Ruth Jin Esq rjinjinlexcom J une 19 2015 The JIn Law Group PLLC All Rights Reserved wwwjinlexcom 1 Introduction Table of Contents What is Sweat Equity Page 3 ID: 562475
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "SWEAT EQUITY ISSUES IN EARLY STAGE BUSIN..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
SWEAT EQUITY ISSUES IN EARLY STAGE BUSINESSRuth Jin, Esq.rjin@jinlex.comJune 19, 2015
© The JIn Law Group, PLLC All Rights Reserved.www.jinlex.com
1Slide2
IntroductionTable of Contents:
What is “Sweat Equity”? Page 3Designing Equity Compensation Page 5 Restricted Stock Page 6Options or Warrants Page 9
Phantom Stock and SARs Page 14Performance Stock Page 15
Profits Interests Page 16
Choice of Entity Page 17
Founders’ as Employees Page 20
© The
JIn Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.www.jinlex.com
2Slide3
What is “sweat equity”?SCENARIO:
Adam and Betty decided to start a business together. Adam will contribute $100,000, but Betty has no money but will work 20 hours/day and is the heart and soul of the business.Adam and Betty hope to own NewCo 50/50.
PROBLEM WITH “SWEAT EQUITY”:Upon receiving 50% of
NewCo
, Betty has taxable income $100k.
Calculation: Adam gets 50% of
NewCo in exchange of $100k
NewCo’s Value x 50% = 100k NewCo’s Value = $200k Betty gets $100k value of security upon receiving 50% of
NewCo
.
Future Services is not a contributable asset under Code Section 83(a) Betty pays 35% ordinary income tax.
There is no such thing as “Founders’ Stock”.
© The JIn Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.www.jinlex.com
3Slide4
What is “sweat equity”?SOLUTION:
Issue “Grid” Notes: Adam put $1k and loan NewCo $99K payable in 7yrs or convertible to equity; orIssue Restricted Stock to Betty (subject to forfeiture) if Betty is willing.
PARTNER #3 or Employee #1 Comes Along:
In year 2,
NewCo
is worth $500k but no profit yet.
David, IT expert, wants to join NewCo as COO, and Adam and Betty wants to give David 10% of
NewCo (=$50k at the time of grant).David doesn’t want to pay taxes on $50k, and A/B don’t want to pay David’s tax liability. .© The JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
4Slide5
Designing equity compensation
Equity Compensation Options:Restricted StockOptions or Warrants with vesting schedule“Phantom” Stock Plan
Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)Performance Stock
Companies
often
use
equity
compensation as a retention tool by requiring the holder to continue to provide services to the company through each vesting date.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com.5Slide6
Designing equity compensationRESTRICTED STOCK
:Pro: Shares of restricted stock are actual equity of the company that carry restrictions on transfer and sale that lapse over a specified vesting period or upon the achievement of specified vesting conditions.Retention and incentive tool.
Designing Restricted Stock:First, the Restricted Stock must be created by
NewCo’s
governing documents, equity compensation plan or award agreement.
The vesting of restricted stock can be accelerated upon a change-in-control event (Ex: sale of company).
Vesting can also be accelerated upon termination without cause or termination due to death or disability.
NewCo can award shares of restricted stock outright or it can require holders to pay a purchase price for the stock.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
6Slide7
Designing equity compensationRESTRICTED STOCK
:The plan or award agreement should specify the holder’s rights as shareholders with respect to unvested shares of restricted stock. Unless otherwise provided, the default rule is that because shares of restricted stock are considered actually issued upon grant, holders generally have same dividend rights and voting rights as other shareholders.
Can create non-voting class with different dividend rights.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
7Slide8
Designing equity compensationRESTRICTED
STOCK:How Is It Taxed?Restricted Stock is not taxed on grant. Holder recognizes taxable income on vesting (only when there’s no substantial risk of forfeiture).
Taxable income = FMV of shares upon vesting – purchase priceHolder can elect to recognize taxable income in the year of grant. Then taxable income = FMV of shares upon grant – purchase price
Such Section 83(b) election must be filed with the IRS and
NewCo
within 30 days of the grant date.
After making the election and paying initial taxes, Holder pays no more taxes on the subsequent vesting.
If Holder later sells the vested shares, any appreciation in value is subject to 15% capital gain’s tax and not 30% ordinary income.Disadvantage: If Holder filed 83(b) election and his stock is forfeited before vesting, can’t get the paid tax refunded -> could end up with nothing.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
8Slide9
Designing equity compensationOPTIONS
:What is Stock Option?It gives the holder the right to buy shares of company stock at specified price.
NewCo can grant the option fully vested or with a vesting period specified in the grant notice. Retention and Incentive Tool
Ex:
NewCo
grants David options to buy 200 shares of Company Stock to be vested in 4 equal installments on each anniversary of grant date or to be vested in full upon certain achievement or trigger events.
NewCo
can put acceleration clause for change-in-control or termination without cause or termination due to death or disability.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com9Slide10
Designing equity compensationOPTIONS
:How Is It Taxed?Incentive Stock Options (ISOs)ISOs are not taxed on grant, vesting or exercise.
Holder has taxable income or deductible loss when s/he sells the shares after exercising the options. If Holder has held them more than 1 yr
after exercise and 2
yrs
after grant, he pays capital gain’s tax.
If not, it will be treated as NSO.
To qualify, the options must satisfy several requirements of Code Section 422Company may only grant ISOs to employees. Directors and consultants are not eligible.ISOs must be exercisable while employed or no later than 3 months after termination (exception: death (expiration) & disability (1yr))
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com10Slide11
Designing equity compensationOPTIONS
:How Is It Taxed?Incentive Stock Options (ISOs)c) ISOs must only be granted pursuant to a written plan approved by shareholders within 12 months before or after the plan’s adoption (# of shares and employee classification/eligibility).
d) Grant ISOs within 10 yr from plan adoption; expire in 10 yrs.e) Exercise price must be no less than the FMV of the underlying share as of Grant Date.
Exception: if Grantee owns more than 10% of all outstanding stock, 110% of the FMV.
f
) Plan or Award Agreement must provide that ISOs can only be transferred by will or the laws of descent and must be exercisable by the Holder during his lifetime.
g) For each employee, the aggregate FMV of shares thru exercising ISOs (at the time of grant) that are exercisable for the first time in any calendar year cannot exceed $100k.© The JIn Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
11Slide12
Designing equity compensationOPTIONS
:How Is It Taxed?2. Non-statutory Stock Options (NSOs)More flexible than ISOs and can be issued to all types of service providers (employees, directors, independent contractors).
Do not have to issue them at FMVAre not subject to holding period restrictions.
Taxed at ordinary income tax rate on exercise price – FMV
How to Be Exempt from Section 409(A)
Exercise price at least the FMV at grant date.
Issued as service recipient stock.
Contains no deferral features.© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
12Slide13
Designing equity compensationPHANTOM STOCK ; STOCK APPRECIATION RIGHTS (SARs); PERFORMANCE STOCK
When They Are Appropriate?Founders don’t want to give out equity and voting rights, but only share the economic value of
company’s equity.Company already has
an equity compensation plan,
but wants to provide additional equity
incentives
without providing stock.
The company is a division of another company, but can create a measurement of its equity value and wants employees to have a share in that even though there is no actual stock.Company
is
a
nonprofit
(meaning, no shares of company stock)© The
JIn Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.www.jinlex.com
13Slide14
Designing equity compensation
Phantom Stock:NewCo sets “bench mark” at $1m and David gets 10% of actual increase in value above $1m, in cash.David is taxed only upon payment; but no voting right or deductible loss.
SARs
Holder has right to receive the excess of the FMV of equity – exercise price.
Similar to options but no actual purchase of shares upon exercising.
Typically has a vesting based on time and/or performance.
Company can pay out either in cash or stock.
Company can offer acceleration upon death/disability/termination without cause or change-in-control).Taxed like NSOs.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
14Slide15
Designing equity compensation
Performance Stocks:Company agrees to issue a # of shares to David based on achievement of specified performance milestones after a measurement period.Ex: In 3 years, if ABC happen, issue up to 100 shares (target share)
If in 3 yrs
, only AB happened, issue 2/3 of the target number of shares
If in 3
yrs
, more than ABC happened, issue 150% of target number.
Or “or or nothing” approach: If all of ABC don’t happen in 3 yrs, zero shares.Different from Restricted stock:
Company doesn’t actually issue performance shares until it vests v. Company issues restricted shares on grant date..
Company issues restricted stock as a flat number of shares, but issues performance shares with up-side or down-side possibility.
How Is It Taxed:
It’s not taxed upon grant.
Taxed at ordinary income tax rate upon actual issuance of shares.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
15Slide16
Designing equity compensation
Profits Interest:Available only for partnerships and LLCs.The holder has the right to participate in the future income and growth in value of the awarded units. Ex: Class B can be defined as “profits interest” and David can get # of Class B Units equal to 10% of
NewCo equity.It can have vesting and forfeiture upon termination.
Profit interests are not “capital interest”
Often not taxed upon grant but taxed upon receiving the distribution (exceptions)
Often no voting; no management.
Created in the LLC operating agreement.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
16Slide17
What entity should you choose?
Types of Entities:Sole Proprietorship: Pro: No formation; file one tax return; no partner to compromise with; easy decision making.
Con: Unlimited personal liability; pay self-employment tax; no transferability-lack of continuity -> difficulty retaining talents; difficulty in raising capital.
Partnership:
Flexible allocation of loss and profit; wider knowledge and skill pool; attraction to employees to become partner.
Unlimited personal liability for GP; decision making is harder.
C corporation
Limited liability for all owners; unlimited life and transferability; easier to raise capital; tax free fringe benefits.Double taxation; harder to make decisions; higher compensation; accumulated earnings tax.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
17Slide18
What entity should you choose?
Types of Entities: 4) S Corp: NYC doesn’t recognize S corp status
5) Limited Liability Company:
Pro: limited liability to all owners; no double taxation; flexibility of allocating profits and losses among members; no ownership restrictions as S Corps.
Cons: Self employment tax just like Sole Proprietorship; Medicare Tax.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
18Slide19
What entity should you choose?
Entity Comparisons based on Taxes: $500k in Income with No Salary
© The JIn Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.www.jinlex.com
19
C Corp
LLC
34% Corporate Income tax:
$500k x 34% = $170k
No corporate tax
Individual Owner Tax: $330k x 20% = $66k
High Income
Addit
Med Tax: $80k x 3.8% = $ 3040
Individual Owner:
Social Security tax: $117k x 12.4% = $14k
Medicare Tax: $461,750 x 2.9% = $13,391
High Income Addit Med Tax: $221.750 x 0.9% = $1,906
Fed. Income Tax: $486,508 x 27.64% = $134,318
Total Tax: $239,040
Total Tax: $164.123Slide20
What entity should you choose?
Entity Comparisons based on Taxes: 2) $500k in Income With Salary of $300K: C Corp: $207K LLC: About $163K
FOUNDERS AS EMPLOYEES
C Corporation:
Betty is the CEO and Betty’s annual salary is $250K; Adam is the CFO and his annual salary is $250k.
If the compensation is too high compared with equity contribution and revenue, and if it is a C corp., the IRS will characterize it as dividend.
If Compensation is too high, it’s a red flag and the IRS may audit.
Compensation must be “reasonable.”
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
20Slide21
What entity should you choose?FOUNDERS AS EMPLOYEES
2. S Corporation:Betty is the CEO and Betty’s annual salary is $10K; Adam is the CFO and his annual salary is $10k. If the compensation is too low compared with equity contribution and revenue, and if it is an S corp., the IRS will characterize it as dividend.
If Compensation is too low, owners can avoid social security tax.
Compensation must be “reasonable.”
3. LLCs
If compensation is too low, not an issue for the owners. Social security taxes are due for partnership
p
rofits allocation and guaranteed payments alike.Two prong tests: (1) payment is reasonable in relation to services performed; AND (2) payment was intended to be compensation.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
21Slide22
What entity should you choose?FOUNDERS AS EMPLOYEES
“Reasonableness” StandardJudicial reliance:Objective criteria such as
BoD approvalDisinterested shareholder approval
Payroll tax treatment
Deducted as salary in books and records
Employee’s qualifications
The nature, extent, and scope of the employee’s work
The size and complexities of the businessA comparison of the salaries paid with the gross income and net profit of the business.
The market practice.
A comparison b/w salaries and distributions to owners.
Subjective Criteria: What would an independent investor do?
© The
JIn Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
22Slide23
What entity should you choose?FOUNDERS AS EMPLOYEES
Subjective Criteria: What would an independent investor do?If the rate of return is high, the performance of the CEO is really amazing, would an independent investor want to compensate this CEO with the same amount of salary, bonus and incentive stocks?
If yes, it’s an indication that the compensation is reasonable.
© The
JIn
Law Group, PLLC. All Rights Reserved.
www.jinlex.com
23Slide24
Upcoming eventsHow to Buy and Sell a RestaurantJuly 10, 2015 (12.00-1.30pm)JOBS ACT Regulation A+: Capital Raising for Small BusinessesSeptember 15, 2015 (12.00-1.30pm)
www.jinlex.com The JIn Law Group (c) All Rights Reserved.24Slide25
The Jin Law GroupThank you!See you next time!www.jinlex.com The JIn Law Group (c) All Rights Reserved.25