Right to the city as an urban utopia ? - PowerPoint Presentation

Slide1

Right to the city as an urban utopia ?Urban Protests Against Neoliberal Urban Planning in Istanbul

Gülçin

ERDI LELANDAIS

CNRS

Research

Fellow

,

University

of Tours

Presentation of the Research

and the Methodology

Research undertaken between 2010-2012 Aim of the project : -Questioning the role of space and identity in resistances against public-planning -Studying the nature of urban planning and its effects on urban dwellers -Interrogating if these resistances give rise to the new forms of citizenship -Interrogating the links between the claims in the neighbourhoods and the « right to the city »

Colloque Engagements et tensions autour de la rénovation urbaine, 25-26 Janvier, Paris

Case StudiesSulukule

1

mayis

Colloque Engagements et tensions autour de la rénovation urbaine, 25-26 Janvier, Paris

Fieldwork : Sulukule and 1 Mayis Neighbourhoods in Istanbul

Sulukule

1 Mayis

Evolution of Urban Transformation in Turkey

from 2000Milestone in urban

policies : 2002 and AKP’s arrival Institutionalisation and consolidation of Neoliberal Urban RegimeMassive Destruction of Gecekondus and Struggle Against Illegal HousingEmergence of TOKI (Institution of Collective Housing) as a main political actor in urban policiesAKP practices neoliberal rules without concession;Progressive privatisation of housing sector

Following...Changing the structure of TOKI by law in 2003 : permission to build beneficial housing consortiums with private firms;

Right to conceive and to realise urban transformation projects for municipalities;

Several laws in order to consolidate neoliberal urban order (2004 : construction of a shantytown considered a crime, 2006 : Mortgage Law, 2003-2008 : Accession to property for foreigners).

Privatisation of public land properties;Decentralisation of industry in urban space;Worker / lower middle class housing in peripheral areas;

Targeting city centres for luxury constructions;

Growth of Construction Sector (CS) and gross national product (GNP) :2001 (economic crisis): CS -17,4 % ; GNP -5,7%2002 : CS 13,9% ; GNP 6,2%

Résistances against urban planning

Two main characteristics of these projects :

- profit priorities - authoritarian

- directed in poor, minority-concentrated neighbourhoodsThis situation provokes reaction in some neighbourhoodsEspecially minorities having the feeling to be denied and oppressed since the foundation of the republic are raised against these projects to protect their place of dwelling considered as the only place of expression of their ethnic and cultural identitySo the city becomes the space for new forms of expression and an insurgent citizenship emerging against established rules of political and societal system.

Reclaim the right to the city ?How to define

the right to the city ? - a concept which could not be

reduced to a right of housing -Henri Lefebvre (1968): a mode of being for all city residents. “The promotion of equal access for all to the potential benefits of the city, the democratic participation of all inhabitants by decision-making processes, and the realization of inhabitants’ fundamental rights and liberties”. - reworking the social construction of urban space -opposition to the conception of capitalist urbanization

Right to the city as a mobilization toolRight

to

the city as a slogan, an “agenda for the mobilization against neoliberalization” (Purcell 2008)Right to the

city as an unifying element for urban social movementsMultiplicity of perceptions of right to the cityRight to the city as an alternative urban project and conception against urban policies of the government

Perception of actorsTwo main understanding :against the exclusion from decision-making processes on the use of space, led by the exchange value, as the right to modify and shape their living spaces and the city, based on their ideas and needs.

against their spatial eviction and social expulsion from the “centre” of the city; they refuse to leave their central urban spaces for new social houses which will be built outside Istanbul

Çiğdem from Fener-Balat and Urban Movements: “The right to the city has a different meaning for me. But for the neighbourhood may be different. As Harvey said, it is the right to build our own city by building oneself, ourselves. In fact, we produce; build ourselves according to the amenities, possibilities around us. If in our city, these are not offered freely to me, but according to my money, to class, this means that obstacle and limits are set down upon me. In that sense, human being must have the right to say his opinion about how his/her living milieu is being shaped since this transformed city will shape him/her. If man/woman is shaped by shaping his/her city, is formed by forming it, he/she must participate in decision-making processes, to be asked about the formation of his/her city, he/she must be able to contribute in it, so in the formation of the right to the city, we must have the right of decision and to say our own words. It is a crucial right since this city at the same time will shape me.” (Interview made by

Basak

Ergin with Çiğdem, April 2012, Istanbul)

Erbatur from Solidarity Studio: “The right to the city is a revolutionary right, not a mere right of dwelling; right to access to centrality or to the urban services. It must be elaborated as related to the use-value of space with a democratic urban imagination. Urban struggle must aim the right to the city, targeting a more democratic, just city based on the use value.”(Interview made by

Basak

Ergin with Erbatur Çavuşoğlu, April 2012, Istanbul).

Whose right to the city and how ?An empty concept ?Develop an alternative

project

Finding the realisation mecanisms of right to the

cityRole of inhabitants and professional activists

THANK YOU !gulcin.lelandais@univ-tours.fr