The Employer’s Guide to - PowerPoint Presentation

Slide1

The Employer’s Guide to Pregnancy Accommodation Laws

Slide2

OverviewFederal statutes requiring some form of pregnancy accommodationAmericans with Disabilities Act, as amended eff. 2009

Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978

Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993

State and local statutes

Slide3

The Americans with Disabilities Act and Pregnancy Accommodation

Slide4

Americans with Disabilities ActApplies to employers of 15 or more employeesSmaller employers may be covered by state anti-discrimination laws

Definition:

A disability is a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity.

Slide5

Amendment Changes EverythingThe ADA was amended effective in 2009. The amendment did not change the definition of “disability,” but it changed its interpretation.

Purpose of amendment:

To make it easier for employees with disabilities to be protected by the ADA

Three changes are key to pregnancy accommodation

Slide6

Old (pre-amendments): Very restrictive definition of disability; few conditions found to be disabilitiesNow

: Expansive definition of disability; many medical conditions qualify as disabilities

Slide7

First Change Stemming from Amendments: “Major Life Activity”

ADA now has non-exhaustive list of major life activities:

“caring for oneself, performing manual tasks, seeing, hearing, eating, sleeping, walking, standing, lifting, bending, speaking, breathing, learning, reading, concentrating, thinking, communicating, and working.”

EEOC added: sitting, reaching, and interacting with others

AND now “major life activity” includes major bodily functions

the immune system, normal cell growth, digestive, bowel, bladder, neurological, brain, respiratory, circulatory, endocrine, and reproductive functions

EEOC added: special sense organs, skin, genitourinary, cardiovascular, hemic, lymphatic, and musculoskeletal functions

Slide8

Second Change Stemming from Amendments: “Substantially Limits”Old: Courts held that employee’s ability to engage in a major life activity had to be severely impacted before the employee could be deemed to have a disability

New: “substantially limits” is not a demanding standard, does not require a severe restriction

means that the employee is limited in a major life activity as compared to the general population

Slide9

ExampleMaria is in her fifth month of pregnancy. She gets frequent migraines because of her pregnancy. Does she have a disability?

Old: Probably not.

Now: Probably yes. The migraines are an impairment, and they affect a major bodily function (neurological system, brain; also affects ability to concentrate) in a way that limits Gina as compared to the general population.

Slide10

Third Change: No Duration Requirement

Old: Disabilities that were short in duration (usually less than six months) were not considered within the ADA’s coverage

New: Temporary conditions may be disabilities

Duration is a factor, but not a bar

Exception: impairments that are

both

transitory and minor may not be disabilities

for “regarded as” ADA claims

(

not

relevant to accommodation claims)

Slide11

Application to PregnancyFirst Step: Is There a Disability?

Under both the old version of the ADA and the new amended version, pregnancy alone is not a disability.

However, now EEOC regulations recognize that a

pregnancy-related impairment

that substantially limits a major life activity is a disability. 29 C.F.R. § 1630.2(h).

Example: gestational diabetes

Slide12

Example: Pregnancy-Related ImpairmentPregnant employee cannot stand for eight hours because her feet are very swollen, which causes pain and numbness

Old: No disability

Now: Disability would likely be found

the ability to stand is a major life activity

(additionally, swelling involves the cardiovascular system)

she is limited compared to the general population in her ability to stand; temporary nature of impairment is no longer a bar

Slide13

Effect of AmendmentsShifted the focus from whether the employee has a disability to whether the employer has accommodated the employee

Example: Wanamaker v. Westport – teacher requested accommodation after injury in childbirth made it difficult for her to stand. She was allegedly terminated when the parties could not agree on an accommodation.

Initially, motion to dismiss ADA claim granted because she was not disabled

Amended complaint included allegations of impairment of major life activities of standing and walking

In summary judgment motion, employer conceded disability and focused on whether it had accommodated her

Slide14

Second Step: Duty to AccommodateEmployers have a duty to provide reasonable accommodations to employees with disabilities, unless to do so would create an undue hardship.

Failure to accommodate is disability discrimination under the ADA.

Slide15

Reasonable AccommodationModification of how, when , where employee works

Enables the employee to do the essential functions of her job

Employers do not have to remove or change essential functions (but can)

Does not have to be the accommodation the employee prefers

Employee is to be returned to original position once accommodation is no longer needed

Slide16

Procedure: TriggerThe employer’s duty to provide a reasonable accommodation is triggered by

Employee’s request

no special language needed

expression of difficulty or needing help is enough

-Obvious need for accommodation

Slide17

Procedure: Interactive ProcessRequest triggers duty to engage in “interactive process”

It’s an informal process

Employee describes what she is having difficulty doing

Employer and employee explore different options for making it possible for her to do her job

Back and forth direct communication is contemplated

Lack of information is not a defense unless employer attempts to get information and employee thwarts attempts

Slide18

Procedure: Medical InformationEmployers can ask for medical information necessary to determine whether the employee has a disability.

Request for information has to be limited to establishing the disability and the need for an accommodation.

Tip: JAN (Job Accommodation Network) has a sample medical information form:

http://askjan.org/media/medical.htm

Slide19

Third Step: Undue Hardship“An action requiring significant difficulty or expense,” considering

(1) the nature and cost of the accommodation needed;

The financial resources of the facility or facilities, or the impact otherwise of such accommodation upon the operation of the facility;

(3) employer’s finances, the number of its employees; the number, type and location of its facilities; and

the type of operation or operations of the employer

Impact on other employees.

Burden on the employer to prove, must complete cost/benefit analysis

Slide20

Types of Reasonable Accommodations

Bathroom breaks

Breaks for rest or water

An accessible worksite

A chair to sit on

Modification of equipment,

test,

or training materials, or policies

Time off for

medical

appointments

Job restructuring

Slide21

More Types of Reasonable Accommodations

Lifting restrictions

Most common request

Look for creative

solutions by focusing on essential function (

e.g

., function = moving boxes, so use cart or dolly)

Schedule changes

Helpful

to deal with morning sickness, fatigue

Slide22

More Types of Reasonable Accommodations

Light duty

- Do not have to create position

- Cannot limit it to workers comp/on the job injuries any longer (post-

Young v. UPS

)

Transfer

or reassignment

- Reasonable

if no other accommodations would allow her to work

-

Do

not have to create position or move employee already in position

- Employee has to have requisite skills

Slide23

More Types of Reasonable AccommodationsWork from home

Might not be required (fact specific inquiry about

job duties, whether others work from home, etc.)

Many employers allow it

Leave

Cannot force employee to take leave

Reasonable only if no other accommodation

Can be unpaid after exhaustion of accumulated paid leave

Lengthy or open-ended leave not reasonable

Slide24

Putting the ADA to Work: Is Accommodation Required for These Pregnant Workers?

Slide25

Meet GinaGina is experiencing swelling, which has caused carpal tunnel syndrome. She has asked for breaks from repetitive tasks that use her hands, and for breaks to use ice packs to reduce the swelling.

Her supervisor tells her to use her regular morning, lunch, and afternoon breaks, and denies her request to change her duties or extend her breaks.

Slide26

Does She Have a Disability?Carpal tunnel is a physical impairment that affects the major life activity of performing manual tasks May also limit lifting, reaching, cardiovascular system and musculoskeletal system

She is limited compared to people without CTS

Answer: Yes

Slide27

What about Accommodation?Gina wants to take breaks from repetitive tasks and have breaks to ice her wrists. Both are probably reasonable; employer could start by offering one accommodation and see if the second is necessary. Breaks can be unpaid.

Slide28

Meet JessicaJessica is experiencing severe morning sickness. She has already been hospitalized once for dehydration, and she still can’t eat. She told her supervisor that she feels too weak to work, but she has used up all of her sick days.

Her supervisor warned her that, under the attendance policy, she will be fired if she misses more time.

Slide29

Does She Have a Disability?Severe morning sickness affects eating, concentration, and other major life activitiesIt also affects the gastrointestinal system.

Note that casual morning sickness may not be a disability (question is whether it is limiting as compared to the rest of the population)

Answer: Yes

Slide30

What about Accommodation?Jessica told her supervisor she felt too weak to work, which was a request for an accommodation and the employer should have started the interactive process.

Allowing her to miss work (leave) may be a reasonable accommodation, but the employer should first see if there is another accommodation (schedule change, naps during the day) that would allow her to work.

She may also be eligible for FMLA leave.

Slide31

Meet JuliaJulia is five months pregnant with a high risk pregnancy.

She needs assistance lifting patients.

Her supervisor denies her assistance and tells her she has to take FMLA leave if she can’t do her job.

Slide32

Does She Have a Disability?High risk pregnancy affects the reproductive system

She is limited compared to the rest of the population

Answer: Yes

Slide33

What about Accommodation?Julia asked for lifting assistance. The supervisor should discuss alternatives with her (assistive devises, co-worker help, light duty).

Forcing her out on FMLA leave is asking for a lawsuit unless there are no other options.

Note that if she exhausts her FMLA leave while she is still disabled, she cannot be fired because leave with a set end date may be a

reasonable accommodation.

Slide34

The Pregnancy Discrimination Act and Pregnancy Accommodation

Slide35

Pregnancy Discrimination ActApplies to employers of 15 or more

First Clause: Unlawful “sex” discrimination under Title VII includes discrimination based on pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions

Second Clause: Requires employers to treat pregnant employees the same as other employees who are similar in their ability or inability to work

Can treat pregnant employees better, just can’t treat them worse

Slide36

PDA in ActionEmployers cannot refuse to hire an applicant because she is pregnant or because she is going to need to take maternity leave

Employers cannot fire an employee because she is pregnant or will need to take a leave, or because customers will object to her appearance

Employers cannot apply workplace rules more harshly to pregnant employees to make them quit or to justify terminating them or to punish them for getting pregnant

Slide37

Accommodating Pregnant Employees:Young v. UPS (U.S. Supreme Court, 2015)

Pregnant UPS driver had lifting restrictions. UPS had policy of accommodating employees with on the job injuries and other employees, but not pregnant employees.

Supreme Court: Plaintiffs can proceed with their lawsuits if they show that pregnant women are burdened by an employer policy that does not accommodate pregnant women and the employer’s reasons for the policy are weak.

Cost and convenience are

not

acceptable reasons for not accommodating.

Slide38

Lessons from YoungEmployers that provide accommodations to nonpregnant employees are required to provide similar accommodations to pregnant employees who have similar limitations on their ability to work, unless the employer has a

strong

,

legitimate, and nondiscriminatory reason for treating the nonpregnant employees differently. 

Employer’s reason must be sufficiently strong to justify any significant burden on pregnant women.

Policies

limiting light duty to

on the

job injuries are

likely not

going to pass muster.

Slide39

Putting the PDA to WorkSandra is fatigued because of her pregnancy. She has trouble arriving to work on time because she frequently oversleeps. She asked to adjust her hours so she can come in later and leave later, but her supervisor said no and disciplined her.

Sandra complains to HR, noting that the company has a flexible work policy and plenty of other people work flexible hours. She also notes that others who come to work late are not disciplined.

Is this discrimination?

Slide40

Putting the PDA to Work (cont.)Answer: Probably yes.Sandra’s employer has a flexible work policy and allows others to work flexibly, so it would have to have a strong, legitimate, non-discriminatory reason for not allowing her to flex her hours.

Disciplining Sandra for coming in late when others come in late and are not disciplined may be discriminatory if the others and Sandra are similarly situated. Note that after the

Young

decision, they do not have to be similar in all respects.

Slide41

The Family and Medical Leave Act and Pregnancy Accommodation

Slide42

Family and Medical Leave ActApplies to employers with 50 or more employees

Employees are eligible if

They work at a location with more than 50 employees in a 75 mile radius

They have been employed by employer for 12 months (need not be consecutive)

They have worked at least 1250 hours in the prior year

They have not already exhausted their FMLA time for the prior year

Slide43

Family and Medical Leave Act The FMLA allows pregnant women to take time off for:

Prenatal visits

pregnancy-related conditions (including morning sickness)

childbirth/recovery/bonding

Leave is limited to a total of 12 weeks per year.

Intermittent leave may be taken

Prenatal use reduces post-childbirth maternity leave.

Slide44

The FMLA (cont.)Employees cannot be retaliated against for requesting or taking leaveEmployees who take leave under the FMLA have to be reinstated to their same jobs or substantially equivalent jobs

Employees must give at least 30 days’ notice of need for leave, unless not possible (unforeseen)

Slide45

The FMLA: Medical CertificationEmployers can request medical certification

Permitted, not required

For bonding time: can request documentation of birth or adoption

Employers cannot ask for doctor’s note when she announces

pregnancy

Have to treat pregnant employees the same as non-pregnant employees (PDA)

Employers cannot ask for note clearing her to return unless ask of all returning employees

Slide46

More about the FMLADC and California allow “leave stacking” – pregnant employees can use FMLA medical leave for their pregnancy-related illnesses and still have their full state law family leave for baby bonding

If an employee cannot return at the end of leave for physical or mental conditions that are disabilities, the ADA may require additional leave as a reasonable accommodation

Slide47

State Laws and Pregnancy Accommodation

Slide48

States With Pregnancy Accommodation Laws

Alaska

California

Connecticut

Delaware

Hawaii

Illinois

Iowa

Louisiana

Maryland

Minnesota

Nebraska

North Dakota

New Jersey

Rhode Island

Texas

West Virginia

Slide49

Local Jurisdictions with Pregnancy Accommodation Laws

New York City

Philadelphia

Providence, RI/Central Falls, RI

Washington, DC

Slide50

Example: California

It's illegal in California for an employer to refuse to provide reasonable accommodations to an employee for a condition related to pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions.

Californians can also receive a transfer to a less strenuous or hazardous position, if the request is reasonable.

Cal.

Gov

’

t Code §§ 12945(a)(3)(A); (a)(3)(C).

50

Slide51

Example: Connecticut Employers have to try to transfer pregnant employees if their current position puts the employee or fetus at risk of injury.

Conn. Gen. Stat. § 46a-60(a)(7)

Slide52

Example: PhiladelphiaIn 2014, Philadelphia passed an ordinance that requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations to employees for needs related to pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition, so long as such accommodations will not cause an undue hardship to the employer. 

Phila

. Code § 9-1128.