Teacher Demonstration Evaluating Sources And Harris Moves Authorizing Darla Oliver SAWP A I 2015 Evaluating Sources and Practicing Harris Authorizing Students Will Need 2 sheets of paper ID: 623777
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "Evaluating Sources and Authorizing" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
Evaluating Sources and Authorizing
Teacher Demonstration
Evaluating Sources
And
Harris Moves – Authorizing
Darla Oliver
SAWP – A. I. 2015Slide2
Evaluating Sources
and
Practicing Harris’ Authorizing
Students Will Need:
2 sheets of paper
Pen/PencilSlide3
Chemical Scenario - Would you drink this?
What if THIS person said you
could drink…
At
your table you have a jar of… something,
pass around jar and look at. NO TASTING OR SMELLING!
Take slips in your envelope out, with a partner/group decide if the person on each slip of paper
could
convince you to drink the contents of the jar.
On your paper, write name of person and whether or not you could be convinced, explain your choice (why this person is credible/why this one is not). Slide4
More Practice – Evaluating Sources
Source Sort Activity
Topic:
Solitary Confinement Is/Is Not An Appropriate Form of Punishment
Sort into 2 columns what you think is:
Credible
Not Credible
At your table discuss why you chose to put each source in that category
Whole group discussion/questions?Slide5
How does a writer decide what source(s) would help to improve their position?
GOOD QUESTION
https
://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EyMT08mD7DsSlide6
How Do I Determine A Credible Source?
C
– Currency, how current is the source?
R
– Reliability, how reliable is the source?
A
– Authority, who is the author?
A
– Accuracy, how accurate is the information in the source?
P
– Purpose/Point of View, what is the purpose or point of view of the source?Slide7
Authorizing My WritingAuthorizing –
When the writer refers to an “expert” to support the claim they are making
. This is another
“Harris Move”
in argument writing.
How Does This Work?
First
,
select
a compelling piece of evidence.
Then
identify
the source of the evidence.
Finally
,
show
the importance of that source, if it is not obvious. Slide8
Pick Your Position
‘Solitary
Confinement Is/Is Not An Appropriate Form of Punishment
?’
Let’s
Look At Some Sources
Articles
– Read through
each
Underline/highlight
examples of
Authorizing (reminder –
When the writer refers to an “expert” to support the claim they are making
)
Scavenger Hunt questions/work togetherSlide9
How Is This Writer Using Authorizing?
Regarding the mental effects of social isolation as punishment,
Dr. Stuart Grassian, an expert on solitary confinement
, found in his research that “aversive
conditioning”- the
use of punishment as a means of changing negative behavior - is inherently ethically questionable and creates an inherent risk of harm. ” So far, the evidence shows an increase of – sometimes the start - of emotional instability and mental illness.
From
The Kenan Institute for Ethics at Duke University
Excerpted from
In The Hole – Is Solitary Confinement Justifiable Anymore?
Jonathan Igne-Bianchi
http
://kenan.ethics.duke.edu/teamkenan/encompass/current-issue/e14-in-the-hole-is-solitary-confinement-justifiable/Slide10
Let’s Practice - Example
Authorizing
Evidence
Who Said it?
Importance
Why is this source so CREDIBLE? Why should we pay attention?
Using social isolation as punishment, Dr. Grassian, found in his research that the use of punishment as a means of changing behavior is really bad . So far, the evidence shows an increase in or development of emotional instability and mental illness.
Dr. Grassian
Dr. Grassian is an expert on solitary confinement.Slide11
You Practice – Choose 1 Article, write on your own paper
Authorizing
Evidence
Who Said it?
Importance
Why is this source so CREDIBLE? Why should we pay attention?Slide12
Putting This Together
On your paper, write 3-4 sentences
using Sentence Starters
Authorizing
your position on Solitary
Confinement
Example:
In his book [insert title of book/article], author [insert name] states,
“_________________.”
Solitary Confinement
Is
Not An Appropriate Form of Punishment
In the article,
In The Hole - Is Solitary Confinement Justifiable
Anymore?,
Dr. Grassian states
,
“the
use of
solitary confinement punishment
as a means of changing negative behavior - is inherently ethically questionable and creates an inherent risk of harm
. The
evidence shows an increase in or development of emotional instability and mental illness
.”