A framework for addressing methodological and ethical issues in offender health Professor Laura Serrant Sheffield Hallam University Dr Cyril Eshareturi University of Wolverhampton Talk outline ID: 559808
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Investigating silences:" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Investigating silences: A framework for addressing methodological and ethical issues in offender health
Professor Laura Serrant,
Sheffield
Hallam University
Dr Cyril Eshareturi,
University
of WolverhamptonSlide2
Talk outlineThe Silences Framework (TSF)Research studyEthical/Methodological considerationsMethodological strengths of TSFSlide3
The Silences Framework (TSF)Developed from concept of 'Screaming Silences' Areas of research either under-researched and require more development, or experiences which are historically and/or politically undervalued, absent or invisible
U
nderpinned by criticalist
and ethnicities based
approaches:
Research and experience is context bound
Impact of inequality and power on experiences
Central role of researcher
Equal importance of marginalised views and personal
experienceSlide4
The Silences Framework – 4 StagesStage 1: Working in Silences (contextualisation)Stage 2: Hearing Silences (location)Stage 3: Voicing silences (verbalisation)Stage 4: Working with Silences (recontextualisation)Cyclical, reflective approach to analysisSlide5
Research study TitleMapping the offender health pathway: challenges and opportunities for support through community nursingDesign
Qualitative case study underpinned by TSF
Aims
Identify points in the community where a nurse led intervention can be delivered to offenders on release
Identify points in a manner and way which would be ethical, non-stigmatising and agreeable to offenders in the community
Address the uni-dimensional presentation of evidenceSlide6
Ethical and methodological ConsiderationsCredibilityProlonged engagementTriangulation
Member checking
Transferability
Thick description
Dependability
External audit
Confirmability
External audit
Member checking
ReflexivitySlide7
Advantages of the TSFMarginalised perspectivesUni-dimensional presentation of evidence
Trustworthiness
Not prescriptive of design
User-friendly
Internal validity
Power imbalanceSlide8
Indicative papersSerrant-Green, L. (2010) The sound of ‘silence’: a framework for researching sensitive issues or marginalised perspectives in health. Journal of Research in Nursing, 16(4). pp. 347–360.Eshareturi, C
.,
Serrant-Green, L., Bayliss-Pratt, L. and Galbraith, V. (2014
) The case for nurses as central providers of health and social care services for ex-offenders: a discussion
paper. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 70(5), pp. 1030-9.
Eshareturi, C., Serrant-Green, L.,
Galbraith
, V
. and Glynn, M.
(
2015) Silence
of a scream
: application
of the
Silences Framework
to provision
of nurse-led
interventions for ex-offenders. Journal of Research in
Nursing, 20(3), pp. 218–231.Slide9
Thank you Professor Laura Serrant l.serrant@shu.ac.ukDr Cyril Eshareturicyril.eshareturi@wlv.ac.uk