Turning over a New Leaf of International Trade:

Transcript:Turning over a New Leaf of International Trade::
Turning over a New Leaf of International Trade: Eco-trade Policies at the WTO Michelle Zang Faculty of law Victoria university of Wellington Concept: eco-trade policies Eco-trade policy: the trade policies/measures that are enforced with the primary aim of climate improvement Format Examples: Technical regulation or specifications: energy efficient/carbon consumption labelling Grants and direct payments: subsidies for renewable energy production Import charges: EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism Import restrictive measures: EU Renewable Energy Directive (Palm oil) Mainly enforced domestically/unilaterally ; some through free (bilateral/regional) trade agreements The current development at the WTO Structured Discussions: Trade and Environmental Sustainability (November 2020, 74 members) Informal Dialogue: Plastics pollution and environmentally sustainable plastics trade (November 2020, 75 members) to explore how the WTO could contribute to efforts to reduce plastics pollution and promote the transition to more environmentally sustainable trade in plastics; Initiative: The Fossil Fuel Subsidy Reform (December 2021, 47 members) coordinated by New Zealand; to rationalize and phase out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies The WTO Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies (June 2022) Eliminating subsidies contributing to harmful fisheries the first WTO agreement to place an environmental objective at its core Question 1 do we still need “multilateral intervention”? YES! to maximize the effectiveness, transparency, coherence, and equality To avoid free riding opportunity for protectionist measures, i.e. hidden trade restrictions EU – Palm Oil dispute pending at the WTO Negotiation deadlock of Agreement on Climate Change, Trade and Sustainability (ACCTS) Question 2 what type of “multilateral intervention” is needed? The current WTO setting: exception-based module Exceptions in public international law; WTO exceptions: public moral, health, environment…. The insufficiency of exception model 1. normative hierarchy between trade and environment 2. indication of conflicts between trade and environment 3. chilling effects: legal uncertainties + heave burden of proof 4. chilling effects: reputation cost The WTO approach towards Eco-trade policies: time for a change Ideal scenario/ long term solution: new multilateral rules at the WTO specific focus on the environment/climate emergency; enforceable rights and obligations on the states; reflect the mutual supportive relationship between trade and environment/climate protection Less ideal reality consensus-based decision-making process; unclear outcomes of the ongoing initiatives and discussions The need for short term solution: updated and environment-focused interpretation of critical WTO rules Short term solution: updated interpretation of critical WTO rules Normative aim: eco-trade policy as an element of, rather than exception to, trade liberalization Step 1: avoid WTO violation through updated, environment-focused