6 (2012): 462-67. Web of Science. Web. 14 Nov. 2012.Metropolitan Transit Authority. Hurricane Sandy Recovery Service As of November 1. Digital image. Mta.info/maps. Metropolitan Transit Authority, 31 Oct. 2012. Web. 1 Dec. 2012.Teo, Audrey, and Jenny Woo. Integration of MRT Entrance with Private Development. Rep. Land Transport Authority, 2011. Web. 30 Nov. 2012. Wilson, Robert. Subway Grates–Bicycle Rack. Digital image. Streets Blog, 1 Oct. 2008. Web. 1 Dec. 2012. Wongrat, Natthawat. Flooding in Thailand 2011. Digital image. Net Photography., 10 Nov. 2011. Web. 1 Dec. 2012.
StrategyProsConsElevated Subway EntrancesFlood-proofs station entrances Allows for subway functionality, if floodwaters are shallow enoughSpace limitationsIntegration issuesAccessibility issuesPrice & time needed for construction: unknown
Figure 2: Created by Rogers Marvel Architects, these elevated subway grates were designed to divert rubbish and storm surge flooding from entering subway tunnels through street level grates. The grates stand 6-18 inches high (depending on flood risk) and can be found in Astoria and Hillside Queens.
2. Elevated subway gratesDiverts water from entering directly into subway gratesDiverts rubbish from falling through into the subway tunnelsCan serve as seats or bicycle racks to be more aesthetically pleasing (Figure 2)Are a short term solution because they will not stop flooding if a 100-year storm event were to happenIncrease subway grates 6-18 inches above the sidewalkSeal up subway grates that are not necessary to stop rain from entering at all
3. Elevated subway entrancesIncrease susceptible subway station entrances’ lowest critical elevation to 20 ft. through a combination of structural elevation and the use of flood gates.Further investigation is needed to determine cost, station placement and/or integration with neighboring structures, and to figure out accessibility issues.Implementation by necessity: More susceptible stations are elevated first.A survey of every station’s LCE and proximity to the shore is needed to determine order of implementation
Completely protect the 4 and 5 train subway tunnels from flooding by 2028
Completely protect the R train subway tunnel from flooding by 2045
Completely protect the 2 and 3 train subway tunnels from flooding by 2062
Completely protect the A and C train subway tunnels from flooding by 2080
Effective January 2013, starting in Battery Park, begin to replace necessary subway grates with elevated grates. Seal up grates that prove to be
unnecessary
. Repeat this process moving uptown until we reach Canal Street.
Conduct a survey in June 2014 of every lower Manhattan train station’s proximity to the shore to determine order of implementation. Stations that are most susceptible to flooding will be the first stations to be elevated.
Aim to have research pertaining to the plugs completed by June 2015, then start to equip subway tunnels with the plugs by 2016, placing subway stations located closest to the water at a higher priority.
By January 2016, establish a training program to teach MTA employees to effectively use the inflatable plugs.
Have researchers evaluate lower Manhattan from 2014-2017 and the changes that must be made to accommodate elevated subway entrances.
Figure 1: Diagram of the Department of Homeland Security’s development of the plug to stop flooding in subway tunnels.
Figure 4: MTA map of the flooded subway tunnels during Hurricane Sandy
Figure 3:
An elevated MRT station in Bangkok, Thailand defends the subway system from floodwaters during the 2011 monsoon season. Subway stations are elevated 1.20 meters above street level and are equipped with flood barriers, adding another 1.50 meters of protection.
Strategy
Pros
Cons
Plugs
Cheap
Effective
Is
not fully developed yet
May need to be altered for each tunnel
Strategy
Pros
Cons
Elevated Subway Grates
Cheap
Effective
Stylish
Will
not take long to implement
Provides seats and bicycle racks
May not
be effective in the event of a 100 year storm occurring