LO To identify the problems historians face when dealing with causation Why is Causation important Every historical investigation begins with the simple question why Identifying the most ID: 410243
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "The Role of Causation in History: Chaos,..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
The Role of Causation in History: Chaos, Free Will and Determinism
L/O – To identify the problems historians face when dealing with causationSlide2
Why is Causation important?
Every historical investigation begins with the simple question – ‘why?’
Identifying the most
important causes
of events allows us to decide how best to deal with it. This gives meaning to situations which otherwise would leave us feeling helpless.Slide3
Why is Causation important?
However… History is the flawed product of incomplete evidence which is
interpreted by Historians
with their own values and preoccupations.
So… historians answer the question ‘Why?’ in different ways, based on the evidence they choose to work with, and the conclusions they choose to draw.
TASK 1 – Read through the quotes on causation on your worksheet. Which one do you like the most and why?Slide4
The Death of Billy Elliot
Billy Elliot (35) finished his last can of super-strength beer and reflected on his predicament. He had been unemployed since the last factory in his area closed down a few years earlier. Like his father before him, he had taken to drink. Just recently, his wife had left him after finding out about the fling he’d had with Tasha Slappa
down the road at a friend’s party. He told his wife that the summer heat had made him drink too much, but she told him to shove it.Slide5
The Death of Billy Elliot
He decided to get another 6-pack of beer from the local off-licence. The government had recently cut back on unemployment benefits, but the bloke behind the counter, Akaash, had promised him a discount for being such a good customer lately. So, he grabbed his coat and put his shoes on.Slide6
The Death of Billy Elliot
Just as he was leaving, his mother rang up to give him some family news. He had a quick chat with her, then left the house. As he strolled down the road, a boy came round the corner on a bicycle in a panic. Billy, who was still reflecting on what his mother had told him, was taken by surprise and leapt into the road.Slide7
The Death of Billy Elliot
Sadly for Billy, a steam roller was passing at just the moment, resurfacing the road after it had buckled in the hot summer weather. The driver was still tired because his baby had been crying all night and didn’t see him. As a result, Billy was squelched into the shape of a pancake.Slide8
The Death of Billy Elliot
Having read the story, answer the following questions:What three
factors would you pick out as being the most important
causes of the tragedy?What one further question could you ask to deepen your understanding about the tragedy?Here are the three verdicts on the death of Billy Elliot. Take a
class vote on which verdict you each find most convincing:
A
B
Death by Free Will
Billy’s death was a freak accident that has no meaningful cause
Death by Marxist Dialectic
Billy was a sad victim of economic forces
Death by Determinism
Billy was the victim of an inevitable chain of circumstance traceable right back to climate and geographySlide9
The Historiographical View of Causation
Key Factor of change
Timescale
Big Question
Concept of
Progress
Details
Whig Historians
(18
th
and 19
th
C)
Great Men & Actions of Individuals
Short-Term
Where have we come from?
Peaceful, Evolutionary progress
Thomas Macaulay
had two key ideas:
The driving force of history was individuals acting with free will
History was a story of progress leading up to high point of the present age: the past was judged on present day values
Leopold von Ranke
led a reaction against this by trying to show things how they actually were and assessing periods on their own terms using evidence =
historicism
. Do you agree with Ranke or Macaulay more?Slide10
The Historiographical View of Causation
Key Factor of
change
Timescale
Big Question
Concept of
Progress
Details
Marxist Historians
(19
th
and 20th
C)
Economics
Social Class
Dialectics
Mid-Term
Where are we going?
Violent, revolutionary
progress
Karl Marx
said that economic forces dictated the overall strategy of history; individuals just provided the tactics
Like Macauley, he saw history as having its own momentum, but felt that class conflict not individuals provided it.
Does the collapse of so many communist regimes in the 20
th
century mean that the Marxist interpretation of history is worthless?Slide11
The Historiographical View of Causation
Key Factor of change
Timescale
Big Question
Concept of
Progress
Details
Annales Historians
(20
th
C)
Geography
Sociology
Long-Term
Are we going anywhere?
Question whole notion of progress
Fernand
Braudel
– argues that individuals and even societies are merely short-term ripples on
mid-term waves subject to long-term tides.
It is these tides of history which provide the driving force in history: climate change, discovery, floods etc…
Does this view of history essentially mean that it is pointless to study individual figures when trying to explain the causes of events?Slide12
The Approach of Philosophers to Causation
The three positions discussed are sandwiched between two extremes of philosophical thought that
reject the idea that human beings can influence the world
around them in any meaningful way,
whether they learn from the past or not.Chaos Theory – The idea that everything is down to chance events which we have no control over.
Determinism – The idea that everything is the inescapable result of what went before.Slide13
Conclusion
The only essential difference between chaos and determinism
is
one of focus
.A chaos theorist find an endless number of trivial accidental causes, whilst the determinist finds an infinite number of profound causes.
Both make the same essential point: tracing any historical event backwards in a chain of cause and effect quickly leads to absurdity.Slide14
Conclusion
Not only is this chain endless, but there is an endless number of chains.To add to the confusion, each event many have
several causes
, which in turn many have been
caused by several events, each of which in turn may have several causes.Quickly, any attempt to sketch out the cause of an event will resemble not a chain, or even a series of chains, but a gigantic tree with an endless number of branches
.Slide15
So how do we tackle Causation in essays?
Avoid the two extremes
of determinism and chaos theory.
Instead, you should
draw elements from both of these extreme. Historians will tend to occupy the middle ground between these two positions, both chronologically and thematically.Slide16
a) Chronologically – be broad ranging
Like the determinists, historians will look at long term
factors like the
Annales School of historians who consider the impact of trends in geography and climate.Like the chaos theorists, they will look too at short term factors like
Whig Historians who stress the role played by the ‘Great-Man
’ coming along at the right time.Slide17
b) Thematically – be broad ranging
By looking at a broad chronological range of factors, historians will also try to be broad ranging thematically.
Many look at
Economics
(Marxists), Politics (Structuralists), Geography (Annales), Ideas (Hegelian), and the role of
Key Individuals (Whig).Slide18
Result of this approach
By adopting the middle ground, we have to reside ourselves to the fact that there are no final answers, only a
cycle of questions and answers
, leading to
progressively wider understandings of history.However, by accepting that each event has a massive variety of causes, we run the danger of not making any conclusion at all!
How do we get round this? We need to consider how we identify, group, link and prioritise causes.Slide19
Practical Approach to Causation – Categorising Causes
Content Causes
S
ocial
PoliticalEconomic
ReligiousM
ilitary
Time Causes
Long-Term
Medium-Term
Short-Term
Role Causes
Trigger
Catalyst
Transformative
Pre-Condition
Importance Causes (Absolutely or Relatively)
Necessary – If no X, then no Y
Sufficient – X was enough for Y
What is the best way to categorise causes OR is a combination of methods best?Slide20
Practical Approach to Causation – Categorising Causes – Example 1
Causes of the First World War 1914-1918
Political
Alliance
System, Imperialism as an political ideology: Empire was the only way to be a Great Power, Nationalism: created the desire for power and security
Military
HMS Dreadnought, Naval Arms Race between Britain and Germany,
Growing size of conscript armies in Europe
Economic
Germany needed
to secure new markets, Britain wanted to protect existing markets, Russia wanted access to Mediterranean
Social
Nationalism
– created culture of superiority within and between nations, led to belief that war was a valid policy option for states, led to assassination of Franz Ferdinand?Slide21
Practical Approach to Causation – Categorising Causes – Example 2
Causes of the First World War 1914-1918
Content
Time
Role
Importance
1
Political
– Imperialism led to competition between states & subjugation
of smaller nations which increased nationalist violence
i.e. Serbia
Long-term
Pre-condition
Sufficient for war to happen, made it more likely
2
Military
– Naval Arms Race, raised fears about German intentions, led to Alliance System
Short-term
Catalyst
Relatively Necessary for war to happen
3
Social/Pol
– Nationalism and independence movements, new nations
i.e. SerbiaMedium-termTriggerAbsolutely Necessary for war to happen, triggered assassinationSlide22
Practical Approach to Causation – Linking FactorsSlide23
Homework
Using your guide to historiography, research one school of historical thought
of your choice.
Write a
150 word summary, identifying what historians of that school believe about why things change in history, what famous historians there are and any famous works