Adhoc-VCG:ATruthfulandCost-Ef - PDF document

Adhoc-VCG:ATruthfulandCost-EfÞcientRoutingProtocolforMobileAdhocNetworkswithSelÞshAgentsLuziAndereggInstituteofTheoreticalComputerScienceETHZurichinf.ethz.chStephanEidenbenzBasicandAppliedSimulationScience(CCS-5)LosAlamosNationalLaboratorylanl.govABSTRACT                     !        �       =@    ?         @           #-:8:0/ %SelshnessandPayments4 &    A &       1         &      �     *       ?    ='*      " ?   *       #-;/ %?   # -0:BC090;/%    # -DE99B:E/%        @                ?                        1          *@       (     &  ?     # =  %+ ? ' # % )'      !'                F@     -0D/?     -./    26!54?F     ?                       AttractiveCheating  !      1G G                    ?                   ?    ?           & GG        A  1           $   ?  1 $   '        &4 1 '   F         (            1               �  *    (      (             = -./   MechanismDesign  "    &   ?        ?     #  = %                                   !          @  ?         @  F 09-00/    2 7-0C/          ?         &      =    4     '* 1                  ?   ?           @    �                  ?       OurContribution  !     &   6          �     0max  ' maxmin%' # %    &?        &(  ! -9;/ -::/ !-:D/GG *        !?                    ?  !      ' ? !    @          =    #   %?             !          ! HF7       ?     !            1  &  ?  #   % =   -D9B/   !     � '*A  '*  1    = �@     �         =      �     �    @   I*    #  %               -./    F             &   Organization?  * 1  F0    F9  ! F; &   FB  '    FCFD   -./    F. '   #     !%2.RELATEDWORK!         *    2 7-0C/     ,  ? +J+ -:/'         -:B/?  -:;/     !   K!+�             &-0.0E/F   #-;/ %, 1            K  A  '-./ # %    26!54?F  � =   26!54?F K  A  '-E/  1      *     ? +4#+4%-9/  =L M7N   O  F+7?4-9B/     )  -:E/              -0:B090;/ =    '   ,   =    ?  )='-;/3.OURMODEL            %     #%     #%     4  @   #   ' %      ?   4                   +                1'* ?   #' %    1                            ,                    ?   ?#  -9B/%       2     ?          4     #  %    ' F-:C/"  F      & @  &�   &    ? @  @    �    #   % # 09 ..8..:-00/% !'   � -:C/               ( @      &&  *           ,        *  )                              =      '   A         '  �     ?G 'G                                        ?      1 
     -:0/1 
 #:%      '    '   min      ,     '  @  +   max   max        #'   %    0        min 5      6       
   #     %min
@        @ 4@:1min
 
 min#0%?%   %1Pmin
2    A     ?@    *            4.THEADHOC-VCGPROTOCOL  !           A    'F          ! &      ! 1:7  0H   �      Routediscovery       -:8:0/         ROUTEREQUEST?1:@  0? 8  9?   ;?  B? 4 '  '   1 4@ 0  @   -:8:0/   # %  
minmin 
#:% min(1)(2)
min(1) Figure1:Packetheadersduringtheroutediscovery: ROUTEREQUEST        ROUTEREQUEST@  �     ''  0H 
 94 @    min
 rec min;7 min
�        �  2  �  $  @   ? ROUTEREQUEST   ) : @   H          %(   (1) #  %5    !   (1)        ? !    1  min+1)#9%  =   '    ?min+1)    � =#%            ) 0'   '    ?&   PBR0R9P:8?   PDR9R;P:;?   PBR9R;P:0?  !P:;:8R0PCP:0:8R9PBF        B            BRCRBP:C �         BR0R9P:8    H ROUTEREPLY @ #:%%     @  min+1)   !  ?ROUTEREPLY            ROUTEREPLY             -:8:0/   ROUTEREQUEST   # %,  @      @   G*G   @                    ?          -:0/4  #' %  ROUTEREQUEST      % ?       !         �'   1531034v3v27S 2 v3v4515 D Figure2:Anexamplenetworkwithedge-weightsDataTransmission   (1)    @    '     (1)  (1)F           # -9B/%@                  #-./'%     -9B/1           #          ! %�          #-9B/ %                ?   �                    RouteRecoveryH        '  $             #%  '            BROKENLINK    6 BROKENLINKGG       @     5.ANALYSIS  !  @ &     &  !    !   F    !    &      ? Observation          !    # % &   !   #'   %    @   F      &  4     * F   !   ?       :H    0    min
 9     ROUTEREQUEST    L M       1       ' (      '   ?          )   1                           ?               $         #'   %    �   )   # @   %      "     #Proof.        1     #    % #    %K          F    '            '         �            4@9 1&   �               # % # %4    '                     "     # #min
  # Proof.    2      min
 6   #  min
 min
 min
min
%        min
     min
             (  #  min
 min
 min
min
%        # %      min
 I          -0B:;/?    #   %    ?      ROUTEREQUEST"          ROUTEREQUEST#    ## !Proof.F     % ROUTEREQUEST   1 #%            %                % = =              ?       2    %? $ 1   #%    #%A     %             F      %     )  #'        %           ?                      2  ?            G G       ? 1Theorem   !6.OVERPAYMENT    !       (0)(1) +1)              ?   min+1)?     !#  %   min (1)min (1)       Theorem$max% min    # %#        max minProof.?        *  (1) +1)@       +1)?   min+1)minmin+1)   min+1)
4     min+1) min +1) min +1) min +1)minmin+1)@  min (1)minmin+1)%)   :R 6      'A   �@   ' max 0  F9 2   :88 B88 4' B09;BC B09;BC B09;BC(   :C:;8:E;0CB;:BB 0B:B00:80.09C.;; 0B:B908:0D0999;  DB:;;0.CB .E:;C0 .C:'  C00;BB8CEC.088E90 BE00;;;E.BD:9BB9: B808E;:9D.B:890:C    0.;0;9B9B9BD EE.:0B:8 88888: Table1:Overviewofexperimentalresults 1  max minminmin+1) min+1)max min F'C     max '      #    '        %?0 @     �     ?0    '  -0/     '  1'  :8    *:B88B88            
#4     %' '?                 ' :88  B88  '   ?C       ' '              ) 9      ')?C  ::C :0BB#  :C0B   %'  ?        L   M  -:./ :  -90/  '  MM'?      '  #  %  � B       ?   88.8.'    �     ?'   :888'  0?0� '       ?'         =  ? '    '         (:88 ?    ) 9:88  B88  '   )9  @    ' I ' ?'   ?           M'   7.ANALYSISOFPACKETPURSEMODELWITHAUCTIONSI        ?   :8    A =':    0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Frequency of Occurrence Overpayment ratio VCG/|SP| Distribution Function, 500 x 1500 Grid, 1000 Graphs, 100 Nodes 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Frequency of Occurrence Overpayment ratio VCG/|SP| Distribution Function, 500 x 1500 Grid, 1000 Graphs, 500 Nodes 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Frequency of Occurrence Overpayment ratio VCG/|SP| Density Function, 500 x 1500 Grid, 1000 Graphs, 100 Nodes 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Frequency of Occurrence Overpayment ratio VCG/|SP| Density Function, 500 x 1500 Grid, 1000 Graphs, 500 Nodes Figure3:Overpaymentratiodistributionanddensityfunctionsofourexperiments ++ ,  -./     ?        F                        #  % ?  =              
 @   F     =   
  ?        ?   = = =  =� 1@  =    
 ? L !MK =             #"    �%       ?    & *      !  "   &) ;  "  ) ;      =   #%?&   9  :0=:C=  ? &,    1  21D110v1v12021511vvv51150S1v115071v64v105118153v16"25""26"8 9 10 11 Figure4:AnexampleforthePacketPurseModelwithAuctions        #%:B0B   ?   = :C0CG G=0:       0:BR:P:D?  :D:P:C 8 (           &*          8.CONCLUSION                   &    !          &     !                      !     #%    # %     #%      FB      &                !      &        ('   !@              &         LM     '       ?   @         A     # ' @ %                 @  K2@         !       "   &�  #%         !         H        &        +  F-9B/2 -E/     !   7           -98/     !�          !    '  #  , �-:9/% * )'       *  Acknowledgements  '      S=F      9.REFERENCES-:/FF7TFF +  �FK F1!??� +&   '())*+,-0/ 4? �) +,�&   -.#/  )0')
10  #EE:EEE0880-9/,K4)H! *?5O5 " � +4�,088:-;/FK  S5K � 7  , 21 4= , F�&$ 
'  ) '2#' ,++,/(0880-B/FK  S5K �2 K ! 1? 7  F ) 7 , A2�&   3" 2#  /
  ;89;:8444  F0880-C/FK  S5K �+ (2)H2?+1 (2 G)H 2?�&   '"""0)#) 4
 # 5)4(6$7 -D/5K  SA � '4 F, A2�&   '"""0)2#) 4
# 5)4(68 0888-./5K  SA � '2 1    *  �&3   #"9$/-E/5K  SA � 'F  F( * , A2�)0: ) 
##  .2B(0889-:8/+K ! ?H,**!,**,N�*H  + 4 4&7   A2� # #  2'
"3!-::/4 �, + + ! �&   :::D99:ED:-:0/FHFK ?K�(       �&)) #  C9S 0880-:9/F4 *FT FN �4@ ?  ! A2�&   /'$)()*+.-:;/S)   +  7FFF�K!+ ,5 7  �&   ,-)# #  /# 5(/6:D9:.0S 0880-:B/S)  FF�H   ,H 177  )  H�&   ;' 2#/  ) ) #  5/ )*+,6)
1::90880-:C/S! S5=�+ H, �&  "  !-
4 CBD.:EDE-:D/?!�?�&"  -C:DCC9:ED9 -:./7! T 7 �   1      �)  "  ,++.0;.0;ES 0889-:E/,SS+A  '5K �     �'&   9  #,++.$ #S 0889-08/F5 TF  7  �+(*7  + ,2�&4 2 
) # '!= 5!6�2 ' !
1;8D;090880-0:/F,?! T5,K�,     �&   3%'   ) # 
 ,+++8) 0888-00/, ,S!�,?�(% ?
1-09/+, 7,�!  � #
!+,+@+'" -0;/+, 7,� (741 7 , , 2�&%'9'       5),++,67 -0B/H, ,?*�H  !1),+�&   -;
   A  '   909D:EEE-0C/227�   �&"  89B:CC:EC-0D/?7�  1+ +� 4 -0./?7   4? �AK F7  V�&�  );E#0%09C0BE,0880-0E/?7   �A   V�&   -. )')#/  5(/608908;F)0880-98/SF H +,F*�( 7, H  ,�43   #3-,+.-9:/F+2  ) 777�4 4& A2F6�&"#2    -90/T?�?+? 1) ?  ,�&   ,+ #3  #  #  536C8.C:EK0889-99/O? 5F �, A2 7  +�&4 2 
) # '!= 5!6�2 ' !
1:EB0:.-9;/�       �&�  9 -;.9D:EC:-9B/FN O 7 O S �F1F +  K F, 2�&   '
9(():E.D:EED,0889A.ALTERNATIVEVERSIONOFROUTEDISCOVERYPHASE      !   ?    ROUTEREQUEST?  ' '  max'    G   F;G'' max?     ROUTEREQUEST     maxmax       " F;  ROUTEREQUEST?   '    1 ROUTEREQUEST         @                         ?      ' F;       #   %          ?    (                       ' �           (       ' )    '    #    %    ?    A    ?       +  #  %     ,  ROUTEREQUEST              @      Adhoc-VCG:ATruthfulandCost-EfÞcientRoutingProtocolforMobileAdhocNetworkswithSelÞshAgentsLuziAndereggInstituteofTheoreticalComputerScienceETHZurichinf.ethz.chStephanEidenbenzBasicandAppliedSimulationScience(CCS-5)LosAlamosNationalLaboratorylanl.govABSTRACT\b\t\n\f\r\f\b\r\b\b\n\r\f\b\f\t\b\b\f\b\b\r\t\f\r\b\f\f\b\b\f\t\r\t\f\f\b\b\f\r\f\b\t\t\n\f\b\n\t\b\f\t\r\t\f\f\r\b\b\t\b !\f\f\b\n\r\b\b\b\f\f\t\r\b"\b\n\n#\f\r$\b\f\n\b\b\b\f\t\r\t\f\f%\f\t\b&#\r\n\f\f\f\b\n\r\t\b\f\b\r\b\b&\f%\f\r\f\b\f\r\b\t\f\b\t\f\n\b\f\n\f\b\b\b\f\t\r\t\f\f\f\b\f\b\f\b\f#\n\b\f\n\f\t%\f\f\r\r\f\b\f\n\b\n\t\f\t\b\t\r'\f\t(\n\b\n\r\b\b\b\f\f\f\b\b\b\f \f\f\t!\b\f\b\b\r)\f\f\f*\f\f\n\f\b\n\r\b\b\b\f\f\f\t\f\f\b\b+\f+\n,\b\t-./\f\n\b\b\n\r\f\t\b\f\n\b\n\f\t\b\b\f\b&\b\n\nCategoriesandSubjectDescriptors 00-ComputerSystemsOrganization/1 \b\n \b\n\f\b2\b3
\b\t\nGeneralTerms\r\b+\b\f4\b\bKeywords !\f\b\n\r\f\r\f\t\r\f\t\b\b\r&\r\f\b 5\b\f\b2\f\b\f5\f\b\f\b+\n\f\b2\b567189:;8;2003edgesthatthiscontributionwasauthoredorco-authoredbyacontractororafÞliateoftheU.S.Government.Assuch,theGovernmentretainsanonex-clusive,royalty-freerighttopublishorreproducethisarticle,ortoallowotherstodoso,forGovernmentpurposesonly.September14Ð19,2003,SanDiego,California,USA.Copyright2003ACM1-58113-753-2/03/0009...1.INTRODUCTION7\b\n\r\b\f\t\b\b\f\n"\b\f=\b\b\f\f�=\b\f\n\t\n\b\n\b\b\f\b\b\n\r\b\b\b#-99/\b\f\n%,\b\b\n\r\b\b\b\f\n\f\f\t\f\f\n\f\t\b\b\f\b\b\f\f\n\f\f\r\b\f\f\t\f\b\t\f\b\n\r\f\b\f\t\r\t\f\f\b\b\b\b\t?\b\b\f\f\n\b\f\f\b\f\b\r\n\r\b\b\b\f\f\f\b\f\n\t\f\r\f\f\t\b\r\b\f\t\r\t\f\f\b\b\b\b\t\f\t\f\f\b\f\b\t\b\n\b\t\r\b\n\b\t\f\b\b\t\f\f\f\b\f\t\b\b\t\f\b\b\t\f\r\n\f\b\b\t\t\t\f\r\f\t\t\f\b\b\f\b\t\b\b\r\f\f\f\f\r\b\b\n\f\f\b\f\r\r\b\f\t\f\r\b\f\b\r&\b\t\b\b\f\f\t\n\f\b\n\f\b"\b\t\r\r\f\b\n\r\b\b\b\f\t\n\b\t\b\f\f\b\n\r\f\b\r\r\b\f\b\b&\f\t\f\r\f\b\b\t\b\b\n\r\b\t\n\t\b !\f\b\n\r\b\b\b\f\f\b&\f\t\n\nEnergyEfciency?\f\t\b\f\f\b\f\b\t\f\r\b\b\f\t\f\f\r\f\b*\r\b\n\b\b\f\r\b\f\b\b\b\b#\n\b\b\t\r\t\t\n\f\b\b\t%\t\t\f\r\t\f\t\f\b"\f\b\n\r\b\b\b#-08/\b\f\n\f\t-:8:0/\b\b\b%\r&\b\n\r\b\b\b\n\f\f\f\b\f\b\n\b\t\b\f\t\f\b\r\b\n\t\f\b\r\b\r&\f\b\f\t\f\b\t?\b\f\r\b\f\b\n\r\f\n\b\b\r\n\t\f\b\n\f\t\f\f\t\f\b\t\r\b\b\b\r\b\n\b\n\f\r\b\r\f\f\t\b\f\r\n\t\f\f\b\r\r\b\f'\b\b\b\b'\t\f\b\b\t\f\b\t\b'\t\f\f\t\f\b\t\n\f\b\r\f\f\b\t\r\f\b"\n\f\f'\b\t\b\f\r\b\n,\b\t\b\b\r#\n\f\f\t%\f\f\b\b\f\r\f\f\r\n\b\f\f'\n\bmax\f\t\f\b@\n\f\f