UI Design & Disinformation Miguel Gutierrez, IRI
Description: UI Design Disinformation Miguel Gutierrez, IRI Research Fellow 19 Mentor: Lilian Coral, Knight Foundation disinformationdesign.github.io This is a web-based interactive essay and UX project that dissects the phenomenon of disinformation
Related Topics
Download Presentation
"UI Design & Disinformation Miguel Gutierrez, IRI" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this website for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Presentation Transcript
slide1. UI Design &
Disinformation Miguel Gutierrez, IRI Research Fellow ‘19
Mentor: Lilian Coral, Knight Foundation<br>
slide2. disinformationdesign.github.io This is a web-based interactive essay and UX project that dissects the phenomenon of disinformation online through the lens of product design.<br>
slide3. Research Question How do design elements or features of the user interface affect the distribution of disinformation?<br>
slide4. Main Takeaways<br>
slide5. Stanford Study, 2018 Compares engagement trends of “fake news” media between Facebook & Twitter
“Fake News” has declined more than 50 percent between the 2016 election and July 2018, using data tracked by the content marketing firm BuzzSumo.
The ratio of Facebook engagements to Twitter retweets on the 570 sites has fallen from about 40-to-1 to about 15-to-1, which implies that Facebook is still by far the larger fake news source. Facing Facts, 2017<br>
slide6. Methodology I first use the UI Theory and Case Study to form a basis of critical inquiry. Here, I can identify the following:
What is the relationship between the design object and audience
What is the nature of human psychology amidst digital information spaces
How has disinformation on Facebook evolved over time?
What design methodologies has Facebook employed?
What are the gaps in Facebook’s design given what we know about UI theory.
From these questions, I conducted ethnographic research on 31 UCLA students. This data then shaped a design proposal to help Facebook resist disinformation.<br>
slide7. Findings Facebook was better equipped at dismantling information after its publishing, but was lacking in means of prevention.
From the array of post-publishing measures, most students surveyed (approx 90%) had not known of their existence.
Facebook’s measures against disinformation were often too dependent on third-party fact checking
Design cannot reach its full potential if it is inhibited by speech politics.<br>
Disinformation Miguel Gutierrez, IRI Research Fellow ‘19
Mentor: Lilian Coral, Knight Foundation<br>
slide2. disinformationdesign.github.io This is a web-based interactive essay and UX project that dissects the phenomenon of disinformation online through the lens of product design.<br>
slide3. Research Question How do design elements or features of the user interface affect the distribution of disinformation?<br>
slide4. Main Takeaways<br>
slide5. Stanford Study, 2018 Compares engagement trends of “fake news” media between Facebook & Twitter
“Fake News” has declined more than 50 percent between the 2016 election and July 2018, using data tracked by the content marketing firm BuzzSumo.
The ratio of Facebook engagements to Twitter retweets on the 570 sites has fallen from about 40-to-1 to about 15-to-1, which implies that Facebook is still by far the larger fake news source. Facing Facts, 2017<br>
slide6. Methodology I first use the UI Theory and Case Study to form a basis of critical inquiry. Here, I can identify the following:
What is the relationship between the design object and audience
What is the nature of human psychology amidst digital information spaces
How has disinformation on Facebook evolved over time?
What design methodologies has Facebook employed?
What are the gaps in Facebook’s design given what we know about UI theory.
From these questions, I conducted ethnographic research on 31 UCLA students. This data then shaped a design proposal to help Facebook resist disinformation.<br>
slide7. Findings Facebook was better equipped at dismantling information after its publishing, but was lacking in means of prevention.
From the array of post-publishing measures, most students surveyed (approx 90%) had not known of their existence.
Facebook’s measures against disinformation were often too dependent on third-party fact checking
Design cannot reach its full potential if it is inhibited by speech politics.<br>