API Spec 10F Specification on float equipment Washington DC June 2016 Results of Final Letter ballot 22 Ballots issued 14 affirmative 0 negative 0 abstention 8 did not vote Number Voting 14 64 must be gt 50 ID: 770857
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "API Spec 10F Specification on float equi..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
API Spec 10F Specification on float equipment Washington DC June 2016
Results of Final Letter ballot 22 Ballots issued 14 affirmative 0 negative 0 abstention 8 did not vote Number Voting = 14 = 64% (must be > 50%) Approval Rate = 14/14 = 100% (must be > 66.7%)
Comments 18 Comments Received 9 Editorial 1 General 5 Technical All comments addressed Responses sent to work group members One comment required additional action
Comment resolution Editorial Comments (9) 4 Not Accepted USC units not presented for flow through volume (50 or 750 mL) USC units not presented for 0.5 gm calibration requirement 4 Accepted Spelling, Punctuation, Add a section on abbreviations, 1 referred to API (formatting)
Comment resolution General Comments (4) 2 Not Accepted Remove API Monogram from document 1 Required additional action from work group Add section on scaling 1 editorial – no USC units after 50 mL
Comment resolution Technical Comments (5) 2 Not Accepted Remove API Monogram from document 1 “Partially Accept” Changed wording of suggestion on verification timing 2 accepted Fix error in figures 1 – 3 Remove “shall” statement in scope (not allowed by API)
Verification timing Current wording: Float equipment shall be either tested or recertified a minimum of once every 5 years. Revision A Design and Development Review, Verification and Validation according to API Specification Q1 shall be conducted at least once every 5 years.
Verification timing A Design and Development Review, Verification and Validation according to API Specification Q1 shall be conducted at least once every 5 years. Validation requires physical testing according to Q1 a) Prototype tests, b) functional and/or operational tests of production products c) tests specified by industry standards and/or regulatory requirements; d) field performance tests and reviews. May move to Design and Development along with Verification but not Validation
Scaling of results (add a section) Little or no guidance found in other API documents Search was not exhaustive, but exhausting Working to resolve issue by developing a scaling section Requested input from pipe manufacturer
Forward plan Once all comments are resolved and final document will be sent to SC10 Chair for any action needed by Publications Task Group Recommended implementation date to be determined by work group and sent to Chair Send to API for final review, addition of table of contents, etc. and publication