September 2017 2014 Trinity Health Livonia MI 2 Overview for today Background on PRISM PRISM bundles risk based interventions Impact of PRISM bundles Where are we going with all this Recap todays challenges ID: 776078
Download Presentation The PPT/PDF document " PRISM Understanding risk and aligning r..." is the property of its rightful owner. Permission is granted to download and print the materials on this web site for personal, non-commercial use only, and to display it on your personal computer provided you do not modify the materials and that you retain all copyright notices contained in the materials. By downloading content from our website, you accept the terms of this agreement.
Slide1
PRISMUnderstanding risk and aligning resources to improve outcomes
September 2017
Slide2©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
2
Overview for today
Background on PRISM
PRISM bundles: risk based interventions
Impact of PRISM bundles
Where are we going with all this?
Slide3Recap – today’s challenges
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
3
Health care is complex, fragmented, expensive
Hand-offs, communication failures
Inpatient: Change in units, shifts, rotations
Across sites of care: outpatient, inpatient,
SNF
Discharge summaries, referral letters
Mass General survey – 59%
housestaff
reported patient harm due to suboptimal handoffs
(
Kitch
Jt
Comm
J
Qual
Pat
Saf
2008)
Only modest level of agreement of the patient’s clinical risk between check-out physicians and incoming physicians
Kappa .19 - .44 (
Brannen
J Patient Safety 2009)
ICC .42 - .51 (
Ratelle
J Gen Intern Med 2014
)
HCAHPS doctor communication
scores worse for high risk
patients
Failure to recognize, rescue
Delays, gaps in care
Clinician alert fatigue
Slide4Recap – today’s challenges
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
4
Imbalance between needs and type of care provided for patients with multiple, chronic conditions
C
linical practice guidelines may conflict with each or not pertain to patients with multiple conditions
(Boyd JAMA 2005,
Lugtenberg
PLoS
One 2011)
Patients admitted for one condition often readmitted for a different condition
(Jencks NEJM 2009)
25 – 33% patients die with pain, shortness of breath, emotional needs
(
Teno
JAMA 2004)
C
ancer screening performed for 31 – 55% of those at high risk of dying
(Royce JAMA
Int
Med 2014)
ICU ventilator use for advanced dementia patients doubled from 2000 – 2013
(
Teno
2016)
Health care resources are finite
Nurses, hospitalists, ICU beds, transition coaches, time for patient teaching (inhaler technique – 2 minutes versus 6 minutes for teach back
Press J Gen
Int
Med 2012
)
Slide5Look to make complex simple
Look for patterns
Look for common denominator
Slide6©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
6
Pareto Principal:30 % of patients > 80% deaths > 40% readmissions
PRISM 1 and 2 patients will likely need more than “usual care”
Slide7PRISM is a counter influence
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
7
Simple
construct – pay extra attention to high risk subgroup
Pareto principle – small proportion of patients (inpatients AND outpatients) have disproportionate number of adverse events
High risk patients need higher nursing staffing levels
High risk patients may have golden hour - physicians
should see
early and often
High risk patients have needs anticipated by other team members (
eg
. Rapid response team, nutrition, pharmacy, palliative care,
etc
)
Understand
explicit
risk of dying – Which goals are most important to the patient right now?
(Fried Arch
Int
Med 2011,
Tinetti
JAMA Cardiology April 2016)
aggressive life-saving efforts right now
?
Living longer at all costs?
Time spent living independently?
Control bothersome symptoms (pain, SOB, anxiety, depression) irrespective of survival time?
Use remaining time to repair personal relationships?
Creates
common
clinical language for hand-offs and communication
Knowing a patient is PRISM 1 provides an immediate array of information
Framework transportable to home care and local SNFs to initiate risk-based interventions
Outpatient version - No
longer “inpatient silo” versus “outpatient silo”
Slide8©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
8
What is PRISM?
Prediction rule that generates a probability of a patient’s risk of dying (mortality risk) within the first 30 days of admission based on information known at the time of admissionProbabilities are distilled into a single score ranging 1-5PRISM 1 – Highest Risk PRISM 5 – Lowest RiskInforms initial placement into the appropriate nursing unit, timeliness of initiating treatment, surveillance and response activities of the clinical team, and transitions of care
AROC
30-day
mortality (0.88)
180-day mortality (0.89)
Palliative status (0.89)
Unplanned Transfer (0.74)
30-day readmission (0.69)
Slide9©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
9
PRISM Risk Factors
Provided by Clinician
Current or past history of: Cognitive Defect Other Neurological Atrial Fibrillation Cancer Metastatic Cancer LeukemiaCurrently have: Respiratory failure Injury Heart Failure Sepsis Medical vs Surgical Admission
Obtained Electronically
Age
Gender
BUN
WBC
Platelet Count
Lactate
Hemoglobin
Albumin
Arterial pH
Arterial pO2
Troponin
Hospitalized at SJMHS within past year
Emergent
Admission
Slide10©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
10
PRISM Inputs
Slide1130-day Outcomes by PRISM StrataSJMAA Adult Inpatients, CY2015
11
Slide12©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
12
Need to institute treatment early
Need to institute life-saving measures quickly
Need to account for persistent
level of risk after discharge
Slide13Disposition and PRISM:Informs Work of Case Managers, Social Workers
Slide14©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
14
PRISM 1 patients sent
home experience a similarlevel of events as their counterparts in SNF, home care
Slide15©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
15
15
PRISM 1 and 2 patients provide lower scores for Doctor Communication and Staff Responsiveness (adjusted for age, gender, language, self-reported health, educational level and service)
15
Journal of Hospital Medicine,
September 2016
More Favorable Responses
Less
Favorable
Slide16Look for common patterns in our daily work
Some root causes (To Err Is Human):Delay in diagnosis, treatmentFailure to respondFailure to preventFailure of communication
Some remedies:Care within “Golden hour”Nurse staffingTeam workCommunicationStandard work
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
16
Slide17PRISM Across the Continuum: Standardized Process & ExpectationsIdentify Vital Few Items to Customize Level of Intensity, andSupport Appropriate for Risk Level
Assign PRISM Score and Pre-Admit Work
Identify Appropriate setting for care, Initiate Care and Bundles
Transition & Discharge
Post DischargeFollow up
PRISM Score 1PRISM Score 2PRISM Score 3PRISM Score 4/5
Placement
& Admission
Admit & Placement Guidelines include risk and acuityPrioritize order entry and initiation for high risk patientsHeightened vigilance for high risk patients in first 24 hrs
Progressing Care
Early Screening of high risk patients for Case Management, Palliative Care and Nutrition
Addressing Advance Directive and Goals of Care proactively for high risk patientsAppropriate frequency of nursing assessments for low risk pts
Reducing
MortalityReducing Complication Improving Evidence Based Care and Patient ExperienceReducing Readmissions, ED Utilization
Discharge & Transition
Scheduling of follow up appointments for high risk patientsDifferentiated Handoffs by risk/complexity levelStandardized, Minimum Home Care support for high risk patientsDischarge med rec, education/support
Copyright©Saint Joseph Mercy Health System,
Ann Arbor Michigan
Slide18©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
18
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
18
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
18
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
18
Example how concurrent processes of care can be launched (PRISM 1 Acute Care Bundle)
18
Slide19PRISM Bundle: Interventions for Care Coordination and Transitions
PRISM Score
Select Interventions
PRISM 1
Palliative Care Consult for goals of care and symptom management
Verbal IP to PCP provider handoff attempted
Discharges
to Home include Home Care at minimum
HomeCare
Bundle
inplace
, includes first visit within 24-36
hrs
Discharges to ECF targeted
to occur prior to 1pm
ECF Bundle, includes all assessment completed within 24-36
hrs
and
HomeCare
and PCP appointment when d/c from ECF
PRISM 1 & 2
Pharmacy provides medication review and counseling (while admitted or with post discharge phone call)
PRISM 1, 2 & 3
Schedule follow-up appointment for within 3 - 7 days after discharge to home/homecare (PRISM 1 & 2 attempt closer to 3 days)
Slide20©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
20
Primary
Bundle Elements - Assessment for Regional Standardization in Progress July 2017
Slide21©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
21
PRISM 1 Patients:
Higher nursing staffing levels (not GMB)
Start treatment quickly (“golden hour”)
Respond quickly, bedside evaluation if new symptoms because mortality risk increases greatly
Include PRISM score with handoffs
Palliative Consult – goals of care, symptom control
Home care (if PRISM 1, non-SNF)
Attempt communication with PCP (or SNF doc) at discharge
Slide22Post Hospital
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
22
Slide23©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
23
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
23
PRISM 1 ECF Bundle (Each team member plays a role)regional collaborative
23
Working on expanding to include interventions for PRISM 2 & #
Slide24©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
24
PRISM 1 Home Care Bundle: Ann Arbor Example
24
Slide25©2017 Trinity Health
25
Process Metrics
and Outcomes
Slide26©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
26
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
26
30 Day Mortality Actual # Deaths / Expected # Deaths
Slide27©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
27
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
27
30 Day Readmissions (Actual / Expected). Reflects statistically significant decreases in
Pneumonia, most Medical Discharges, however, trends for HF, COPD, AMI, Stroke, Surgery were non-significant with this particular risk-adjustment method
Slide28Slide2975th percentile - Time from order placement to Nurse Review (hours)
Numerator
Denominator
Time from diet order placement by physician to RN review (
dietorderrnreview_hr
) - 75th percentile (in hours)
Scored in ED
Slide3030
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
30
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
30
Associations with Early Assessment and Inpatient Care Orders*
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
30
Length of Stay
PRISM 1: (vte advisor) Shorter average LOS by 0.37 days (p = .003)PRISM 2: (vte advisor) Shorter average LOS by 0.16 days (p = .01)30 day mortalityPRISM 1: 18% fewer deaths (vte advisor or diet order), p = .03PRISM 2 : 13% fewer deaths (vte advisor or diet order), p =.07CHF patients 30 day mortality borderline lower (vte or diet order) 19.8% versus 31.7% (p = .05)Severe infections (sepsis) 30 day mortality lower (vte or diet order) 39.1% versus 47.0% (p = .0498)Unplanned transfers to ICU in first 24 hoursPRISM 1: 46% fewer unplanned transfers if diet order or vte advisor completed within 75 minutes (p = .03)Top 3 clinical conditions having unplanned transfer regardless of PRISM score: Serious infection (33% of transfers), Pneumonia (9.8% transfers), Alcohol-related (6.1%)
…mortalitysite 8/1/13 – 3/31/16
*As measured by launching VTE advisor (or diet order if noted) within 75 minutes of floor arrival in non-surgical cases (cannot determine causal relationships)
Slide31Nutrition Screen for PRISM 1, non-ICU
Discharge MonthMeasure201611201612201701201702Target Pop: PRISM 1, admit unit Not ICU86959397Any Intervention Criteria Met - Count69747077Any Intervention Criteria Met - % Target Pop80%78%75%79%Individual Intervention Criteria - Count:Nutrition Consult Order entered w/i 48 20202019Nutrition Note entered w/I 48 hrs63686269Review in TeamFlow w/I 48 hrs24192730
Prospective PRISM scored,
disch
as IP or TC
Slide32PRISM Bundle and HCAHPS Dashboard for Prospective PRISM Scores
PRISM 1PRISM 2PRISM 3PRISM 1 &PRISM 2
Slide33PRISM 1 Follow Up Appointments Kept (IHA)
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
33
Slide34Current state
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
34
All 5 SE Michigan Trinity hospitals + Grand Rapids St. Mary are generating inpatient scores (see next slides for details)
CNOs working across the region to standardize PRISM-related care bundles
Outpatient PRISM scores generated and delivered to IHA practices monthly (more detail at a later time)
“Check-in PRISM
” launched. Before the ED evaluation takes place, an initial PRISM score is calculated at the time of ED registration
[NEW] There is now a separate prediction rule in place in all EDs to identify patients at high risk for repeated future ED visits
Slide35[NEW] Prediction Rule to Identify Those at Risk for Frequent ED utilization
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
35
Prediction rule for determining patients likely to return to the ED 2 or more times in the 30 – 120 days following the index visit developed
Allows 30 days for interventions to be put in place
3 Risk Categories (high, medium, low) for returning to the ED
Implemented
in 6 Trinity Hospital Emergency
Departments
Scores visible in the ED PRISM web application
No standard bundles yet
Permits
control charts to
evaluate effectiveness of
interventions (observed / expected)
Slide36Other new uses of inpatient PRISM scores
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
36
Ann Arbor Pastoral Care visiting PRISM 1 patients in the Emergency Department
Working on a patient pathway for PRISM 1 patients
Slide37Your Care Path starts as soon as you arrive at St. Joe’s and continues beyond….
When you arrive to your in-patient roomDuring your stayDuring your stayAs you prepare to leaveThe nursing team will greet you when you arrive in your room and will make you comfortable. They will assess your immediate needs. Your Hospitalist doctor will see you within 1 hour and develop with you the right treatment plan to get you better. The nursing team will make sure the tests, medications and plan are carried out and will inform you and your family of next steps.Your “My Important Papers” folder is where all your new information will be kept. Your team will review the material often with you.Good nutrition is important for healing, so healthy meals and snacks will be provided.We begin planning for your discharge from the hospital the day after you are admitted since a safe transition takes time to put into place. The Care Coordination Team will work with you and any family to determine the type of support you will need once you leave the hospital.Sitting in your bedside chair and walking a few times a day are important steps to get you better. We will always assist each time to keep you safe.Nursing team will check on you every hour. Your doctors will see you once or twice a day and review your care plan with you.Sometimes it can be difficult to manage troubling symptoms, like pain or fatigue; while at home and in the hospital. Our Palliative Care staff are part of the team that help you learn how to better cope with your illness and its impact on your daily life.Your active participation in all discussions and decisions are so important. We will help you make the plan that is right for you, and respect your wishes.Other physician consultants and therapists might also be involved in your care, but your Hospitalist is the one in charge. Ask any one of your healthcare team when you have questions or need help. Your care team will ensure you have the support necessary for a safe transition from the hospital:We will help you schedule a follow up appointment with your own doctor, if you are going home.Your hospital physician will update your primary care physician with a summary of your hospital stay.If you have a family member or support person, it is best to include them in all of your health teaching ,or as often as they can visit you while you are at St. Joe’s, since sometimes it is hard to remember once you get home.
Skilled Nursing FacilityOur goal is to have you transferred earlier in the day and once your arrive, you will be seen by the nurse within 1 hour.The physician as well as members of the social work, therapy and nutrition teams will meet to discuss your plan of care by the second day.When you are ready to go home, your skilled nursing facility team will :Schedule a follow up appointment with your Primary Care physicianPlan for Home Care to follow up with you after you leave
HomeTalk with your team about what to expect when you go homeA nurse or pharmacist will review your medications with you before you leave the hospital. When arrive home, a Home Care nurse will call to schedule a home visit2 – 3 days after discharge, a pharmacist will call you to answer any question you may have about your medications.
Patient Pathway Draft (
pg
1)
Slide38Your Care Path: After the Hospital
What to Expect if you are going Home In the HospitalWe will help you schedule follow-up appointmentsA nurse or pharmacist will review your medications with you beforeAt HomeHome Care nurse will call to schedule a home visitA Pharmacist will call you 2-3 days after discharge to answer any question you may have about your medications.
Before I Leave the HospitalDo I:Understand the purpose and the common side effects of my medicationsHave all the medications I needHave all the equipment I needFeel comfortable getting up and moving aroundWhat else do I need to know or learn What other questions do I have?
What to Expect if you are going to a Skilled Nursing FacilityIn the HospitalOur goal is to have you transferred earlier in the dayWhen you arrive at the FacilityA nurse will see you within 1 hourThe physician as well as members of the social work, therapy and nutrition teams will meet to discuss your plan of care by the second dayWhen you are ready to go home, your skilled nursing facility team will :Schedule a follow up appointment with your Primary Care physicianPlan for Home Care to follow up with you after you leave
Patient Pathway Draft (
pg
2)
Slide39If your patient asks about PRISM
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
39
http://infonet.trinity-health.org/clinical/prism/docs/Infosheet_Talking_about_PRISM_with_Patients.pdf
Slide40We are Building Coordinated, Risk-based Care Across the Continuum
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
40
Slide41©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
41
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
41
©2014 Trinity Health - Livonia, MI
41
Our Vision:
Every patient will get timely, anticipatory, appropriate care based on the level of risk/need
Every patient will received better-coordinated care wherever they
are (home, physician office, hospital, emergency department, skilled nursing facility or
other) because all care providers communicate the level of risk (“handoffs”) using the same language
Every patient in our population will have a PRISM
score
Slide4242
©2017 Trinity Health
QUESTIONS