The Little Misunderstood Mental Health Effects of Racial Tr - PowerPoint Presentation

Slide1

The Little Misunderstood Mental Health Effects of Racial Trauma

Presented by:

MHTF Diversity Sub-committee

July 11, 2017Slide2

Introduction to Racial Trauma

On Sunday, police officers in Seattle shot and killed

Charleena

Lyles in her home. She died in front of “several children”, according to reports and her family members say she was pregnant. Just days before

Jeronimo

Yanez, the Minnesota police officer who shot and killed

Philando

Castille

during a traffic stop was acquitted of all charges. Earlier this spring, an unarmed teenager named Jordan Edwards was shot and killed by police as he was driving away from a party. By now, it’s become a sickeningly familiar sequence of events

. While the trigger (both literally and metaphorically) is the same, there is an aspect of these events that is frequently overlooked: the effects of the frequent police killings on black Americans’ mental health in the form of racial trauma, a psychological phenomenon that some experts say is similar to post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Slide3

What is Racial Trauma?

Racial trauma is

mental health symptoms of individuals who have encounters with law enforcement, those who witness these events directly or indirectly may also be impacted negatively. In an attempt to capture how racism and discrimination negatively impacts the physical and mental health of people of color, many scholars have coined the term “racial trauma” or race-based traumatic stress. Racial trauma may result from racial harassment, witnessing racial violence, or experiencing institutional

racism

(Bryant-Davis, &

Ocampo

, 2006; Comas-

Díaz

, 2016).

Racial trauma

psychological

symptoms such as

anxiety, depression, hypervigilance

to threat

, low self-esteem, feelings of humiliation, poor concentration, irritability,

or lack of hopefulness for your future as a result of repeated exposure to racism or discrimination” Erlanger

A. Turner, PhDSlide4

Carlson

(1997)

also

points to secondary responses to trauma.

Secondary and Associated Responses:

•

Depression• Aggression• Low Self-Esteem• Identity Crisis• Problems with Interpersonal Relationships• Guilt and Shame

Symptoms of Racial TraumaCarlson 1997

ModeRe-experiencingAvoidance CognitiveIntrusive ThoughtsIntrusive Images  Amnesia of TraumaDerealization/Depersonalization AffectiveAnxietyAnger Emotional NumbingIsolation Affect BehavioralIncreased ActivityAggression Avoidance of Trauma RelatedSituations PhysiologicalPhysiological Reactivity toTrauma Reminders Sensory Numbing Multiple ModesFlashbacksNightmares Complex Activities inDissociated States Slide5

Avoidance

:

Avoidance is a defense that assists an individual to minimize

feelings that

cause discomfort and trigger negative modalities

.

Identity: Trauma victims are known to adopt the identity of the victimizer. Forexample, victims of molestation have been known to develop into perpetrators themselves. Male children that witnessed domestic abuse are at a high risk in becoming abusers. This behavior has been observed in-present day Black police officers, bank officials, administrators, etc. Black people have been taught to hate themselves and anything associated. This is why it is easy for a Black person to kill someone that looks like him or herInterpersonal Relationships: Interpersonal relationships are impaired throughidentity issues and self-hatred. It is difficult for an individual to love someone ifhe or she doesn’t know how to love him or herself.Many argue that the separation of the family was continued through the welfare system and mass incarceration.Slide6

Emotional Numbing:

The Black male slave was forced to watch his

offspring brutalized

, disrespected, and sold. Black male slaves were used for breeding

purposes and were not allowed to form an attachment to their offspring

– when they

did, it was usually short lived. Today, it is well known that Black males still have difficulty emotionally connecting to their children and to Black women.Isolation of Affect: Negro clinicians are taught that showing affection is goingagainst the grain of the European style of psychiatric discipline. As a result these clinicians have a reputation of not having the ability to relate to their clients, they are in fear that they may not meet their bosses approval with diagnoses.Anger: Black People have demonstrated their anger more commonly by reacting to difficult incidents with acts of violence or destruction rather than legal action. Normally, when a mass demonstration of anger is triggered by an event it unleashes accumulated aggression.Slide7

The 1999, Department of Education Federal Register defines the context of the

term:

"Emotionally

Disturbed" in the following manner:

An

inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or

health factors.An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationshipswith peers and teachers. Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated withpersonal or school problems. The term includes schizophrenia.The term does not apply to children, who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have an emotional disturbance.Slide8

AGGRESSION

E

ncompasses

behavior, such as yelling or physical violence, that comes about as a result of feelings of anger. When you are angry, you will often take your anger out on the person causing it. But sometimes you are not able to express your anger directly to the person who is causing it. And if you are unable to resolve your anger, it may become displaced, meaning that it is directed towards something or someone else that has nothing to do with the original conflict.

DISPLACED AGGRESSION

Is

aggressive behavior that cannot be expressed to the actual source that provoked the behavior; instead the anger is taken out on the easiest victim. In the example of Tom, he cannot take his aggression to the source of his anger, his supervisor, due to the possibility of getting fired if he does. Instead, he takes out his anger and dissatisfaction with the way things are going at work, on the easiest victims, his wife and kids. After all, his wife and kids usually forgive him. Slide9

Coping with Racial trauma

Affirmation and acknowledgement

Create space for race

Racial storytelling

Validation

The process of naming

Externalize devaluationRechanneling RageSlide10

References

Meadows-Fernandez

, R. (2017). The Little Misunderstood Mental-Health Effects of Racial Trauma. Science of Us, 1-3.

Mims, S.,

Higgenbottom

, L., & Reid, O. (

n.d.). Post Traumatic Slave Disorder. Pyramid Builders, Inc., 1-90.Turner, E. A., & Richardson, J. (2016, July 14). Racial Trauma is Real: The Impact of Police Shootings on African Americans. Retrieved from American Psychological Association: Psychology Benefits: https://psychologybenefits.org/2016/07/14/racial-trauma-police-shootings-on-african-americans/