By Constance Sibanda Background 1 ICTs have become one of the crucial building blocks for a better education ICT in education is the application of technology within the context of education ID: 186623
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "The OLPC XO, Intel Classmate PC and A..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
The OLPC XO, Intel Classmate PC and Asus Eee PC user study
By
Constance Sibanda
Slide2
Background [1]
ICTs have become one of the crucial building blocks for a better education
ICT in education is the application of technology within the context of education
ICTs are often out of the reach of the poor and those in rural areas for a number of reasons:
Lack of appropriate products;
Insufficient funds;
Insufficient knowledge;
Language barriersSlide3
Background [2]
The recent creation of small, low cost and low powered laptops called netbooks, are seen as possible solutions to allow integration of ICTs in education in these disadvantaged communities
The recently created netbooks include:
the OLPC XO laptop
the Intel Classmate
the Asus Eee PC
the Lenovo mini-netbookSlide4
Aim of the project
The aim of the project was to evaluate the suitability and intuitiveness of OLPC XO, Intel Classmate PC and Asus Eee PC within an educational context for previously disadvantaged learners at a secondary school level.
It is hoped that this project will help contribute to the decision making processes in providing ICTs in schoolsSlide5
Methodology [1]
A user study was undertaken as a means of conducting assessment
Three teachers and three learners from previously disadvantaged schools in Grahamstown were chosen to participate in the project.
The teachers were chosen by their school principals based on their commitment and interests in the research
The teachers in turn chose the learners they wanted to work with, concentrating on responsible learners from the schoolSlide6
Methodology [2]
Pre intervention questionnaires were first distributed to both the learners and teachers.
This provided information about their computer literacy and their views concerning the use of ICTs in education
However, limited questionnaire responses were obtained from participantsSlide7
Methodology [3]
15 minutes interviews were conducted with the participants after they had spent 2 weeks with each laptop
This allowed them to draw out their experience with the netbook
The interviews were recorded using HP Compaq nx9010 laptop, Compact 4 Mixing Desk and two 130
0
_
Shure
Microphones
Microsoft Word was used to transcribe the recorded interview
When I was analysing the information obtained from the interviews, I took note of the comments that were made concerning the
learnability, memorability, effectiveness and efficiency
and of each netbook
The advantages and disadvantages of each netbook that were mentioned by participants were also taken into considerationSlide8
Results [Intel Classmate]
The learners in this user study felt that the Intel Classmate was the most intuitive of the netbooks
Learnability and Memorability
: The participants found it easy to learn how to use the Edubuntu interface installed on this netbook. They also did not struggle to remember what they had learnt about the computer
Efficiency
:
Participants completed their task at a much faster rate using this netbook.
This was as a result of
;
An easy to use interface
The faster speed of the netbook when compared to the other netbooks(this was expected because the processor speed is triple that of the OLPC XO and almost double that of the Asus Eee.
The
larger screen display made it easier to use and caused less strain on the eyesSlide9
Results [Intel Classmate]
Effectiveness
:
The carry handle makes it easy to carry around without a bag
The learners loved the webcam
Teachers felt that the Intel Classmate was very useful during teaching
However
the absence of a VGA port limited its use in teaching because it could not be used together with a projector for classroom presentations or demonstrationsSlide10
Results [Asus Eee]
Participants also found the Asus Eee suitable for secondary school education
Learnability and Memorability
: Asus Eee and the Intel Classmate were installed with identical Edubuntu netbook remix images and the participants again did not struggle using the interface
Efficiency
:
Though the speed of this netbook is slower than that of the Intel Classmate, it is much faster than that of the OLPC XO hence
the speed at which participants completed their task was not hampered.
The participants again felt that the interface was easy to use
However,
it was criticised for its small screen which caused eye strain for some participantsSlide11
Results [Asus Eee]
Effectiveness
:
It was usable for class presentations because of the presence of a VGA port
Its portable nature was highlighted as advantageous, making it easy to carry around.
However,
it was criticised for the absence of a webcamSlide12
Results [OLPC XO]
The OLPC had a poor reception from the participants due to a feeling that it is intended for younger learners (this was expected because it was primarily targeted to small children)
Learnability and Memorability
: Because the OLPC XO comes with a custom operation system and software, it was difficult for the participants to familiarise themselves with the unconventional operating system interface.
Efficiency
: Participants had a bad interaction with the netbook due to;
The low speed of the OLPC XO (this again was expected as the processor speed of the OLPC XO is less than that of both the Asus Eee and the Intel Classmate)
unconventional operating system interface
the cursor that got “stuck”Slide13
Results [OLPC XO]
Effectiveness
:
The mesh network played a role in collaborative learning
The carry handle makes it easy to carry
It was felt by the participants that this netbook is rugged and can endure being dropped.Slide14
Conclusion
At the end of the user study, participants were asked to highlight their overall preference
The participants in this study found the Intel Classmate to be the most intuitive netbook for learners.
One leaner said “
The laptop is just great. It was love at first sight. It is just beautiful and attractive. The features it has are just what you want to work with.
”
One of the teachers commented saying “
Umm, this Intel classmate, if you ask me to recommend it for students, it becomes number one.
”
It would be a good idea for the SA DOE to invest in such devices for secondary school learnersSlide15
Conclusion
Both the Asus Eee and the Intel Classmate were found suitable for teaching purposes.
Teachers should be given an opportunity to choose the most appropriate for the task at hand. i.e. Asus Eee for class presentations
It would not be a good idea to place the OLPC XO in secondary schools as it seems to be inappropriate at that level
One learner said
“It is not really good enough for me honestly, it is a little too like a kindergarten toy for a small child but I like it a lot.”
The unconventional interface could also be challenging to primary school children hence further investigation is neededSlide16
Thank you for your time
Any Questions?