Ç ok F Bozkurt Ş Ş ener T Paper presented at the Surrey PIDOP Conference on Political and Civic Participation April 16 th 17 th 2012 University of Surrey Guildford UK ID: 531375
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Mapping the Varieties of Perspectives on..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Mapping the Varieties of Perspectives on Civic and Political Participation of Youth, Women and Minorities/Immigrants in Turkey
Çok F.; Bozkurt Ş.; Şener T.
Paper presented at the Surrey PIDOP Conference on “Political and Civic Participation”, April 16
th
-17
th
, 2012, University of Surrey, Guildford, UKSlide2
General framework and overview
The aim of this paper is to map discourses on civic and political participation in Turkey in relation to women, youth and minority/immigrant groups. D
ominant paradigms embodied in the perspectives of public authorities and NGOs, and the counter arguments and recent public agenda/media coverage are tried to be underlined.Slide3
General framework and overview
This analysis is based on an examination of the policy documents/reports produced between 2004 and 2011 by the public institutions and NGOs working in the fields of youth, women and minorities/migrants in Turkey. In total 34 documents were reviewed, the distributions are
shown in Table.1, are incorporated in the study.Distribution of Reviewed Documents by Target Groups youthwomenmigrant/minorityTotalPublic
683
17
NGO
6
7
4
17
Total
12
15
7
34Slide4
Representation of Women issues in
the documentsMain Focus of Documents (Governmental)
Protection of the family unity, social solidarity, struggle against poverty and social exclusionHuman rights, gender equalityPrevention of domestic violencePrevention of honour killings Slide5
agenda of public institutions
and media on womenLegal improvements
in juridical procedures in favour of victim women.Public institutions concern with women mainly if they are victims.Restricted participation of women in the parliament and the government (higher representation of women in the main opponent party, new %30 quota? in implementation, there are problems.)Slide6
Existence of a few influential
women parliamentarians recently in the parliamentMore media
coverage of victim women (domestic violence, women murders, sexual harressment/abuse)More media coverage of successful women (successes of key women figures)Slide7
agenda of Civil society organisations
/NGOS on womenIncrease in number and representation
in the public NGOs have contributed to the politicization of formerly domestic/private issues such as sexual harressment and violence againt womenNGOs have been increasingly interested in women’s conventional forms of participation (such as their more representation in the parliament, encouragement for voting) NGOs have increasingly stressed the prevention of
discrimination against women in the educational and economic spheresSlide8
Representation of youth issues in the
documentsHuge population and youth
population (about 11-12 million) Slide9
Youth unemployment
Youth unemployment rate (%)
1985199019952000200120022003200420052006
200720082009
2010
Greece
24,2
23,3
27,9
29,5
28
26,8
26,8
26,9
26
25,2
23
22,1
25,8
32,9
Italy
33,9
31,5
31,9
29,7
2726,326,323,52421,620,321,325,427,8Portugal199,615,78,69,411,614,515,316,116,216,616,52027,7Spain43,830,240,425,320,822,222,72219,717,918,224,637,941,6Turkey...1615,613,116,219,220,520,619,919,12020,525,319,7EU15......20,314,914,314,815,516,216,916,215,215,719,920,4EU27.........17,417,418,118,318,718,917,515,715,820,121,1
Huge
Youth
Unemployment
(
app
. %20-25) Slide10
Youth unemployment and
related problemsYoung women and
unemploymentUnregistered/informal employment and lack of social security Mismatch of training and work life Compulsory military service Slide11
Representation of youth issues in the
Governmental documentsLack of a comprehensive youth
policydespite the existence of huge youth population and the presense of a Ministry for Sports and Youth Lack of a policy concerning youth participationLack of policies/priorities/practices concerning different youth categories such as ethnic and cultural groups, sexual orientation and disabled youthSlide12
agenda of public institutions on youth
Discourses on youth which tend to polarise them in relation to their religious identitiesPrime Minister’s declaration of government’s aim to raise a ‘conservative/religious youthImplicit prioritization of religion in educational system (
assignment of religious teachers as school principles, compulsory religion courses)Slide13
agenda of public institutions on youth
regarding educationMany more young
people in the higher education in spite of low quality of educational institutions Promotion of distance education Establishement of more youth centres and sport facilities More budget for youth sport competitions and sports training Slide14
Agenda of parents and
schools for youth participationDiscouragement (
even banning) of active forms of civic and political participation due to protective parental attitudes and political polarization among the youth in the recent past, 1960, 1971, 1980 military interventions contributed to the avoidance of being very active. Slide15
agenda of Civil society organisations/
NGOs on youthUN-related organisations attempt
for promoting sexual health of different youth categories including youth in education and out of education youth. Public campaigns for increasing schooling of girls especially from disadvanted backgroundsSlight increase in the numbers of youth organizations and activities promoting especially civic engagement of young individuals Slide16
Representation of minority/immigrant issues
in the documentsThe conception of
‘minority’ in Turkey implies differences from most of the European countries. According to the Turkish Constitution, the concept of citizenship does not include any reference to one’s ethnic and/or religious identity. It is estimated that there are about 50 different ethnic groups in the current nation of Turkey. Legally all citizens without reference to their ethnic or religious backgrounds have equal rights and obligations. Since the foundation of the Turkish Republic, the only protection for minorities has been that set out in the 1923 with the Treaty of Lausanne. In the Treaty only the non-Muslim populations are defined as minorities (Minority Rights Group International, 2007). Slide17
Representation of minority/immigrant issues in
the documentsIn the process of
creation of a nation state ideology by Atatürk on the basis of single national identity had been emphasized.Slide18
Representation of minority/immigrant issues
The conception of immigration has quite different
meanings in Turkey stemming from rich cultural heritage, consisting of a variety of cultural populations and transition from Ottoman Empire to Turkish RepublicMost of the Turkish citizens have trans-generational immigration storyImmigrants in Turkey are not visible as they are in Europe and they do not have a strong immigration identity except from recent immigrants from
Middle Eastern and European countries. High ratios of illegal immigration to
Turkey
recentlySlide19
Representation of minority/immigrant issues
in the Governmental documentsLack of a comprehensive
strategy for minority/immigrant issues.Lack of registered data on ethnic minorities and immigrants.The project team choose working with Roma and Bulgarian resettlers as minority groups which have different characteristics and problems in the participation processes. Slide20
agenda of public institutions and
NGOs on minorities and immigrants
Slight coverage of promotion of life standards of Roma peopleRecent projects of NGOs for the imrovement of living conditions of Bulgarian resettlers Focus on Kurdish issue more than before and more than other ethnic and cultural populations.If Kurdish people are minority is a controversial issue due to their high ratio.Alevi issue has been central in
terms of religious minority for years but they still have problems in relation
to
their
religious
rights
Slide21
General ConclusionLimited
number of available documents regarding policies for youth
, women and minorities/immigrants.Slight increase of attention and promotion of participation of women in civil and political lifeDespite huge youth population and the existance of a Ministry for Youth and Sports, there is almost no long term policies and strategies for youth participationAlmost no comprehensive policies for minorities/immigrants Slide22
The PIDOP project is supported by a grant received from the European Commission 7th Framework Programme, FP7- SSH-2007-1, Grant Agreement no: 225282, Processes Influencing Democratic Ownership and Participation (PIDOP) awarded to the University of Surrey (UK), University of
Liège (Belgium), Masaryk University (Czech Republic), University of Jena (Germany), University of Bologna (Italy), University of Porto (Portugal), Örebro University (Sweden), Ankara University (Turkey) and Queen’s University Belfast (UK)