Affirmative Basics Basics of being affirmative If you can convince the judge that passing your affirmative plan is a good idea you will win the debate Essentially you need to prove that the affirmative is better than the status quo current system ID: 161547
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Welcome to debate!" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Welcome to debate!
Affirmative BasicsSlide2
Basics of being affirmative
If you can convince the judge that passing your affirmative plan is a good idea, you will win the debate. Essentially, you need to prove that the affirmative is better than the status quo (current system).
To do this, you need to prove that the advantages of the
aff
plan are larger than the disadvantages. Slide3
How to prepare your 1AC
Both partners should practice reading the 1AC. It will make you a more fluid speaker and will help you to learn the details of your proposal. You will need to know it well to defend against counter arguments and to look competent in cross-ex.
The 1A should be particularly clear and fluid with the 1AC. Make sure that you do not mispronounce words (which can hurt your credibility). Your goal is to create an excellent first impression.
Both partners should create “pre-flows” of the 1AC
.
Let’s make a set now. Slide4
How to prepare your 1AC
The 1AC should be carefully highlighted.
Only highlight is you plan to read less than the underlined portions of the card.
Highlight to save time but do not lose essential arguments made in the cards.
How do you decide what is important? It is a judgment call. What arguments might you use in later speeches.
Let’s do this now. Slide5
How to prepare for the 2AC
The good news is that
aff
team
can expect most of what the negative will argue.
You know your
aff
well, you can look at the DAs they can run against you, and you can look at the case arguments they can run against you.
The bad news is that you must cover every single negative argument. This means that both partners must carefully flow the 1NC. If you miss a negative argument, you will not respond to it and they will automatically win that point.
Only jot down arguments that you plan to make on your flow. NEVER write out arguments long hand. It will set you up for poor flowing that will cost you the debate if the other team is any good. Slide6
How to prepare for the 2AC
Look over all of the DAs that they could run against you. Prepare a list of 6-10 answers that you plan to make against those DAs.
Variety and offense will be the keys to winning.
Integrate both evidence and analytical arguments into your prepared answers. Slide7
How to prepare for the 2AC
Common types of
aff
answers to DAs (pick and chose what looks good based on the situation)—all MUST have explanation:
No link (the plan does not cause the DA)
The link is non-unique (other things should have caused the link)
The impact is non-unique (other things should have already caused the impact)
No internal link (the DA makes a logical leap that does not make sense)
Link turn (the opposite of the link is true—the affirmative prevents the DA from happening)
Impact turn (their impact is actually a good thing—FYI do not impact and link turn in the same debate)
No impact (they exaggerate the impact)
Aff
case solves the impact (our proposal is key to preventing the DA impact)Slide8
How to prepare for the 2AC
Let’s pick one of the DA’s and write out a list of answers that you think that you should make. Pick cards and make analytical arguments. Each person will read at least one argument out loud and we will compile the best ones for the whole group to use.
Do this on your own vs. each DA and you will be extremely well prepared. Slide9
How to prepare for the 2AC
You should also prepare answers against case arguments that they can read against you.
You should particularly be ready to answer the arguments they make in the frontlines.
Be smart about spending more time on better arguments and try to quickly get through arguments that are nit-picky/unimportant.
If two similar arguments are made in a row, you can say “group the __ and __ arguments” and then respond to both at once.
If two similar arguments are made that are not next to each other, answer them the first time and then say “Cross-apply my answers to the number ___” the second time.
Read new cards if you need to but you should first consider if you have a card in the 1AC that answers the argument. If so, say “extend the ___ evidence from the 1AC. It argues that… .” Slide10
How to prepare for the 1AR
Rebuttals are NOT a time for summarizing. They are an opportunity to win key arguments. Focus on substantive issues.
Both partners need to carefully flow the negative block.
All 1AR arguments need to be written down on your flow, not pre-written or written long hand.Slide11
How to prepare for the 1AR
What makes the 1AR different from the 2AC?
The 1AR can no longer make new arguments (unless they are in response to NEW arguments made in the block).
Your goal is to build on the 2AC arguments.
Choose 2AC arguments that you are ahead on. You do not have to extend every 2AC point but you must have arguments that can win the debate on every negative position.
You ARE allowed to read cards in the 1AR but ONLY if they build on 2AC arguments or if they are in response to NEW block arguments. Slide12
How to prepare for the 2ar
Both partners must carefully flow the 2NR. The 2AR cannot be prepared ahead of time. The focus of your speech is to RESPOND to SPECIFIC arguments made by the 2NR. This makes a good flow of the 2NR essential.
Remember that your overall mission is to prove that the advantages of the affirmative case are larger than any disadvantages. This involves simple logic. For example, if the affirmative proposal is expensive but saves the world from eco-system collapse due to global warming, the advantages outweigh the disadvantages. Slide13
How to prepare for the 2ar
The 2AR should begin with the following line… “The advantages of the affirmative proposal outweigh the disadvantages because… .” Then give the judge a brief overview of why you win. :30 is a good maximum length.
Then, move on to focusing on specific arguments made by the 2NR.