Chair STM Futures Lab Committee Beyond the article Scholarly publishing and data management Agenda Report from STM Future Lab Recent NISO activity IEEEspecific activities 2262013 ID: 806833
Download The PPT/PDF document "Gerry Grenier Senior Director, Publishin..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Gerry Grenier
Senior Director, Publishing Technologies, IEEEChair, STM Futures Lab Committee
Beyond the article: Scholarly publishing and “data management”
Slide2Agenda
Report from “STM Future Lab”Recent NISO activityIEEE-specific activities2/26/2013
2
Slide3Three framing aspects of “Data management” discussion
Data submitted along with a journal article“Supplemental material”Linking between “Big Data” to and from related journal articlesData hosted outside of the publisherData hosting via publisher repositories
2/26/2013
3
Slide4STM’s “Future Lab” Outlook on Data
International STM Association (http://stm-assoc.org) The leading global trade association for academic and professional publishers> 120 member publishing companies and societiesMembers collectively publish nearly 66% of all journal articles
Slide5Annual brainstorm to identify trends in STM publishing
18 contributing members of the committee including:Societies (IEEE, AIP, ACS, IOP, RSC)Traditional publishers (Wiley, Nature, Elsevier, Springer, OUP, Thomson-Reuters, Taylor & Francis)Open Access publisher (Hindawi)Committee meets annually to develop “STM Trend Watch”
December 2012
Slide6Data management issues emerged as a major theme two years running
Sense is that we see data management as looming large issue, but our actions are still in formative stageData discoverabilityInterfaces to dataGuidelines for:Re-use and sharingEditorial policiesCitationDatabase versioning
Curation
Data peer review
2/26/2013
6
Slide7Data Management Discussion
STM Future Lab
RESEARCH DATA
DATA OBJECTS ARE FIRST CLASS RESEARCH OBJECTS
MAKE DATA INTERACTIVE
share
the
actual
workflow
of the researcher?
graphics
represent
data sets;
how
to open
them
up?
ACTIONABLE DATA
DATA CREATION
What
formats
do
users
want?
COMMON STANDARDS
AUTHORING TOOLS
how
to
treat
supplemental files to journals?
Guidelines for:Reuse and sharingIncentives and barriersEditorial policies
Discoverability of data
BIG DATA
Deep Linking
REPOSITORIES
DATACITE
Bibliographic tools
User behaviour
Mendeley
CiteSeer
ColWiz
ReadCUBE
Data
journal
Slide8Validation, Verification,
Curation, Mining and Data: From
Validation
to
Augmentation
DATA
Altmetrics
, New
M
etrics
CURATION AND ANALYTICS
What
is the minimal NUGGET in
an
article
?
CROWD VALIDATION
HARD SHELL VERSUS
SOFT SHELL APPROACH
ANALYTICS IN THE ONLINE-ECOSYSTEM
Assertion
Tables
with
falsification
/
verification
statements
What
happens to
Peer Review
?CrossQuarry
Data curationQuality AssuranceData peer
reviewData miningTriple Stores, RDF’sData citationMining of referencesTHE QUANTIFIED ACADEMICTransparent Validation Tools
THE NEW IMPACT FACTORTURN DATA INTO MAPS
Improving
Data
from
others
ReliabilityFROM VALIDATION TO AUGMENTATION
Augmenting Manuscripts via
submisson systems
Where
is the innovation of manuscript
submisson
systems
?
CHANGING HOW PEOPLE
READ JOURNALS
Analytics
for the online
eco-system
Slide9Journal Supplemental Material: NISO releases NISO RP-15-2013
Recommended practice for “Online Supplemental Journal Article Materials”Differentiate between “Integral” and “Additional” contentDefines metadata and persistent identifiersPotential role for NISO to define standards around larger data sets
i.e. Discovery and Provenance metadata
Expand the work of
DataCite
?
2/26/2013
9
Slide10Linking to-from externally hosted data
Example: Data hosted at Australian National University Data CommonsAre there related journal articles?If so, provide mechanism to associate and link A simple citation 2/26/2013
10
Slide112/26/2013
11
Slide12IEEE considering its role as data repository
IEEE’s Strategic Planning Committee has identified data preservation as a strategic priorityIEEE’s focus in the EE and CS uniquely positions it to play a role in the vertical space2/26/2013
12
Slide13Sustainability questions in addition to technical issues
IEEE believes that the research community would value a public repository that holds data sets and makes them available to other researchersComplement institutional repositoriesChallenges include:Business Model (Sustainability)Data governance issueInteroperability and facilitation of re-use
2/26/2013
13
Slide14Two projects to provide focus
IEEE’s immediate next stepsWork with one of our societies to identify a large active data set to pilotSurvey plannedWork with data repositories to create links between data sets and related IEEE journal articlesPurdue and Stanford have reached out
2/26/2013
14
Slide15IEEE Data Management Survey of 45 Society Presidents
Does your Society use Big Data? In what sense?Do any of your publications publish papers on big data?
If yes, to 2, which publications and what aspects of big data?
Do you require data referenced in the results of a paper be
publicly
available?
If yes to 3, how do you expect the data to be made available?
Do you believe the IEEE should provide an archive for data?
If yes, do you believe a cost per
mb
is a reasonable model for sustainability and if not, can you suggest a model.
Is there anything else we should have asked about big data and your Society that you are willing to share?
Slide16Looking forward to a continuing dialog between publishers and the research community
g.grenier@ieee.org2/26/2013
16