Stuart Hall Policing the Crisis (1979) Explores the economic crisis in 1970s UK and issues surrounding immigration 1950s60s UK welcomed immigrants from the Commonwealth to fill essential,low-paid, semi-skilled jobs. By the 1970s
"Stuart Hall – Policing the Crisis (1979) Explores" is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to
download and print the materials on this website for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it
on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright
notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this
agreement.
Presentation Transcript
01
Stuart Hall – Policing the Crisis (1979) Explores the
economic crisis in
1970s UK and
issues
surrounding
immigration<br>
02
1950s/60s – UK welcomed immigrants from the Commonwealth – to fill essential,low-paid, semi-skilled jobs.
By the 1970s – unemployment increased in UK.
Black employees were first to lose jobs. Immigration and unemployment<br>
03
New jobs given to white applicants.
Black workers seen as ‘taking jobs’ and being blamed for the unemployment situation.
Now they were being accused of abusing the welfare benefits system!
A DOUBLE WHAMMY!<br>
04
Rising Racism in UK Black Britons were blamed for the rising economic problems and poverty (SCAPEGOATS).
Politicians like Enoch Powell began to make speeches against a multi-cultural Britain.
Right wing (neo-nazi) parties were on the increase, like the National Front (NF)<br>
05
The effects of structural racism Basically – many Black Britons were now being socially outcast as scapegoats
They were also facing poverty, due to unemployment (from losing jobs and struggling to get re-employed)
Some of the unemployed turned to crime to survive ( a rise in street crime/muggings/ dealing)<br>
06
In short…..
Black crime was being driven by economic strain/poverty and not a symbolic resistance!<br>
07
The Mugging Scare Hall applies the deviance amplification cycle to this issue.
Society defined a new type of crime ‘mugging’ (the media, police, judges and politicians) wanted this threat dealt with.
THE STREETS WERE NO LONGER SAFE!<br>
08
Mugging itself wasn’t a new phenomenon. In Victorian England there were ‘footpads’ who stole form people in the street.
Hall notes that this crime was re-marketed, with a new image
It fed into a moral panic – designed to help people address their fears and concerns about the crisis in society.<br>
09
Remember all those social problems and resistance Anti-Vietnam demos
Gay liberation
Women’s movement
Student protests
IRA threats
Trade Unions/Strikes<br>
10
Hall argues… In the early 1970s – a crisis of hegemony (influence or authority over others)
The working class were no longer in a state of false consciousness.
Capitalism needed to regain control.
The answer was to find a new way to regain order – to identify a scapegoat to blame.<br>
11
The scapegoat in the UK – were young Black Britons ( a folk devil)
The media stirred headlines that treated ‘black muggers’ as the threat to social order ( a moral panic)
Public wanted a solution (societal reaction)
Inner cities were flooded with extra ‘heavy handed police’<br>
12
Selective policing Aggressive – STOP AND SEARCH
Many arrests justified the policy.
The public felt more at ease that the social problems were being dealt with.<br>
13
So, overall… Moral panic and heavy policing were linked to the social and economic crisis in capitalism.
Black crime was happening because of poverty (and racism) caused by capitalism.
The process of selective policing and moral panic fed a deviance amplification spiral.<br>
14
Critique of Hall Downes (1988)
- Hall is contradictory – on the one hand they are doing more crime and on the other it’s the fault of the police and media.
- The link between moral panic and crisis in capitalism is weak.
