Andrew R Meyer PhD Baylor University 2011 CSKLS Annual Meeting Journal of Sport and Social Issues for consideration Muscular Christianity allowed for a new and modern imagining of the role athletics and sport competition had within Christian theology ID: 565111
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document "LANCE ARMSTRONG: REFLECTIONS OF A MODERN..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
LANCE ARMSTRONG: REFLECTIONS OF A MODERN Muscular Christian
Andrew R. Meyer, PhD.Baylor University2011 CSKLS Annual MeetingJournal of Sport and Social Issues (for consideration)Slide2
Muscular Christianity allowed for a new and modern imagining of the role athletics and sport competition had within Christian theologySlide3
Christianity’s Connection with Sports
Early Protestants in the New World saw the body as an instrument of evil and sin. Believed in original sin. Only way to redeem ones soul
was to work and toil hard. Not used for sport or glory
Later sport is called forth to keep young men at elite private schools out of trouble with sexual desires and other immoral behaviors. Also the young men were being seen as unhealthy and we know there was a movement at the turn of the 20
th
century to include physical education to help the ailing results of the industrial revolution.
Connection between religion and Christianity was given a new name to validate the new ways of thinking about the body; Muscular ChristianitySlide4
Protestant Christian Beliefs and Sports
Contemporary Protestant Christian beliefs support the ideas that:The body is a tool to be used to establish mastery over the worldCompetition is a legitimate means for demonstrating individual achievement and moral worth
Sport participation could be used as a form of religious witness (
Coakley
, 2010)Slide5
Muscular Christianity
Term used to promote notions that sports participation encourages moral education as character building experience. The value of sports in education was its encouragement of youths to learn to cope with defeat, falling short, and losing, as most people experience in life.Sports ideals and lessons and their connection with the ideals and lessons of life were thought to have great benefit for the individual. What one learned on the field helped them off the field. The encouragement of competition was based “on the moral grounds that games were a preparation for the battle of life and that they trained moral qualities, mainly respect for others, patient endurance, unflagging courage, self-reliance, self-control, vigor, and decision of character.” (Freeman, 127)
Muscular Christianity made exercise, fitness and sport compatible with the Christian life. Combined the elements seen in sports with desired characteristics of Christianity that produced manliness, courage, patriotism, moral character, and team spiritSlide6
Muscular Christianity in text books
The term was first used by a reviewer of Tom Brown’s Schooldays (1857). It became applied to a doctrine about the positive moral influences of physical exercise and sport. (Cashmore 2005, 78)According to muscular Christianity, there was something innately good and godly about brute strength and power. Physical weakness was considered to be unnatural because it was a reflection of moral and spiritual weakness…an effort to overcome physical weakness could be seen as an effort to be Christian, moral and good. Sport activities came to be seen as an effort to be a good Christian. Also viewed the body as a temple which meant taking care of it and develop physical prowess. (
Mechikoff
&Estes 2006, 248)
Proponents of muscular Christianity claimed sport as essential for building character, leadership, competitiveness, courage, teamwork, and discipline…sport was a positive training for manhood. (Gems,
Borish
, &
Pfister
2008, 71)Slide7
Key figuresThomas Arnold
Head Master at Rugby (British Public School)Create in young boys a moral thinking, create Christian GentlemenMake every boy 1.) a Christian, 2.) a gentleman, 3.) an educated person (in that order)Did no overemphasize athletics but those who so valued athleticism used Arnolds religious and educational philosophy to promote such idealsSlide8
Thomas HughesThomas Hughes
Author and admirer of Dr. Arnold’s – Made Rugby School famous through his work Tom Brown’s Schooldays – citing it as the birthplace of manly Christianity and heroic athleticsConsidered games far more essential to moral development than did Arnold - sold the English-speaking world of the restorative powers of vigorous athletic competitionSocial stress and social change required young British upper-class boys to be “energetic and enthusiastic and executive; he must do things, he must do hard things, he must do heroic things.” (
Gulick
)
All under the notion of “fair-play” institutionalized in British athleticism
Muscular Christianity became synonymous with physical moralitySlide9
Charles Kingsley
Clergyman and authorWrote on the social issues of the time and preached a Christian moral earnestness within the frame of an athletic bodyIn published fairy tales for his children, we find the apotheosis of the strong, loving, reverent man—the doer of noble deeds. -Kingsley may have been the first to widely popularize the position that the greatness and scope of the British Empire came from its sporting youth – still reflected in Olympic competition todaySlide10
Muscular Christian Values
1861, “Hold it to be a good thing to have strong and well-exercise bodies… that a man’s body is given to him to be trained and brought into subjection, and then used for the protection of the weak, the
advancement of all righteous causes
,
and the subduing of the earth which God has given to the children of men
.”
Thomas Hughes,
Tom Brown at Oxford
(London: Macmillan, 1861), 83.
2004
Newsweek
article, presidential hopeful John Kerry was described as demonstrating a “gentleman’s code of muscular Christianity” reflecting traits such ideals as “
virtue of humility, the sin of pride, and the value of quiet service to others
.” Evan Thomas, “Fits and Starts”
Newsweek
(11/15/2004). <http://www.newsweek.com/id/56239>Slide11
To review the central themes
Manliness, courage, patriotism, moral character, and team spiritBrute strength and power – sin is associated with weaknessStrong well-exercised bodiesBody is given to be trained and brought into subjection
Used for the protection of the weak and advancement of righteous causes
Humility, sinfulness of pride, and quite service to othersSlide12
Armstrong is neither a Christian nor is he (to my knowledge) aware of that he is reflecting muscular Christian notions. His image is however caught up in the American sport context that is premised on these ideals.
My Research
Focused on exploring how American cyclist Lance Armstrong’s popular image involves several muscular Christian values from these classic authors
All of this is of course embedded in contemporary American sport ideologies, perpetuated through the media portrayal of athletes and sport.Slide13
LANCE ARMSTRONG
The man; the media image; the philanthropist…the muscular ChristianSlide14
Public Art
Shepard Fairey
Austin, TX AirportSlide15
Sports Illustraed Covers
Lance in other popular culture: On children’s program
Arthur
10/2009
2000
2002
2005
2006Slide16
John MacAloon
“Introduction: Muscular Christianity after 150 Years,” The International Journal of the History of Sport 23 (2006)He suggests the “ethos” of muscular Christianity’s “reflections and representations are all around us and so normalized (usually but not always under secular rubrics) that it fails to stand out as anything unusual.” (692).
“Many new developments – from… – ethic themes such as youth moral development, urban renewal and class peace through sport with the more historically American theme of immigrant integration and multiculturalism – all suggest a renewed significance and even a certain hidden dependency on muscular Christian ideology.” (690).
“In the United States, where, it can be argued, the ethos had even greater impact in building institutions of civil society than in Britain, the term muscular Christianity is not today widely familiar, even in scholarly circles. Those who know it as such tend to inhabit the marginalized fields of education, religion, and sport studies.” (690).Slide17
Armstrong Evidence Used
Books: One autobiography, and one biographyNews media – news outlets, magazines, online materialTelevision CommercialsYouTube Montage VideosAt the LiveStrong campaign of the Lance Armstrong Foundation (LAF)
Participation in charity events
Yellow BraceletsSlide18
Armstrong Texts2000
It’s Not About the BikeEstablishes his image as an exampleProvides advice on living, dying and thinking about each “So if there is a purpose to the suffering that is cancer, I think it must be this: it’s meant to improve us.” He then gives a prescription, for how someone should deal with cancer, “I think we are supposed to try to face it straightforwardly, armed with nothing but courage. The definition of courage is: the quality of spirit that enables one to encounter danger with firmness and without fear” (273).
2009
Lance: The Making of the World’s Greatest Champion
Interviews those who influenced Armstrong and those inspired by Armstrong
Argues Armstrong is a champion beyond because he excelled in an event so daunting, “so physically, mentally, and emotionally demanding it has even been called sadistic.” He references the perfection of Armstrong, that a “pure athlete can win the Tour, but to keep winning, year after year, demands a different kind of sporting perfection” (xi)Slide19
Commercial representation of Lance
Nike Commercial for Lance as cancer victim: Courage, manliness, determination http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWBTNPTAJTc&feature=related “My Body”: Strong well-exercised body http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MIl5RxhLZ5U
“Miracle Breath”: Savior?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXAleHsmgEg&feature=related
A Reason for living: Body given to be trained and brought into subjection
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cER-hTmLNf0&feature=related
Slide20
New media campaign by Livestrong
The Advancement of Righteous CausesIn these videos we see the advancement of righteous causes as well as humble service to others
Nike
Driven
“
It’s
about…”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ph6Gd2Cg4gc&feature=related
Wassner
sisters:
http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&videoid=59806372
Lance Mackey:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4itoaTozjg&feature=SeriesPlayList&p=60A95A6DB9FF442ESlide21
YouTube Honorary Montages
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vR4CQq4HMg snow patrolhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPS-ygfFWCM&feature=related requiem for dreamhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kif_S8wwRRs cold playThese video montages reflect new ways that digital sport fans are interacting with Armstrong’s image and creating virtual communitiesSlide22
The Philanthropist
Armstrong’s philanthropy is a clear example of his service and advancement of righteous causes.Cancer has defined his image: “I would rather have the title of cancer survivor than winner of the Tour…” (It’s Not about the Bike (2000) 259.)Developed Lance Armstrong Foundation
(LAF) while battling cancer
Spreading cancer awareness globally is Lance Armstrong’s goal through the LAF, and ONE of the reasons he un-retired.
Has developed successful “for cause”
Livestrong
events
A sign of faith 2004 – Yellow bracelets
Today over 80 million sold (4/2011)Slide23
The Sign of FaithSlide24
LiveStrong & “For cause” events
Many have taken Armstrong’s image and included it into their own lives, they have followed his example.One Facebook respondent “LiveStrong is to live thru cancer, and if possible, beyond. To grablife by the balls and live it to the full. To appreciate all that is good in life and not dwell on the bad stuff, as, as a survivor,
i
know
i
shoudn’t
be here.
Thats
what
LiveStrong
means to me (sic).”
LiveStrong
Challenge
http://www.livestrong.org/site/c.khLXK1PxHmF/b.5612027/k.7211/TEAM_LIVESTRONG__Home.htmSlide25
Conclusion
The power and popularity of sport in contemporary American culture suggests that sport, and the characters involved, can come to assume religious and spiritual meaning.Sports have become a social activity where millions of Americans look to find spirituality today because of the embedded religious values (muscular Christian) and involves many of the socializing elements of human communities.Sydnor, suggests that we can “envision sport as a cultural site that may have transformative sacramental qualities in which the effort and discipline of sport can be experienced as purification, sacrifice and
immolotion
.”
Bruce Forbes – “Notice that popular culture and traditional religion function in similar ways, providing meaning and helping people cope with life’s problems.’Slide26
B
ecause of the muscular Christian ideology at work in contemporary American sport (premised on Judeo-Christian values) characters such as Armstrong can operate as religious and spiritual figures in that they give meaning and purpose in peoples lives.While Lance Armstrong is the sport hero-icon I focused on in my reseaach, I argue that these themes could be applied to many in the American sport’s world
His case offers a clear example of the muscular Christian themes the American sport narrative is premised upon.
Kyle
Kusz
suggests Armstrong’s unique portrayal has taken the form of an “ideal embodiment of the human spirit.”
His victory over death
His continued athletic success
His philanthropic endeavors
Sydnor
“our studies and conclusions…we might boldly answer that the developed world’s obsession/fascination with…sport-related productions and representations is the result of individual and societal emptiness that is only fulfilled by God.”Slide27
Thank you for your time and attention!
Questions please?Andrew R. Meyer, PhD.Slide28
Cultural Shifts in Religion: Postmodern Evidence
Jon Meacham. “The End of Christian America,” {http://www.newsweek.com/id/192583}; “The percentage of self-identified Christians has fallen 10 points in the past two decades.”
The Associated Press. “More Americans say they have no religion: Study finds percentage of Christians in the nation has declined,”
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/29603915#29603915Slide29
If there is a cultural decline in traditional religious adherence…Slide30
Radical OrthodoxyDue to a shift in cultural mentality, radical orthodoxy claims that in post-modernity, individuals seek God, or the divine in and through common daily cultural activities. They seek to recover “what might be termed ‘theological
textuality’” (a recognition and description of a “divine reality” in theologically empty cultural texts. Graham Ward writes on the presence of God in the architecture of modern cities and other cultural products like film and literature in his book Cities of God (Radical Orthodoxy), 2000.“These thinkers point to the world not as a secularised
object of knowledge, but rather as a God-given mystery. They search for the God that the academy attempts to erase, and their scholarship is aimed as journeying toward a higher wisdom of God; God may be found at their epistemological and ontological
centres
.”
Sydnor
(2002), 26.Slide31
What to think about this decline with regard to radical orthodoxy
The power and popularity of sport in contemporary American culture suggests that sport, and the characters involved, can come to assume religious and spiritual meaning.Sports have become a social activity where millions of Americans look to find spirituality today because of the embedded religious values (muscular Christian) and involves many of the socializing elements of human communities.Sydnor, “radical orthodoxy leads one to envision sport as a cultural site that may have transformative sacramental qualities in which the effort and discipline of sport can be experienced as purification, sacrifice and
immolotion
.”
Bruce Forbes – “Notice that popular culture and traditional religion function in similar ways, providing meaning and helping people cope with life’s problems.’