Soviet Soviet The material presented in the EHES Working Paper Series is property of the authors and should be quoted as such The views expressed in this Paper are those of the authors and do n ID: 424710
Download Pdf The PPT/PDF document "factors receive only qualified support. ..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Soviet Soviet factors receive only qualified support. Finally, I demonstrate that the factors determining The material presented in the EHES Working Paper Series is property of the author(s) and should be quoted as such. The views expressed in this Paper are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the views of the EHES or "#=/$31$#65#7&#x 1 0;#'?$&1/$5"#$'#-3.1&=$-.@#'17#15$.2$A&5&=.13&$ �68=30$-../,$5.$5".,#$31/3@3/8&=,$=.0&5#/$2&'$&4&%$2'.7$5"#$-.@#'17#15$31$5#'7,$.2$6'#2#'#10#,$.'$-#.-'&6"%:$I2$31/3@3/8&=,$&'#$=.0&5#/$2&'$#1.8-"$2'.7$5"#$,.8'0#$.2$68�=30$-../,?$5"#%$7&%$-&31$�%$,#0#/31-$&1/$6'.@3/31-$68�=30$-../,$5"#7,#=@#,?$#@#1$32$5"3,$6'.@3,3.1$3,$6'.6.'53.1&==%$7.'#$0.,5=%:$!"3,$�&,30$5'&/#H.22$0&1$�#$7./#'&5#/$�%$&$187�#'$.2$2&05.',:$I2$�&''3#',$5.$5'&/#$&'#$-#1#'&==%$"3-"$&1/$5"#%$0.3103/#$435"$,5&5#$�.'/#',?$5"#'#$&'#$&//353.1&=$�#1#235,$2'.7$=3@31-$&1/$/.31-�$8,31#,,$31$&$ /#7.1,5'&53.1,$&0'.,,$5"#$*Y+$6'.@310#,$.2$5"#$@3#5$D13.1$31$5"#$=&5#$*KY)Z,$&1/$#&'=%$*KK)Z,$5.$0.1,5'805$&1$#,537&5#$.2$5"#$6.68=&'$/#7&1/$2.'$,#0#,,3.1:($$!"3,$&66'.&0"$"&,$&$187&#x. -1;&#x 000;#'$.2$/3,53105$&/@&15&-#,:$Q3',5=%?$5"#$=3&#x. -1;&#x 000;#'&=3F31-$'#2.'7,$.2$C3E"&3=$[.'&#x. -1;&#x 000;&0"#@$6'.@3/#/$&$"3,5.'30$431/.4$.2$.66.'58135%$2.'$,#6&'&53,5$6'.5#,5,$5.$5&E#$6=&0#$435".85$&#x. -1;&#x 000;#31-$,&#x. -1;&#x 000;8\#05$5.$5"#$0.10#'5#/$,866'#,, 0",3)+")&");'+5):";3,)!"#-'&3,*+'"#-)28)1"!*1)31'+3-.)�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x 1 0;(,#*$1"#5')-,?--$'1,(,-'1#4-'($.'($.'&/*?,"6'@/#-.0($'89:AA='5*1#,-.',"(,'1,(,-'1#4-'0(B')-'('2+$3,#*$'*2',"-'&*C-/$0-$,D1',B5-'*2'/-C-$+-E'#2'/-C-$+-',B5-1'C(/B'#$',-/01'*2'-22#3#-$3B6'F#$3-',"-1-'-(/&#x 1 0;B'3*$,/#)+,#*$1E',"-'&#x 1 0;#,-/(,+/-'"(1'&/*?$'&#x 1 0;(/&-'($.'.#C-/1-E'5(/,&#x 1 0;B'#$'/-15*$1-',*',"-'5/*&#x 1 0;#2-/(,#*$'*2'#$.-5-$.-$,'1,(,-1'(2,-/',"-'2(&#x 1 0;&#x 1 0;'*2',"-'F*C#-,'G$#*$'81--'&#x 1 0;H*,*$E'&#x 1 0;7*($.'($.'F&#x 1 0;5*(*/-'9::;E'(1'?-&#x 1 0;&#x 1 0;'(1'7+,('IJ'2*/'1+/C-B1=6'K'3*$1,/(#$'0B1-&#x 1 0;2'"-/-',*'*+,&#x 1 0;#$#$&'('$+0)-/'*2'%-B',"-0-1'#$',"-'&#x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�??�A4*E/"*+&:#( ',$"$1#,%&'2#$"-2(,/*$(%6(D$.*$(*%)-+.5,0(/(5,#(%6(-+%A.1*,5(D.#$(/($.'$(0,'+,,(%6(,*%1%).*(/10($.5#%+.*(5.)."/+.#7�(((B%A.,#(,*%1%).*(/10(6.5*/"(-%".*7(.1#,+/*#,0(D.#$(#$.5(6,0,+/"(575#,)(.1(5,A,+/"(D/75�(W1(#$,(%1,($/102(-"/11,+5(5#+%A,(#%(,`&/".],(.1#,++,'.%1/"(.1*%),(0.66,+,1*,5(:A/1(B,")(;NNa=2(D$.*$(#$,7(#+.,0(#%(/**%)-".5$(&5.1'(0.+,*#(6.5*/"(#+/156,+5(8,#D,,1(#$,(*,1#+/"(31.%1(8&0',#(/10(#$,(8&0',#5(%6(5&8%+0.1/#,(+,-&8".*/1('%A,+1),1#�5(C$+%&'$(#$.5(575#,)2(#$,(,*%1%).*/""7()%+,(0,A,"%-,0(D,5#,+1(31.%1(H,-&8".*5(8,*/),(1,#(0%1%+5(#%(#$,(-%%+,+(31.%1(H 3%/3/%5)/*#!(*#5)/*#!(%"3%"&"*5#5)/*()*(3"%&/**"!($"+)&)/*&:(;1)&("99"+5)2"!4(/%="$(5/(51"(#$2#*5#-"(/9("51*)+(&#x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x -5 ;"&$*'?(#2"3%*#*4$2&$*4#&+*#"%$#&1&2'&E'*#%"#�+%12"32&'#'*1*'6#X%12*$#2"3%*#;&$&#&+*#&'4%#"%$#;***;#$%#E*#1*+?#+*'2&E'*(#&4#&33%&#x -6 ;"$2"=#4$&";&+;4#;288*+*;#E*$:**"#+*0&#x -6 ;E'234(#&";#:&=*4#:*+*#"%$#&#=%%;#2";23&$%+#%8#&3$&#x -6 ;&'#2"3%*6#C#E*$$*+#2";23&$%+#24#0*+#3&02$%"&#x -11;&#x 000;40$2%"(#:)23)#$&H*4#2"3%*#8+%#&#x -7 ;"+*=24$*+*;#4%&#x -7 ;+3*4#2"$%#&33%&#x -7 ;"$#F[2$+&#&";#`*$4%1#9KKaM6#-#!$#)&4#$)*#&;;2$2%"&'#E*"*82$#$)&$#2$#24#+*3%+;*;#%"#�+%12"32&'#'*1*'6#7"*#;+&:E&3H#2=)$#E*#$)&$#2$#;%*4#"%$#$&H*#+*=2%"&''?#1&+?2"=#4&12"=4#+&$*4#2"$%#&33%&#x -2 ;"$6#D)24#3%&#x -2 ;';#E*#&"#244&#x -2 ;*(#=21*"#$)*#8&3$#$)&$#4&12"=4#2"#$)*#X%12*$#P"2%"#:*+*#'&+=*'?#/8%+3*;5(#26*6#3&&#x -2 ;4*;#E?#&#'22$*;#&1&2'&E2'2$?#%8#=%%;4(#:)23)#=)$#E*#+*=2%"#40*328236#!#$)*+*8%+*#&;] 10;&#x 000;4$#$)*#3%"4 10;&#x 000;$2%"#82=� 5 ;+*#� 5 ;42"=#$)*#+&$2%#%8#"*?#2"3%4#$%#+*$&2'#4&'*4#3%''*3$*;#8+%#)%&#x -8 ;4*)%';#E&#x -8 ;;=*$#4&#x -8 ;+1*?4#8%+#$)*#'*1*'#%8#P"2%"#+*0&#x -8 ;E'234#E?#b2#&";#X)2;&#F9K,.M6#D)*#+*4&#x -8 ;'$2"=#1&+2&E'*#!\Q7[ZYQ#3%"82+4#$%#:)&$#%"*#:%&#x -7 ;';#*V0*3$#8%+#$)*#0*+2%;N#!$#24#)2=)*+#2"#$)*#%+*#2";&#x -10;&#x 000;4$+2&'#&";#&#x -10;&#x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x -1 ;&#x -1 ;=@+'-+$*'-6+5+(&5**'0'(51'/-+*(3"2"*+0!/2+&'-6$'*1'(*+S"D'* G$*&'22'-/!'1'"*+357+%""-+5+*5&'"-1+'**$"+'-+X$**'5-+'2#"!'5&+3'*1/!;+P5##"&"!+&#x ] T;&#xJ ET;&#x Q q;&#x 0.2; 0 ;� 0.;$ 1;P.4;ٙ ;А.;™ c;&#xm BT;&#x 0.0;’ ;&#xTc 4; 0 ;� 45;&#x 0 0;&#x Tm ;&#x/TT5; 1 ;&#xTf [;&#x 000;&#x ] T;&#xJ ET;&#x Q q;&#x 0.2; 0 ;� 0.;$ 1;P.4;ٙ ;А.;™ c;&#xm BT;&#x 0.0;’ ;&#xTc 4; 0 ;� 45;&#x 0 0;&#x Tm ;&#x/TT5; 1 ;&#xTf [;&#x 000;=L@A+X"&'6'/-+(5-+13"!"0/!"+%"+*""-+5*+5-/13"!+'2#/!15-1+(&"5:56"A+F+'-(&$7"+5+7$22;+:5!'5%&"+G4KSFG+'0+5+!"6'/-+35*+5+G$*&'2+#/#$&51'/-+/0+2/!"+135-+T&#x ] T;&#xJ ET;&#x Q q;&#x 0.2; 0 ;� 0.;$ 1;P.4;ٙ ;А.;™ c;&#xm BT;&#x 0.0;’ ;&#xTc 4; 0 ;� 45;&#x 0 0;&#x Tm ;&#x/TT5; 1 ;&#xTf [;&#x 000;ZB+%5*"7+/-+13"+LMQM+("-*$*A++O'-5&&;B+'1+25;+%"+1351+3"1"!/6"-"'1;+/0+#!"0"!"-("*+7/"*+-/1+(/'-('7"+D'13+2"5*$!5%&"+'-7'("*+/0+"13-/ E/+5((/2#&'*3+13'*B+F+!"(/!7+13"+0'!*1+1'2"+5+#!/:'-("+(52"+$-7"!+13"+'-0&$"-("+/0+13"+G/*(/D+/!+K1+]"1"!*%$!6+6/:"!-2"-1+$*'-6+*15-75!7+3'*1/!'"*+/0+X$**'5-+'2#"!'5&'*2+5##"&"!+=&#xP -3;&#x 000;&#xP -3;&#x 000;L@+5-7+(/&/-'5&'*2+Y!";0/6&"+"1+5&+=&#x 4 0;&#x 4 0;Q@+5-7+13"+,!"51+K/:'"1+H-(;(&/#"7'5+LMQN@A+^3"!":"!+#/**'%&"B+F+15R"+13"+751"+1351+(/!!"*#/-7*+2/*1+(&/*"&;+1/+13"+#/'-1+'-+3'*1/!;+D3"-+#3;*'(5&+G$*(/:'1"B+ 3(-0',#-$9%-,#'%),'5$#/("&-,5':%/;1%)5#'2)(9'=&#x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�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x -4 ;+$)S,="$*)$Q8$%"-$&*)67(,)677,E()6)',-86%"(,&),#)*+$)8,8076%).$-6&.)#,%)($'$((",&)"&)6)%$",&)6&.)*+$)$Q*$&*)*,)E+"'+)*+$)%$",&T()7$6.$%()6'*06779)80%(0$.)6)($'$((",&"(*)8,7"'9C)&#x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x 6 0;+$%$)6%$)-6&9)%$6(,&()E+9)8,8076%).$-6&.)6&.)8,7"'9).$'"(",&()&$$.)&,*)/$)(9&,&9-,0(:)$=$&)"&).$-,'%6'"$(C)X,7"*"'"6&(),%)%07"&)$7"*$()-69)/$)-6Q"-"I"&)."##$%$&*)0*"7"*9)#0&'*",&(:),%),8$%6*"&)0&.$%)."##$%$&*)',&(*%6"&*(:)*+6&)*+$"%)',&(*"*0$&*(C)&#x 1 0;+$9)-69)67(,)+6=$)."##$%$&*)(,0%'$(),%)Y067"*9),#)"&#,%-6*",&)6/,0*)*+$)/$&$#"*(),%)',(*(),#)($'$((",&C))N&$)E69),#)-$6(0%"&).$'"(",&()*,)($86%6*$)"()*,)',0&*)*+$)&0-/$%),#)($86%6*"(*).$'76%6*",&()-6.$)/9)8%,="&'"67),=$%&-$&*(C)4)',&(*%0'*)*+"()=6%"6/7$)!1AD&#x 2 0;@?@4N5S)0("&).6*6)#%,-)&#x 2 0;%$"(-6&)KVZZ[MC)&#x 2 0;+$).6*6)',&=$9()*+$ &'33#&).-3$)"*)$(+;*($(#*5#%&$*%#$;+-&)%*.-#5$&+8#,"*)$/6$)"#$*8+'-)$+9$%#&+'%;#&$3%*-)#5$)+$)"#8$/6$)"#$9#5#%*($&6&)#82$$!"#$%#*&+-$,"6$#-;(*7#$&)*)'&$+-(6$8*))#%&$9+%$*')+;%*).;$5#;.&.+-$8�*.-3$;*-$*(&+$/#$*-&,#%#5$9%+8$5.99#%#-)$:#%&:#;).7#&2$A)$,+'(5$/#$;+-&.&)#-)$,.)"$&'::+&.-3$)"*)$(#*5#%&$*%#$/#))#%$.-9+%8#5$*/+')$)"#$;+&)&$+9$&';"$*$&#;#&&.+-$ 9%+8$)*/(#$01$*-5$&'::+%)$)"#$-+).+-$)"*)$&#:*%*).&)$:+(.;6$.&$5#)#%8.-#5$5.99#%#-)(6$9%+8$:+:'(*%$5#8*-5$9+%$&#:*%*).&82$0()"+'3"$&.4#$.&$&.3-.9.;*-)$*;%+&&$&:#;.9.;*).+-&$.-$.-;%#*&.-3$)"#$(.�#(."++5$+9$*-$#*%(6$#?.)$8+&)$8#*&'%#&$+9$"#)#%+3#-#.)6$*%#$-+)*-5$3#+3%*:".;*($5.&)*-;#$#?"./.)&$)"#$,%+-3$&.3-2$0&$.-$)"#$:%#7.+'&$#?#%;.&#)"#$&)*)'&$*&$*-$ 5/*")'!&.)!"#!'5/('-6!'!;.+-!"#!'/5'%'-(%)!J/55'7!-9!!"'+.3!'%")',/,*$%-./"'6!-!(/4!"!.-0'."'-6!'5/(=%-./"'/5'+-%-!+1'6.+'!&.)!"#!'+-!=+'5(/='!;%=."."4'K8LLM',(/J+!#!++./".+-',(/-!+-+'%#(/++'-6!' 23.(40(56%7'3(+.5%'8%#9'+':*9;()331()321CH32IJ)!"#$%&'()!*)'&+)@A9"'9=#()B*)0122456)%&#x=0 1;&#x 000;*?0%'8%!.4*'+;()K'E:=%+#)L!6)LMN)O=#$$)!"#$%&'()!*()/'P%=(),*)'&+)Q9R:S()K*)0122T56)O9"%8%-'")U;=%$+%-8%9&$)%&)Q#8#=9# $)K9EE;&%8%#$()7'3(+.5%'8%-'5*4*9.5%#9'+':61)3310156)&#x -3 ;4TH4?J*))!"#$%&'()!*()@A9"'9=#()B*)'&+)V'-F%'=(),*)0122256)B-9&9E%-)%&8#='8%9&)'&+)A9"%8%-'")+%$%&8#='8%9&()@:0(*9.+%#9'+':*9%$0A*0B()?20I5()31CJH31?J)!"#R##W()L*X*)'&+)Y'++S()K*Y*)03??456)M&-9E#)Z%$8=%:;8%9&)%&)8.#)[@@,)%&)8.#)3?&#x 1 0;2$(),#W%#\)9G)M&-9E#)'&+)V#'"8.()43035()14H4J)/#%$$%&#=()L*)0122156)7'8%9&'"%$8)L9:%"%F'8%9&)'&+)8.#)K9""'A$#)9G)8.#)@9W%#8)@8'8#()K'E:=%+#6)K[O)/9"89&(),*)'&+),9"'&+()Y*)03??C56)N.#):=#']H;A)9G)&'8%9&$6)!)A9"%8%-'")#-9&9ES)'&'"S$%$()23.(40(56%7'3(+.5%'8%#9'+':*9;()T2()32ICH&#x 2 0;32?)/9"89&(),*(),9"'&+()Y*)'&+)@A9"'9=#()B*)03??J56)B-9&9E%-)8.#9=%#$)9G)8.#):=#']H;A)'&+)%&8#='8%9&)9G)&'8%9&$()#3('/0.+%#9'+':*9%$0A*0B()T2()J?CHC2I)/=#SG9"#()7*/*()@-.='+#=()!*)'&+)@;&+#="'&+()V*)0#+$*5)0122C56)O#9A"%&)8.#),;$$%'&)O#=%A.#=S*)/9=+#="'&+)-9"9&%F'8%9&)%&)B;='$%'&).%$89=S()DR9&6),9;8"#+#))/;-.'&'&()U*L*)'&+)^'%8.(),*_*)03?&#x 2 0;C56)@#-#$$%9&)'&+)8.#)_%E%8$)9G)N'R'8%9&6)N9\'=+)')N.#9=S)9G)M&8#=&'")BR%8()@:0(*9.+%#9'+':*9%$0A*0B()CC0I5()3214H3243))K'E#=9&()!*K*)'&+)N=%W#+%()O*)0123456)$0,(0;;*'+%@+.56;*;%'8%C'3+4%D.4.()1&+)#+%8%9&()K'E:=%+)K[O))K'$#""'()!*)'&+)^#%&$8#%&()U*)0122156)O;:"%-)99+$)%&)8='+#6)9&)8.#)G9=E'8%9&)9G)E'=]#8$)'&+)`;=%$+%-8%9&$()E+40(+.4*'+.5%#9'+':*9%$0A*0B()T4015T4CHTJ1))K%--.#88%()K*U*()^=##E'&)MMM()!*L*()Q'W#E'&(),*Q*)'&+)a$-.()U*_*)03?C356)D&)8.#)B-9&9E%-$)9G)L'$$)Z#E9&$8='8%9&$6)!)K'$#)@8;+S)9G)8.#)79W#E:#=)3?J?)L'=-.)9&)V'$.%&89&() g9'A-!N,$M!D9A#PB!W&7&,'PS!g9'M#$%!D,=&'!`HH3!!fA9:7%j'-(!6*!0KHHb45!d$P&$�#^&7!:9'!7&P&77#9$!#$!�S&!='&7&$P&!9:!@9E#A&!&�S$#P!%'98=7(!(#)*$+,'#4'?)A,&"'!"#$#%&"1(!G3(! @)68!P4)%4!Q648#:$!OC5=68!:45!8G6!A6BCD$)7'2!E:'8!R@)56476!:45!QC##648!3B$)7:8)%4'*!!/$0$1*/)2$3245+00*06*!MS*!J/HT0!!A%D)4'%4*!R,U,V,!-65,1!-./KL12!78&2!/$0$1*/29$0)&:"&0/&)2$32-8&2,*;&2$32+-*$0) @37A!"%566!&"#$%#& %3A79!+(#!%I47I!R;"KGR!R+2-.�!*(*+-0=.(1!Y!96Z!345!"#)!%6755!"%3!GF$BR#&$! !$!$!(?�&"C($$!$!$!$!$!$! P078!B0H;7!6E6;24H24==;0!3076;!30=767=$!"!=;H:;36!67!784!&- -.5&3&.5&.6&!3+0*&/*/7!+&32$%-6#.!%&8&%7!908-&*!:.-0.!&#x=000;;4;@A&+04B.1%#*&5!C&D#*-8&!E-.0,-#%F!)&3&.5&.*! !105231B"""$!%$+(!10111/"""$!%$.+!10/231B"""$!%$&%!1031B"""$!%$&)!105231B"""$!%$'+!10111"""$!&$(.!10?231B""$!&$&%!:.C9%*%$$!$!$!$!/50B1"""$!%$(%!$!$!$!:%-.A=;@D$$!$!$!$!$!3"""$,*$()!310118"""$,+'$(!108231B""$!%$%(! ] ;&#xTJ E;&#xT Q ;&#xq 0.;$ 0;&#x 0 0;&#x.24 ;٣.;٧ ;Є.; cm;&#x BT ;3 0;&#x 0 3; 0 ;� Tm;&#x /TT;Ȥ ; Tf;&#x 000;=-:.A" ] ;&#xTJ E;&#xT Q ;&#xq 0.;$ 0;&#x 0 0;&#x.24 ;٣.;٧ ;Є.; cm;&#x BT ;3 0;&#x 0 3; 0 ;� Tm;&#x /TT;Ȥ ; Tf;&#x 000;*9.$$!$!$!$ !3107/"""$,%$'(!105/"""$!%$++!310/6"""$,%$&+!310B?"""$,%$*+!310/4"""$,%$&#!31046"""$,%$'-!1064""$!%$)&!+D(�;=$3/086"""$,-$'&!3"""$,*$-#!361"""$,*$%+!3/07?"""$,-$-+!3/077"""$,*$*&!3/07"""$,-$*-!3/047"""$,#$'(!310??""$,+$+.!$$!$!$!$!$!$!$!$!P0D-*!@3+&5-6*!QF!$ """$,'$'-!101118"""$!&$%(!1011B"""$!+$+'!36076"""$,&$'#!3101"""$,%$)(!101155"""$!%$.)!1011/1"""$!+$%#!1011/5"""$!&$&&!C%+(.*A.$360B4"""$,'$&*!35016"""$,&$).!3/05?"""$,+$*+!310B8"""$,%$+.!31078"""$,&$%*!3/01/"""$,&$--!310/7"""$,%$((!31078"""$,+$)-!"%;=-@;$$!$!$!$ 10111$10111$10111$10111$10111$(GE$(FT2JFSGGM$3864$3/54$34?6$38B8$35/$3B11$3B1$357B0$*$!1$GUP#$?4$!64#$?4$!64#$?4$!64#$?4$!64#$?4$!64#$?4$!64#$?4$!64#$?4$!5?#$/012345!617802$!94:;;7;0=5!=44!7&#x -1 ;47!676@A4!B& A4R4AF!""!=;G;:;367!67!784!*Q Markus Lampe and Paul Sharp New crops, local soils and urbanization: Clover, potatoes and the growth of Danish market towns, 1672-1901 Torben Dall Schmidt, Peter Sandholt Jensen, Amber Naz Longevity and the Rise of the West: Lifespans of the European Elite, 800-1800 Neil Cummins ÔCreative DestructionÕ: Chinese GDP per capita from the Han Dynasty to Modern Times Kent Deng and Patrick Karl OÕBrien The Drivers of Long-run CO2 Emissions: A Global Perspective since 1800 Sofia Teives Henriques and Karol J. Borowiecki State dissolution, sovereign debt and default: Lessons from the UK and Ireland, 1920-1938 Nathan Foley-Fisher and Eoin McLaughlin