PPT-Rebuttal I

Training 12102011 Warwick Debating Society Proudly sponsored by The basics What is rebuttal Rebuttal is responding to the arguments of the other side and explaining why they are wrong When you make an argument you are explaining why the audience should agree with your side but when you make rebuttal you are explaining why the audience should not agree with the arguments of the other side . Tetzel, Johann, 1460–1519Johann Tetzel’s rebuttal against Luther’s sermon on indulgences and grace / Translation and introduction by Dewey Weiss Kramer.32 p. cm.1. Luther, Martin, 1483& Response/Rebuttal Statement.candidatehas the right to submit a response or rebuttal statement in writing and/or request a meeting to discuss a reappointment, tenure, and/or promotion (RTP) recommenda 2meets specific category definitions. In particular, they are not able to block access to specific content transmitted via a non-HTTP protocol while simultaneously allowing access to other non-HTTP Eiji Hayashi. Human-Computer Interaction Institute. Carnegie Mellon University. Presented @ WISS 2012 Night Session. Dec. 6. th. , 2012. CC BY-NC-SA © 2012 Eiji Hayashi. Some rights reserved. . Additional Note. Training, . 12/10/2011. Warwick Debating Society. Proudly sponsored by. The basics. What is rebuttal? . Rebuttal is responding to the arguments of the other side, and explaining why they are wrong. When you make an argument you are explaining why the audience should agree with your side, but when you make rebuttal you are explaining why the audience should not agree with the arguments of the other side. . Project. Arguments on Energy . . . Mind Muse 2/14/13. a. Write your learning target. . b. Refute (argue . against. ) this counterclaim: . Many people believe Valentine’s Day is a silly holiday and shouldn’t be celebrated. . Method of Logic. Claim. Data. Warrant/Bridge. Backing/Foundation. Counterclaim. Rebuttal. Toulmin. Method of Logic. CLAIM. The overall THESIS the writer will argue for. Toulmin. Method of Logic. DATA. Sake…. Writing . Counter-arguments and Rebuttals. ENDURING UNDERSTANDING. 1. In . order to . write a convincing essay . you may need to . anticipate common opposing arguments. . that dispute your thesis. Basic Debate Workshop. Your Turn!. What comes to mind when you think of debate?. What is Debate?. A debate is a formalized argument. It provides a structure for different parties to exchange thoughts and discussion on an issue. . II. Training 23/11/2011. Warwick Debating Society. Proudly sponsored by. Things to note. 1. ) You can show why different areas of the other side’s argument is wrong; the explanation can be wrong (i.e. the argument’s justification does not make sense); the example can be wrong (i.e. it is either irrelevant or invalid); or the link can be wrong (it is irrelevant to the debate. Overview. Lincoln-Douglas Debate is . a  . VALUE. debate, meaning it is a debate about what . ought to be . rather than specific policy.  . It is usually a topic regarding the conflict . of rights or moral obligations. and Rebuttal. Purpose of an Opposing Claim. The purpose of an opposing/counter claim is to show the reader you have considered all sides of the question or issue. An opposing claim and rebuttal strengthen your essay by showing that you have looked at all sides and made an educated choice.. Breaking it Down.... What is the Counterclaim? . Counterclaim: The opposition’s argument. ALWAYS ATTACK THEIR STRONGEST POINT. What is a Rebuttal?. Rebuttal: Evidence used to contradict, counter, or refute the counterclaim.. House That Jack Built. Concession/Rebuttal. House that Jack built. (Causal Chain). Causal Chain. This elaboration strategy is referred to both as. “House that Jack Built” . AND a . “Causal Chain”..