A sequel to the hit PowerPoint presentation Modernism More than a mass of crudely drawn rectangles thank you very much link here in case you forgot that one Menand Louis Saved From Drowning Rev of ID: 813111
Download The PPT/PDF document "Post-modernism: When “confusing signal..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Post-modernism:When “confusing signals…give you verisimilitude”*
A sequel to the hit PowerPoint presentation,Modernism: More than a mass of crudely drawn rectangles, thank you very much. (link here, in case you forgot that one)
*
Menand
, Louis. “Saved From Drowning.” Rev. of
Hiding Man
, by Tracey Daugherty.
The New Yorker
23 Feb 2009: 68-76. 74.
Slide2Modernism Post-Modernism
“We can never be pre-modernist again…. We can never be modernist again.” – Menand 68The middle of the 20th century is often thought to have created a barrier: grotesqueries, interconnectedness, and technology have put innocence and certainty permanently beyond our reach. But…is this bad? Or just real?
Slide3 ModernismPost-modernism (Pomo)1. Hope for truth but critique of past efforts: an existential crisis
1. Loss of faith in “truths” and authority. Widespread use of air quotes.2. Attention to subjectivity but preference/admiration for The West remainsRadical decentralization: perspective, subjectivity
3. Meaning is difficult to find (c.f., Eliot [
online version
])
3. The exterior exists, but drawing interior conclusions should be avoided
4. Technological/industrial society poses dangers: discontinuity, disorientation, fragmentation
4. No choice but to get used to parody, instability, mockery, discontinuity, “play”, disorientation, fragmentation
5. Authorial imposition: authorship is not “natural”…notice it! Notice language!
5
.
Narratorial
imposition; challenge to authorship: pastiche, materials, audience as participant
Slide4Not a clear-cut division
Can argue – and disagree – about whether a particular piece is modernist or post-modernMore a philosophy about the state of the world than a literary “technique”ZeitgeistSome key pomo-linked terms, however:metafiction
simulacrum
i
ntertexuality
deconstruction
Slide5Conflict in AmericaSource: ThinkParadox.net. Painting by Rene Magritte, 1928-29.
Just as Modernism was a tough sell to Americans in the first half of the 20th
century, Pomo is an even tougher sell now: anti-traditional, anti-serious, anti-authority, anti-boundaries.
Even: rude.
Source: ThePublicInterest.freedomblogging.com. Painting by Robert Rauschenberg, 1955. Detail source: Boston.com.
Slide6We have met the enemy, and he is…Postmodernism? (page 1 of 2)Concerning these [postmodern] ideas, let us not mince words. The ideas are profoundly dangerous. They subvert our civilization by denying that truth is found by conscientious attempts accurately to portray a reality that exists independently of our perception or attitudes or other attributes such as race, ethnicity, sex or class.j
ournalist George Will, commencement speech at College of William and Mary, 1994The professors of humanities are in an impossible situation and do not believe in themselves or what they do. Like it or not, they are essentially involved with interpreting and transmitting old books, preserving what we call tradition, in a democratic order where tradition is not privileged…. The students just were not persuaded that what was being offered them was important. The loneliness and sense of worthlessness were crushing, so these humanists jumped on the fastest, most streamlined express to the future. This meant, of course, that all the tendencies hostile to the humanities were radicalized, and the humanities, without reservations, were pitched off the train.professor and critic Allan Bloom, in Closing of the American Mind , 1987 (353)[J]ust take a look at what these "postmodern" people like and at what they don't like in current art. They happen, I think, to be a
more dangerous threat to high art than old-time philistines ever were
. They bring philistine taste up-to-date by disguising it as its opposite, wrapping it in high-flown art jargon.
art critic Clement Greenberg,
Dobell Memorial Lecture
, 1979
Slide7We have met the enemy, and he is…Postmodernism? (page 2 of 2)[P]ostmodernism subscribes to the notion that the human mind is incapable of knowing the real world because there is no world out there that exists separately from our senses. In other words, everything that exists is all in our heads.
And, furthermore, what's in your head is no better than what's in my head.blogger/scientist “Dr. Sanity”, 2009Conservative academics have long attacked "postmodernist" philosophies for questioning whether "truth" exists at all and claiming that what we take as "truths" are merely "narratives" woven around some ideological predisposition.journalist E.J. Dionne, Washington Post, 2005Modernism’s displacement of the Church, monarchy, and aristocracy from positions of power and privilege continues to be deeply resented among conservatives.critic Christopher L.C.E. Whitcomb on arthistoryresources.net, originally 1997
Slide8So…what do we do?
How should/can one live in the so-called Postmodern era: resist, succumb, revel, mourn, struggle to make sense, rage, plunge one’s head in the sand?