RANSFORMATIONALbushe@sfu.ca Whenthe(2013),transformationalpotential . - PDF document

ROCESS RANSFORMATIONALbushe@sfu.ca Whenthe(2013),transformationalpotential (c)EmeraldGroup doesgrantthisfurtherhostedexpressPublishingversionthis  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013      Whenthe2007unclearsuccessappreciativeinquirybutthatmuchclearerjuxtaposedthegenerativebecausetherecontradictionthem;themindependentcharacteristicsRather,conceptualunderstandingappreciativeinquirytransformationalchangeprocessdebateswhenBothArkin,2005;Oswick,2005)(e.g.,2006;Fineman,2006)tendedputattention“focuslittlethecomponentbackthen,“Oneconcernsaboutexcitementandappreciativeinquiry(AI)thatconsultantsdoingdon’tunderstandgenerativityoutcome,AI.ManypeopleblindedAfterdeficitsdysfunctiontheybecomewithpositive”AI…”(Bushe,2007,p.33).then,generativityappreciativeinquiry,Dialogicbecomeaccepted(Bushe,2013).NumeroushaveJournalCorporatefocusedgenerativitydifferentstakeholderengagement2010).2012AppreciativeConferencetheGenerativeAppreciativeInquiry”.doneunderstandwhatgenerativityandappreciativetheprocessesenhancesgenerativitytransformationalchangeThepractice,descriptiongenerativeduringappreciativeinquiry.keytheconceptgenerativityappears.referenced(1950)generativityadultdevelopment.chapter,generativityprocessescapacitiesthatpeoplethinkingindependentlyKennethGergen(1978)DonaldSchon(1979).seminalpaper,arguedthatscientificcouldappliedstudyinghumanrelationshipsandthepredictionandcontrolpsychology.suggestedthat,focusedits"generativecapacity”.this"…capacitychallengetheculture,fundamentalregardingcontemporaryfosterthatgranted'therebyfurnishforactions"(1978,p.1346Schondescribedgenerativity   “…nothingthings(1979,p.138).Schonarguedproblemsthedescribeproblemproblemspurposesdirectionsseekproblemperspective,problemsgiven,choicesbeyondinquiry.problemsproblempotencycasesmetaphors.”(1979,150).thatacknowledgeimpactmetaphorCooperrider,1990).thantryingexplainpast,appreciativethegenerativeperceptions,metaphors,thatbetterfororganizationalactions(Cooperrider1987).   organizationdevelopment(OD)generativitywhengrouppeoplecreatethemexperiencetheirorganization  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013justgroup.doesn’tgroupthatwidely.“new”.   generativeanew,formulategenerativebecausethatthinkgenerativechangeorganizations(fromBushe,2013).   ENERATIVITYinfluenceshowtheandtheytake.Overpeoplethemselveseachotherdifferenttakingnewthisculturechanged,turnwhatthattheculturechangeunleashedappreciativeinquiryoccurproposalsplans,butchangeseverydaydaythinkingacting.examplegenerativedevelopment”.theemergencephrase1987,theregroundbetweenenvironmentalistsTheyhadnothingeachother.emerged,environmentalistsgroundtheybeenbefore.Suddenly,governmentsthetheirproducts,servicesandproducts,processes,relationshipswidelyaccepteddefinition.Indeed,probablythisambiguitythatsustainspotency.thanyearsdevelopment”continuesgeneratethinkingandacting.   generativitycannumberthree,andeach actions       changes  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013spawnedtheproposals,createdchangeprocess(generativeoutcomes).Anothertheindividualsproducegenerativeoutcomes;howdoeschangeprocessencouragepeopleroutines,habitualandtheknowncapacity)?approachgenerativecapacityand/orproducesgenerativeoutcomesfiguregenerativeprocessonewhichproducesgenerativecapacitypeopleproducesgenerativeoutcomes.capacity,increasesoutcomes.generativegenerativeandindividuallyandreconsiderwhichtheytakegrantedandopencapacity)producesthatpeoplethatbeneficialothers(generativeoutcomes).numberways:about,andturn    (1990)theorizingtheimagesandaction.(2001)principle”theandforchange.andSekerka(2006)peopleappreciateandincreasesthatelevationchangeIsen’s(2000)andFredrickson’s(2001,2006)foundmorecreative,openefficientthinking.resilientableoccasionalhaveincreasedforvariety,broaderoptions.decade,everpeopleandgreatergenerativecapacity(Achor,2010).thisargumentfavoursupportsgenerativebeingappreciativetheexamplestheory(1978)to, Outcomes  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013FreudMarx,notcomeAnd,out(e.g.,Fitzgerald,2010;Johnson,2013),appreciativeengendering   recentlyconfrontedtheDalaiCenterforPeaceEducation’sprojectVancouver.promotetheir“educatingpartneredcommunityagency(FrogNeighbourhoodlaunchappreciativeinquiryhopedparent’sinterestdevelopingcompassionneighbourhood,wherepeopleandlimitedsummitInstead,discoverytrainingparentvolunteers“compassionthemandinviteneighbourshourssharetheylearnedfromstories,theirnotestheirlearningsbackquestions“Thinkchildhoodthecooperativeconfident”,andthetimeyouthegreatestcompassion,cooperationand/orconfidenceyoungperson.”   happenedFrogrefugeescountrieschildhoodsconcerned,aboutaboutengenderanythingcounselingsomeparticipantstheinquirystunninglygenerative.outset,neighbourhoodthoughtcouplehundredwasambitiousWithinmonthsthousandpeoplehadprocesspeoplenothingtheresultstheircircles.consumingitstheprogramsFrogbecamecaughtbecamehadparticipationbecausetheyfundthecontinuetheirthoughtheinquirymidprofound,NeighbourhoodHouse.communitylessdeeplyaboutappreciationandemotions.theWorldConference2013Ronandabout600participantsinquiryinto“whatgreatconference”andthemdiscoveryquestionstheywouldgenerateaboutyourconference(whenhappiest,proudest,inspired,joyful)conference(perhapsyourthinkingupended,yourconfronted,yourchoicesyou).    broadconsensuswouldgenerativethinkappreciativeinquirybasedassumptionpeopleabout“bestof”usefulhappen.publishedconsultantperceptionsappreciativeaction(EganLancaster,2005)didn’tWhentheylisted“strengths”consultants,aboutgenerativenatureexperienceandfocusgenerative,producechange“AIthatonehearsbutrarelyaboutFitzgerald,  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative20132001,andGrant2006,beingexceptions).   example,fifteenagospentgroupconstructiontheirexperiencesleadership.thebutnot,theopinionsomedecidedtheyneededbetteronedayheadmemberidentifydayorganization.conventionalbeganthemfoursandinsights.extractedabouthopewasincludingconversationaboutleadershiporganization.backdidpayattentionrequiredgenerative.(andtheymen)hadneverthoughtaboutdidn’tthestoriesleadership.“bestthatgroupswholegroupwerepathetic.demeanourthedaythereaftersymbioticallyinfluencedanddecliningNothinggenerativetheprocessgrounddon’tSimplythenotguaranteeintervention!strandthattendsdescribing(Bushe1995)contemporary2009).thisfromI’veOrganizationDevelopment”(BusheMarshak,2009)baseddifferentchangestandardOD,generativethreeunderlyingchange(BusheMarshak,MarshakBushe,2013).beingtoooppressing“negative”,arebasedconstructedunderstanding(e.g.,2006;Fineman,2006).thefocuspositivebecomescritiquesimply,appreciativeusedleader’schangeagent’swhileattemptorganizationfocusedthepositive”avoidfearbeingout,beinghijackedWhenbecomelabelprocessareButequateoutManysuccessfuldescribegeneratedexample,thecase(Powley,Fry,Bright,2004)describesemergingsummits.emerge“generativemetaphorsthattheyguideandframepeoplethink,unconsciously.Butcreatesmetaphor”Barrett(1990),opensthinkingacting.describedgenerativeless”couldhelpedthembecomeunstuck(Bushe,1988).(BusheKassam,2005)foundthatthetransformationalchangeevidencegenerativemetaphorsnontransformationalalsotransformationalthingsthatthemtransformationalchangingthinkinsteadpeopledo,supportingselfchangethatthanimplementationuponchanges.Bothcallinggenerativity.January20062007,consultingmetropolitanundertakinglearning.Different  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013highschoolshighlearningcentreelementaryresearchstreamsobserversurveycollectedanalyzedattemptunderstandaffectedchangeobserved(Bushe,2010).oneyear,(4)transformationaloutcomes.Anotherquarter(2)doingthechangesunderwaytheinquiry.Twoimpact,thoughonepositivechange.OSITIVITYSITESbetweentheirexperiencethetheyfeltwiththechangetheirsummitschoolrelatedcorrelatedchange.Figureaverage“AtthisthebecauseAppreciativeband4.4outoneschool.measuresratedtheirschoolexperiencedchangescoreschoolthatexperiencedchangethethirdhighest.relationshipbetweenchangeraisesaboutoutcomes.   mostpeoplefeelingsaboutprocessgeneral,thecouldbutsufficientforchange.can’tthatWhatexplore,however,generativity.evidencethatsignificantlychange.eachDocumentstheDiscoverycoordinatingteamscapturekeyandthedegreechangecontainedDocumentsourperspectives”generativity.findinginformedobserversduringthesummits,correlations   DiscoveryDocumentsinsightsstronglydegree                             8.006.005.004.003.002.001.00 Mean of Feel positive about future because of AI  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013Whenchangesthatoccurred(describedBushe2010)tracedtheyeithergeneratedduringDiscoveryemergedduringphase.contrast,changescoresprovocativehighanother,happyWhateveroccurredthejustprogramsplace.study,surprisingstudentsorganizationalchange,eachthetransformationalacknowledgedconcernsthatthemThismisunderstandingaboutthatorganizationalgoingconcernedputfirstWhite,aboutappreciativeinquiryprocess,“Wecan’tneedapproachthem(1996,p.474).appropriatethatjustconcernedrespondinganyotherchangebutthatthroughgenerativitychangingbutthatnotprecludebeingconcernedproblems.requireswithdifferently.differentlypregroups(Bushe,2002),hypothesisconfirmedFitzgerald,2001;2004).appreciativewhodon’tbelongingconcerngroupdifferent,think,thanhavebelonging.cantransformationalgroupscreatinggroup.thepeakorganization),otherquestionsthatfocusgroupgenerativeduringDiscoveryphase.groups,hand,peopleexperienceunproductivegazing.thegroupthegroup’sefficacythegroup’sinquiryneedthegroupbetweenseemsdesigningappreciativebackthisexploremakinggenerative.opportunitygenerativitytopics,generativequestions,generativegenerativethingthinkfromsuccessfulcraftgenerativeoutsetengagements.numberdefininghasbeenguidancethat.attentionthepotencygenerativethetopic,can2002)theAirwayscase(Whitney2003).inquirynatureexceptionalgenderthe“exceptionalintergendergenerativeusedcontextnotbefore.Eventoday,peoplethought1990’saboutgenderAssumingthat,formedsenseinquirygroup.askingaboutthegreatgendergenerative,topic.thegroup/organization/community  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013Andyouthatthisexampleappreciativeinquiryonlyincludedmembers   contrastBritishproposalthattheytakespassenger’sbackstandingsolving,Whitneyfocustheyhelpedthetopic“exceptionalexperiences”(Whitney2003).Again,generativeTheorganizationaboutthatquestionprobablyjob,andinquirygeneratedwaysrecovery.Noticegoodgenerative,focuswhatthehoweffectiveaccomplishingpurpose.Andthisincludedorganization,likethinkwhichconsultantsprovidetheircraftgenerativeoutsetbeforetakenthinkbeginninggenerativegreatlychancesproducingoutcomes.topiccapturethethosetheidentitythegroupwhichused,focusbefore,capturethewhoengagedtheappreciativeinquiryquestionsAskingrecollecttheirrelationshipsandnumberattentionnaturequestions.appreciativeinquiries,cantheformulated.    peoplebeginhavingThat’sgood,havetheyfollowing(Bushe,2007):surprising Theyquestionsthathaven’taboutquestionscausereflectThisthequestion.people’sspirit takepeoplebackthatmeaningfuldeeptakepeopletouchtheirgenerativecouplereasons.matterspeople,thingsmeaningfulmeaningenergy,whichaction.aboutandlistening relationships resulttheconversationsquestionspeopleother.theyimportantaboutimportantaboutotherperson.vulnerabilitytrustengenderedandtheseindirecteffectsthisgenerativity,butdirectoneincreasedcapacitythroughopenmindedness,andpubliclypeoplequestionsforce becausebecausewhocanreframedtheasked.reframedbecausethefromquestionsEveryquestionsbeentheyusedaddition,peoplecandecreaseForhandfulpeople  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013engagement,relationshipgoingbeinggenerativeyoucanmarginssocialduringthatorganization’s(Bushe,2001;2002)andthisAI’stransformationalpotentialWidespreadengagementgenerativedisruptive,keythechangeprocessdescribeon.thatthestateidentityneedsconstructingquestions.group,thatvaluedthegroup,thegroups,questionssupportthegroup’sefficacypurpose,bothgenerative.thinkgenerativityandDesigndon’tthink(2007)recentabouttheydon’torganization,them“no,can’tthat,thisappreciativeturnpeopleoff.probleminquirytheydon’twhattheydon’ttheydon’tthinkvalueinquiry.Butwouldn’tgenerative.knowthepersonbutgeneratingfuture.whatorganizationoughtthatcreatingtheytheysee.Thisinquirygenerative.thatpointbetterfuture.banishpeopledon’tduringappreciativeinquiry;theychargethoughtfulforhurt, ‐ contributesgroup’sunderstand,bringbeing,whendon’tacknowledgeproductivefor“negative”thatpointforcefullyFitzgerald,(2010).thatwhichproductiveJohnson’sarticlewonderfulaboutabouthappenscollectiveintothetakesgeneratively.synergalysisBushe,1995)provengenerativeduringappreciativerecentfieldParanjpey(2013)comparedoutputsdifferentgroupsforcorporategroupsgroupsdidconventionalDiscoverysmalldiscussion)thesynergenesishigher,problemthanconventionalgroups.group,appreciativeinterviews,thetryingpurposegroupgeneratethatcatalyzesthatconversation.Everyonethethetogether.theyimagesstoryprovokedrelatedquestion.analyzethetryingcaptureandideasforanswerwon’tthetheWhenconversationsteam,groupstory.groupcontinuesuntilanyonlysynergenesisgenerate  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013organizationalinfluencedtheandconversationthey’veplaceideasamongthepeopleAccordingBushethekeychangesuccessfulOD,shiftsorganizationaltheory(Cooperrider,Srivastva,1995).needthinkhowmaximizeusethathighlygenerativephase.theaspirationsdreamwilltheydevelopingdreamincreasesopportunitiesdifferentiationdivergence.thinkpurposewas  ‐ groundcollaborate.thatuseful,perhapsthinktheopportunityindividualstheyreallyandgenerativeencouragepeoplefordeeplyheld,increasingthedifferentiation   throughexperiencetheyabout,beingheardtheirdifferences,thatcommunityAccordingHolman(2010),differentiation,afterdisturbance,changeprocesses.differentiation,essentialtransformationalchange,complex,adaptedcoherencecanphase,theotherhand,whereconvergencearchitecturethatCooperrideroriginallytheoutputbecausegenerativity.are,definition,generativetheyprovoke/generateandaction.generativeproducehousebeautiful,andmovetheconsensusenergygenerativityneedbetteraboutparalysisconsensuscreatingconditionsthatindividualsandgroupstakingunderstoodandsanctionedideas.WorkingchangeactionWhenAppreciativeInquiryeffectknownadvance,onlyidentifiedretrospect(SnowdenBoone,2007),thenchangeappropriate.theseSnowdenBoone(2007)normalanddecisiontryingoutexperiments(probes)thenchosethosethatjob.generativeproposalsfewchosenencourageindividualsgroupsencouragedgenerativenumberactinggenerated“probes”arethetheinquiry. Generative Action the2005metaanalysis,foundtransformationaldesignedthe“actionphase”changeuponactionteams.implementButtheydidn’timplementationtheInsteadtheyadoptedapproach”theaction(Bushe2005).Thebutcaseideaspeoplewhateverorganizationtowardthanimplementleaderspeopleinnovatinghelpedcould.approachgenerativechangequickly.usedSchool  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013changeeffortstransformationaloutcomes.   Whythisgenerativeapproach“Deployment”2012)(2010,2013)adaptationorganizationdevelopment.Shecouncils“nature’schange”withcomplexity,thatemergentchangeprocessesdisturbance,disturbancecreativedance   Insteadoutcomes,focusholdoutcomestheD’sandareencouragedtakeaction,forwardchampionproposalscomeparticipativechangeprocess,oftenyoungerandBecausetheyyoungerexperiencedusuallytransformativepotentialempowerthroughout   generative   thatsponsor’s/leadersunderstand,beginning,thatthepurposeappreciativegeneratethatpositionwinnersbutneed“track(BushePitman,1991;Bushe,2009).andresourcedshouldplanningprocessbeginning.consultantsstart,groupsusefulchangeequipment,forshouldplanchangesinitiatedindividualsandinnovations,celebratoryandshortdocumentingactionsencourage.thereclear,agreementyou(yourtheredifferentforwhythe(Ludema,Whitney,Griffen,2003)emergedthepopularengagementfortheensureunderstandingprobescomegenerateenergythisgreatengagement.questioned,forchangeorganizations,particularlywhenchangeVanstone2008).Whetherspreadoutlongerpeople,thechange,awareengagedtheprocesscollapsecoherence,doingtenable.pushedthepointsystemapartorganizesnewchangethinkgrouppeoplereorganizinghigherencourageworkensureandDiscovery,andbecomeStrengthenproductivelyabsorbdirectbettercommunicationandamongstakeholders,systemhighertheyauthorizedactionbasedtheproposalscameEnsuretheyunderstandtheydon’tneedaroundnoneThey,createplanstheythinkLeadersboundsthenoutthecommitmentsfromtakekindaction.donethroughhavebeenfinalized,explainedindividualssomepublicdeclarationtheyeachDesign  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013Salancik(1978)arguesactionsvoluntary,irreversibleabouteventslaunchphase.generativityenhancedcasesthelessonsoutcomestheforAI.customer(onlyusefulidentitygroup)thatkeythedeveloppersonnel.Destinyanotherlaunchednaturehighlycreatingideas,conversationsandtherequestionssurfacinglongprocesscanthatprocesstransformationorganizationcounterorganizationquestionpotencyorganizationsforI’veheardaboutgroupsbecominginuredandfromthatparticularlygenerativeorganizationsappreciation(Bright,2009)thatappreciativeculture,transformational.thisattemptedbringbackcentertransformationalchangepotentialappreciativeinquiry.appreciativegenerativeprocessproducesimagesrepresentationsOne,theythinkdifferentlyaboutthatopensand/oraction.Secondly,thepeople;theyactopenedthegenerativecapacityindividualsandtheywillproducegenerativitythreechangeunderlyingDialogicprocesses(thechangesdiscourse,emergentchange(BusheMarshak,AppreciativeInquirybecausefoundedorganizational   theappreciativecanactually“planned”transformationalchange,moreI’vethroughoutchapter,emergenceotherduringappreciativesupportive,planned,transformational     ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013      Achor,(2010)HappinessAdvantage(2005)brightManagement30.(1990)Generativeapproachforcaughtperception.JournalBehavioralScience,26:2,219239.Bright,D.S.(2009)AppreciativeorganizationalpracticeforturbulentOrganizationDevelopmentPractitioner41:3,Bushe,(2013)OD:theorypractice.Development45:1,Bushe,(2010)comparativeappreciativeorganization:forReviewResearchSocialIntervention29:24.Bushe,(2009)Leadership(Rev.Ed.)MA:Bushe,(2007)Appreciativeinquiry(just)positive.OrganizationDevelopment:4,Bushe,(2002)Meaningteams:Appreciativeinquirywithpreidentitypostidentitygroups.R.,Barrett,F.,Seiling,(eds.)AppreciativeInquiryOrganizationalTransformation:fromFieldCT:Quorum.G.R.(2001)theorieschangeembeddedappreciativeinquiry.Cooperrider,Yeager,(edsAppreciativeDirectionOrganizationDevelopment(117Stipes.Bushe,(1998)Appreciativeteams.DevelopmentJournal,16:3,Bushe,(1995)Advancesappreciativeorganizationdevelopmentintervention.DevelopmentJournal,22.G.R.Coetzer,inquiryteamdevelopmentintervention:controlledexperiment.JournalAppliedBehavioralScience(2005)appreciativeinquirytransformational?analysis.JournalBehavioralScience161181Bushe,Marhsak,press)DialogicorganizationHandbookDevelopmentChange,    NY:                     Bushe,Marshak,(2009)DiagnosticpatternsJournalBehavioralScience45:3,348368.Bushe,(1991)Appreciativetransformationalchange.Practitioner,23:(2012)concentrationHow‘‘AI’’summitouttheenterprise.41:2,106117.(1990)affirmativeorganizing.Cooperrider,(eds.),ManagementLeadership(91125).Jossey(1995).andappreciativeinquiry:journeyorganizationaltheory.Hosking,Dachler,(eds.)ManagementandAlternatives(157200)Aldershot,UK:Avebury.Fry,(2010)Editorial:engagementJournalCorporateCitizenship38,  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013Cooperrider,D.L.L.E.TowardtheoryorganizationalGallos,(ed.)OrganizationDevelopment:JosseyReader(223238).SanJossey(1987)AppreciativeorganizationalWoodman,W.A.(eds)ResearchChangeDevelopment,(129169)Stamford,CT:Whitney,(2001)Cooperrider,Yeager,(edsAppreciativeDirectionOrganizationDevelopmentChampaign,IL:Stipes.Egan,C.M.(2005)Comparingappreciativeinquiryperspectives.OrganizationDevelopmentJournal;:2,49.(1950)ChildhoodSociety.Fineman,(2006)beingConcernscounterpoints.AcademyManagement270–291.Fitzgerald,S.P.,J.C.(2010)AppreciativeinquiryManagement19:3,220233.Fredrickson,(2006)broadenCsikszentmihalyi,WorthPositive(85103Fredrickson(2001)psychology:ThebroadentheoryAmericanPsychologist56,218226.    (2007)inquiryappreciativesubmittedsymposium,Inquiry:BestPresent,andFutureAcademyManagementConference,(2006)evaluationappreciativeBridgingapparentActionResearch,401–418.(1978).generativetheory.SocialPsychology,13441360.(2013)engage:dialogicorganizationdevelopment.Development45:1,(2010)EngagingEmergenceSanFrancisco,Koehler.(2000)affect(Eds.)HandbookEmotions(417435)NYC,NY:Johnson,(2013)Transcendingappreciativeinquiry:appreciativeBoland(eds.)OrganizationalAppreciativeandScholarshipTransformation(AdvancesInquiry,Volume189207.)UK:(2002)AppreciativeapproachorganizationdevelopmentFry,InquiryOrganizationalTransformation:Reports(239261)Westport,CT:Whitney,(2003)InquiryFrancisco,Koehler.Marshak,Bushe,(2013)introductionadvancesOrganizationOrganizationDevelopment45:1,Fitzgerald,(2001)Appreciativeteam:Movingactionresearchcontinuum.OrganizationDevelopmentJournal19:3,43.  ‐ GenerativityAppreciative2013Grant,(2005)Lookingdiscursivedirectionsorganizationalchange.JournalOrganizationalChangeManagement,18:383390.Paranjpey,(2013)relationshipbetweengenerativityappreciativeBenedictineChicago,E.H.,R.E.,Barrett,andBright,(2004)DialogicdemocracyTransformationthroughAppreciativeInquirySummit.AcademyManagementExecutive80.Salancik,(1977)Commitmenttooeasy.6:1,80.Schon,D.A.(1979)metaphor:policy.Ortony,MetaphorandThought,(137163).Cambridge,UK:Snowden,Boone,(2007).forHarvardBusinessReview,85:11,76.Vanstone,(2008)Cantore,AppreciativeforChangeManagement(183195).KoganWhite,(1996).WorkinginterestingDay,62,472474.Whitney,Bloom,(2003)ThePowerAppreciativeKoehler.